Kelly Clarkson vs Leona Lewis

[Denver]

Kelly has long been seen as the poster girl for the Idol franchise while Leona is the biggest success story of the X Factor franchise.

But which one is the better one?

[Marsh.]

The one with a career and more than one hit single... Ms Clarkson.

[Ross.]

Kelly didn't release the greatest song of all time Bleeding Love

[MB.]

Kelly outsold!

[Saph]

both alright but Kelly has some good songs (before 2009)

[DouglasS]

One Direction are the biggest success story of the X Factor

[RileyH]

I love Leona but Kelly queen >>>

[Denver]

One Direction are the biggest success story of the X Factor

They are not though

[montblanc]

i like leona more

[Marsh.]

They are not though

Erm, they are though.

They're vastly more successful than Leona has ever been.

[JerseyWins]

Kelly didn't release the greatest song of all time Bleeding Love
This

I like Kelly Clarkson a lot but Leona Lewis has a few songs that are >>>>>>>

[RileyH]

Behind These Hazel Eyes >>> anything by Leona

[JerseyWins]

Behind These Hazel Eyes >>> anything by Leona
That is a bop but Bleeding Love >>>

http://images4.fanpop.com/image/photos/15100000/BB12-gifs-big-brother-15161064-300-225.gif

[RileyH]

Let's not act as if Forgive Me isn't Leona's best

[montblanc]

That is a bop but Bleeding Love >>>

http://images4.fanpop.com/image/photos/15100000/BB12-gifs-big-brother-15161064-300-225.gif

http://images4.fanpop.com/image/photos/15100000/BB12-gifs-big-brother-15161064-300-225.gif

[Denver]

Piece by Piece is a masterpiece

[Smithy]

Kelly there’s no competion lol, outsang, outsold, outtoured

Leona has one good song and even then it’s dated, Kelly has numerous and Since U Been Gone still goes AWF

[Shaun]

Kelly didn't release the greatest song of all time Bleeding Love

She did release the greatest song of all time Since U Been Gone, and the second greatest song of all time My Life Would Suck Without You, though.

[Marsh.]

Kelly there’s no competion lol, outsang, outsold, outtoured

Leona has one good song and even then it’s dated, Kelly has numerous and Since U Been Gone still goes AWF

Queen! :clap1:

[LukeB]

Kelly didn't release the greatest song of all time Bleeding Love

Tea

Leona did A Moment Like This better too with her better vocals :love:

[Eddie.]

Though I love both, I picked Kelly just because she has the longer staying power, and is still relevant in 2018 unlike Leona...

[Mitchell]

Kelly obvs

[reece(:]

Leona is better now but Never Again cannot be topped

[Mokka]

Kelly has had huge success in recent years in the country music genre... while I dont listen to country myself... she is still current and relevant... so obviously Kelly

Also she is fabulous as a Voice couch. Such a lovely, funny woman

[Glenn.]

Kelly obviously. I love Leona and hope she can make a successful comeback but it’s not likely.

[Niamh.]

I wouldn't be overly into either but Kellys songs are better and she has more personality which comes through in her music too i think. Leona has an outstanding voice though

[Adamw92]

Leona obviously :lovedup: but I do love Kelly's older stuff, not so much what she's released lately

[Amy Jade]

Definitely Leona!

I love Kelly but Leona has the better voice and in my opinion the better songs.

[Smithy]

CLTNF6GXovM

I mean.... my wig is GONE

WHEN will Leona

[Alf]

Post me Clarkson's best American Idol performances and I'll tell you who's best.

I already know how good Lewis was on the Xfactor and she'll take some beating.

[Glenn.]

Piece by Piece had an effect on me that none of Leona’s songs have had. Leona has some beautiful songs and I listen to her a lot but ugh Piece by Piece :lovedup: