should JC be removed?

[RileyH]

scum!

[Mokka]

Yes yes yes yes and yes

Yes

[RileyH]

Anyone who votes no is getting curb stomped

[reece(:]

Yes

He's also broke the rules more then Chima

[JerseyWins]

Eh no not really

I don't really think his actions are ejection worthy even by UK's standards let alone BBUS who rarely ever do it :shrug:

[RileyH]

Eh no not really

I don't really think his actions are ejection worthy even by UK's standards let alone BBUS who rarely ever do it :shrug:

And this is why people mock New Jersey http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar92709_8.gif

[Mokka]

Eh no not really

I don't really think his actions are ejection worthy even by UK's standards let alone BBUS who rarely ever do it :shrug:

Did you not see his hand roving all over Tyler's body under the blanket?

He kissed his armpit.... HIS ARMPIT.

He kissed his body and rubbed him all over while he slept. AND Tyler complained the next day about how uncomfortable his night was.

There is actual .... video.... footage

[Jack_]

idk there's a part of me that likes how BBUS are in respect of the integrity of the game and just letting the houseguests get on with the ~social experiment~?

I don't know whether that's because I've just become so ****ing sick of BBUK's trigger-happy interferences, warnings and ejections - like Big Brother screaming over the tannoy when a 74 year old woman has an argument, or removing someone for things that literally happened outside of the house. And the whole culture its fostered among the tragic fandom of 'I'm complaining to Ofcom' and 'let's search their social media for dirt!'. It's just...not the show it was a decade ago. And so to have a version where they're kind of just left to their own devices is somewhat refreshing? That's not to absolve JC of any wrongdoing, but...this happens in real life, and in a warped kind of way it's probably a good thing people are seeing it.

The only person I thought should've been expelled since I've watched BBUS live is Amanda. From the previous seasons I've seen, it's only really Justin Sebik's expulsion I was totally in favour of. And I quite like the fact it's such a small number? :shrug:

[Mokka]

idk there's a part of me that likes how BBUS are in respect of the integrity of the game and just letting the houseguests get on with the ~social experiment~?

I don't know whether that's because I've just become so ****ing sick of BBUK's trigger-happy interferences, warnings and ejections - like Big Brother screaming over the tannoy when a 74 year old woman has an argument, or removing someone for things that literally happened outside of the house. And the whole culture its fostered among the tragic fandom of 'I'm complaining to Ofcom' and 'let's search their social media for dirt!'. It's just...not the show it was a decade ago. And so to have a version where they're kind of just left to their own devices is somewhat refreshing? That's not to absolve JC of any wrongdoing, but...this happens in real life, and in a warped kind of way it's probably a good thing people are seeing it.

The only person I thought should've been expelled since I've watched BBUS live is Amanda. From the previous seasons I've seen, it's only really Justin Sebik's expulsion I was totally in favour of. And I quite like the fact it's such a small number? :shrug:

I'm actually disappointed in you for saying sexual harassment should be let go of for the sake of the game... and a little shocked this is your stance.

[RileyH]

I'm actually disappointed in you for saying sexual harassment should be let go of for the sake of the game... and a little shocked this is your stance.

Me too

https://78.media.tumblr.com/69daa1b6be7bfb106b8577fa95eeb605/tumblr_pci5tjfcWM1vcwmiso1_540.gif

[JerseyWins]

Did you not see his hand roving all over Tyler's body under the blanket?

He kissed his armpit.... HIS ARMPIT.

He kissed his body and rubbed him all over while he slept. AND Tyler complained the next day about how uncomfortable his night was.

There is actual .... video.... footage
I didn't see where he kissed him, I assumed it was his forehead. Kissing his armpit is GROSS but doesn't make it any better or worse I just don't think kissing someone (unless it was like sexually on the lips or something) while they're asleep is that bad. That was like a kiss goodnight that a parent would give to their child (I know it's not actually that situation but it was that type of kiss)

The touching is a little worse but again I don't think he crossed any lines with where he touched him / how long he touched him for / how inappropriate it was. It's on the spectrum of sexual harassment but like anything there are extremes to it and not-so-extremes IMO.

They're friendly with each other, JC probably doesn't realize it makes Tyler uncomfortable. I didn't see it as, like, JC taking sexual advantage of Tyler at all. If Tyler let's him know he doesn't like it and he still did it that would be a very different story (which I'm not sure if that has happened or not).

[Jack_]

I'm actually disappointed in you for saying sexual harassment should be let go of for the sake of the game... and a little shocked this is your stance.

Let me be clear, there was an 'and' in this statement:

in respect of the integrity of the game and just letting the houseguests get on with the ~social experiment~?

Two different, unrelated points. I like how they respect the integrity of the game in terms of minor things like Julie's questions etc, but I ALSO like how they kind of just let the social experiment that Big Brother is just play out. The latter is what I'm referring to with regards to JC.

Sexual harassment should not be let go for the sake of the game (but again that's not what I was implying) - or at all - he should be severely reprimanded and if Tyler were to have complained (as Vegas said) then I'd be in favour of his expulsion. What I'm saying is, I like how social situations are just left to play out on BBUS. Some of Josh's pots and pan scenes last year were very uncomfortable, BUT in some ways I'm glad they just allow it, because Big Brother is supposed to be a social experiment and reality show. Human behaviour is not always pleasant. Can you imagine what would've happened had that gone down on BBUK?

Again, maybe I'm just so sick of our trigger-happiness that I'll take anything that's the antithesis of that but the way I see it is; behaviour like his happens in the real world, that video has gone viral and hopefully people are going to see it and realise (if they hadn't already) that it's not okay. He is going to come out to a ****storm and hopefully realise it's not okay. An expulsion is going to change none of that, his life is already going to be affected. And rightly so.

[Mokka]

I didn't see where he kissed him, I assumed it was his forehead. Kissing his armpit is GROSS but doesn't make it any better or worse I just don't think kissing someone (unless it was like sexually on the lips or something) while they're asleep is that bad. That was like a kiss goodnight that a parent would give to their child (I know it's not actually that situation but it was that type of kiss)

The touching is a little worse but again I don't think he crossed any lines with where he touched him / how long he touched him for / how inappropriate it was. It's on the spectrum of sexual harassment but like anything there are extremes to it and not-so-extremes IMO.

They're friendly with each other, JC probably doesn't realize it makes Tyler uncomfortable. I didn't see it as, like, JC taking sexual advantage of Tyler at all. If Tyler let's him know he doesn't like it and he still did it that would be a very different story (which I'm not sure if that has happened or not).

So you can't imagine that Tyler feels awkward and ashamed to say anything... cause that is generally how most victims of sexual assault or harassment feel. ALSO he was asleep... he doesn't even know all of what occurred or was done to his body.... and the producers aren't telling him that's for sure

[JerseyWins]

Also I'm not saying someone should have to tell another person they don't like being touched to not be touched at night but in this case I really think it was more friendly than harassment levels that's why I say that.

[Mokka]

Also I'm not saying someone should have to tell another person they don't like being touched to not be touched at night but in this case I really think it was more friendly than harassment levels that's why I say that.

You have not been on the receiving end of this... I can tell. But as someone who has? Let me tell you one persons version of friendly touching is not anothers

[JerseyWins]

So you can't imagine that Tyler feels awkward and ashamed to say anything... cause that is generally how most victims of sexual assault or harassment feel. ALSO he was asleep... he doesn't even know all of what occurred or was done to his body.... and the producers aren't telling him that's for sure
You have not been on the receiving end of this... I can tell. But as someone who has? Let me tell you one persons version of friendly touching is not anothers
All good points tbh, the last part especially which I didn't consider as much compared to how I saw it.

Should he be removed... I'm still not sure considering some things that are let go in BBUS (and I like to see people not removed personally) but I definitely see what you're saying!

[Macie Lightfoot]

"Respecting the integrity of the game" really just means that the show has been panicking ever since Kaitlyn's failed Bonus Life about whether or not they'll actually have enough HGs in the house on finale night, let's be real.

As for whether JC should be removed, I'll say yes mainly because he's so ****ing annoying and he thinks he's invincible since he's gay AND Hispanic AND short (he literally said as much in the n-word episode, don't forget!) Like, I don't care about the whole ~HGs are not allowed to sing~ thing but he's been sooooooo bad about it and just yells at BB whenever they reprimand him. He tried to use an ice cream scooper on like three different people's genitals. He used the n-word, repeatedly defended his usage of it, and then openly admitted that he only apologized for the TV edit. He acts like a lecherous creep towards just about every straight guy in the house. He opened the toilet door on Haleigh and wouldn't close it even when she started yelling about it.

Like, whether or not you find his WACKY ANTICS hilarious or annoying, he clearly has not even come remotely close to even attempting to follow the rules and he's been dreadful from a producer's standpoint. When is enough enough? What happened to three strikes and you're out? How come Scott got removed for throwing a chair in an empty room and Chima got removed for breaking a bunch of rules, and yet JC is being given a free pass for breaking rules and just being an offensive creep? I can't stand JC, but I also don't like the inconsistency/the show being so desperate to have a certain number of people in the house because they locked themselves into such a ****ing rigid structure of how to produce this show.

[Jack_]

Just to clarify, by respecting the integrity of the game I meant in a general sense. Like how they sequester the jury, limit Julie's questioning of jurors, don't allow the audience to cheer, that sort of thing

In hindsight I shouldn't have included it in my post, it was just a side-point

[Mokka]

Just to clarify, by respecting the integrity of the game I meant in a general sense. Like how they sequester the jury, limit Julie's questioning of jurors, don't allow the audience to cheer, that sort of thing

In hindsight I shouldn't have included it in my post, it was just a side-point

I understand that BBUK is OTT about kicking people out.... and BBUS, I agree, refreshingly let's real life scenarios play out and we all appreciate the conversations on race and sex and different view points.

But, I still argue this is a scenario where we have an assult that isn't even fully realized by the victim, so the conversation isn't happening... and things aren't going to work themselves out naturally because the producers are afraid to admit it occured... and the victim doesn't have the complete information to voice his concerns.

So, maybe JC should be allowed to stay if they let Tyler know what happened while he slept, and Tyler is given a choice in the situation. But really, this is, in my opinion, the exact scenario that I want the producers to stick up for their charges... and say it's not right, appropriate, or allowed.

[Matthew.]

yes he’s a horrible person

[Underscore]

Yes he’s ruining the Labour Party.

:joker:

[Dominic]

Yes, for reasons that have been named in this thread already. But no, CBS won't even show these events in the episodes, they'll continue editing him to be some cute fun AFP third placer.

[ethanjames]

yes of course he sexually harassed tyler whichever way you flip it JC touched tyler while he was unconsious and that isnt ****ing on and hes getting away with it. he should have been ejected a while ago

[starry]

I understand that BBUK is OTT about kicking people out.... and BBUS, I agree, refreshingly let's real life scenarios play out and we all appreciate the conversations on race and sex and different view points.


Generally that is true, for all the faults of scripting DRs, feed blackouts and manipulation, blurring people's mouths when they swear etc. Though there was the case of Willie Hantz who got thrown out though hardly touching the person who was winding him up. They seemed to have to make up that more happened off screen, looked very fishy anyway (though they could play up to those who hated the Hantz family).

[Mokka]

Generally that is true, for all the faults of scripting DRs, feed blackouts and manipulation, blurring people's mouths when they swear etc. Though there was the case of Willie Hantz who got thrown out though hardly touching the person who was winding him up. They seemed to have to make up that more happened off screen, looked very fishy anyway (though they could play up to those who hated the Hantz family).

I was remembering this but couldn't come up with the guys name to post the scenario.
Thanks for that :wavey:

[ethanjames]

at the end of the day JC touched tyler while he was unconsious scooped at peoples genitals with an ice cream scooper touched angelas genitals while she was blindfolded said the N word many times and exposed haleigh while she was naked. this shouldnt be aloud.

[starry]

And the whole culture its fostered among the tragic fandom of 'I'm complaining to Ofcom' and 'let's search their social media for dirt!'. It's just...not the show it was a decade ago.

It might have started like that, but I think it changed to using the tabloids to fuel the publicity for the show, ejections were thought to be useful publicity even.

[Jason.]

Ugly midget mother****er

[RileyH]

Ugly midget mother****er

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar93640_122.gif

[Dominic]

Ugly midget mother****er

:skull:

[montblanc]

Ugly midget mother****er

omg

[JerseyWins]

Ugly midget mother****er
omg
https://i.imgur.com/HiN54w4.gif

[Macie Lightfoot]

Honestly they should just do what they did to Kitten and force his ass out and deduct money from the prize fund if he continues to act like a twat.

[Macie Lightfoot]

1035936207266439168

Again, my main issue with all of this is that JC does not even pretend to be ~a good person~ or show any remorse or follow the rules at this point. He openly admitted that he only apologized about the n-word because he had to for the TV segment, and then he apparently went on to say it again after being told by production not to. He tied the bathroom door open on Haleigh and then played the victim with Sam yelled at him, saying how he just wants to play pranks but everyone gets mad at him when he does (this is literally Marc O'Neill logic) :skull: and I forgot to mention this earlier in my first post but remember when he interrogated Rachel on whether or not she was trans?

It's just a bunch of empty threats at this point and he knows it, and it's embarrassing that the show is giving him this much control by not doing anything other than getting on the intercom and saying "JC, please stop singing!" But again, this show is petrified to deviate even the slightest from its structure that they'll never do anything super serious unless it's a black woman going on a tirade about how the show was manipulated against her. Remember last year when (I don't blame you if you wiped this from your memory, I forgot all about it myself until someone else brought it up) Matt broke the HN rules on purpose so he could make sure that he was evicted over Raven, and then the show "punished" him by giving him exactly what he wanted, a penalty vote? There's no backbone here.

[Captain.Remy]

I told y'all they wouldn't do anything. What is surprising at this point from Grodner? All of this because "it doesn't affect the game" (that lame ass excuse they used in BB15)

[Dominic]

One thing the producers need to realize is that expelling JC won't even ruin the structure and course of what's left of the game. They'll have enough weeks left to get everyone evicted and have three people left on Day 99. All they'll have to sacrifice is a proper double eviction, which isn't even necessary at this point.

If JC were to get removed this week, seven HGs would be left in the game and this is how everything would play out:
Day 79 - F7 eviction aka this week
Day 86 - F6 eviction
Day 88 - F5 eviction, which always happens two days after the F6 one nowadays
Day 93 - F4 eviction
Day 99 - Finale

[JerseyWins]

Technically they could eject him, cancel this week, and still have a double eviction too.

It'd be interesting with Tyler being HOH :think:

[VanessaFeltz.]

I seriously dont understand what the **** is wrong with him....... i actually wanted to root for him as well but i cant after all the things he did

[Mandie]

My feeling towards this is that if a male did this to a female or someone else did this to JC they would likely be gone. I dont think he should get a free pass.

Just curious - why dont the cast stand up and say something? It seems like over half of them have been targeted by JC sexually. Perhaps they are not allowed by production. I know JC would likely play the Im innocent/it was a joke" card, however I would love to see him called out.

[JoshBB]

I haven't been watching BBUS, but if twitter is anything to go by, goddamn he needs to go

[Mokka]

My feeling towards this is that if a male did this to a female or someone else did this to JC they would likely be gone. I dont think he should get a free pass.

Just curious - why dont the cast stand up and say something? It seems like over half of them have been targeted by JC sexually. Perhaps they are not allowed by production. I know JC would likely play the Im innocent/it was a joke" card, however I would love to see him called out.

All of this

They put out a statement saying everyone involved was talked to... Tyler, Haleigh, and JC... and no one felt unsafe in the house. I'm unimpressed to say the least

[Mandie]

All of this

They put out a statement saying everyone involved was talked to... Tyler, Haleigh, and JC... and no one felt unsafe in the house. I'm unimpressed to say the least

Ugggg really? Even if they didn't feel unsafe, that doesn't make it right. Also - whats going to happen when he does take it to far? Be a little to late to say OPPPS! then.