Charley dislikes Emily the way Jade disliked Shilpa (class 'issues')

[the_chosen_one]

Just watching the live show, the way Charley is describing her 'issues' with Emily is the same way I remember Jade Goody describing her 'issues' with Shilpa Shetty.

Charley claims - She doesnt like the way Emily thinks shes better than her and doesnt like Emily's 'face' sometimes.

Does anyone else see the similarity? Is it a 'class' issue?

[andybigbro]

No i just tyhink Charley has some priorities that NEED sorting out

[Ruth*Star]

Exactly, Emily's not said anything bad about her, shes the one with the issues.

[the_chosen_one]

:joker: What priorities Andy?

[Psylocke]

Hmmm maybe.But i rekon Emily is very different to Shilpa,so it would be a diferent situation.

[the_chosen_one]

I switched off Celeb BB so Im not sure how it turned out.

[Amy21]

Yeah I agree Emily done nothing wrong Chantely is just over reacting and making an issue out of nothing.

[spacebandit]

Originally posted by the_chosen_one
:joker: What priorities Andy?

Remembering to shave for starters

[BigBrotherFan..*]

emilys done nothin an even if she did say stuff about her good on her coz charley is just annoyin an needs sorting out!!

[Rocky2605]

not the same but i see your point, thers a chance bb will be pulled of air theres such a mix of origins theres bound to start a racist row, charley hates nicky and tbh i think its racialy pushed.

[nodisharmony]

Originally posted by Rocky2605
not the same but i see your point, thers a chance bb will be pulled of air theres such a mix of origins theres bound to start a racist row, charley hates nicky and tbh i think its racialy pushed.

Well that is up to the viewing public & up to Endemol to recognize. Editing is everything.

I personally look at Charley & Nicky as ordinary housemates.

Whether they are white or non-white is neither-here-nor there.

Indian or Black.

The last thing anyone wants is another furore on our hands.






nodisharmony :angel:

[Rocky2605]

yer i see what u mean :) i dont want this year's bb to go off. i really want her to go thooooooooooooough please.

[nodisharmony]

Originally posted by Rocky2605
yer i see what u mean :) i dont want this year's bb to go off. i really want her to go thooooooooooooough please.

Endemol will behave this year.

This article speaks volumes very loudly to them:-

http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=60830

I am sure we are in for a great one:thumbs:

Charley is going to have to get with the flow & be nice:hello:






nodisharmony :angel:

[SiMoN!]

well Emily is like shilpa - both annoying fake tarts

[the_chosen_one]

Originally posted by Rocky2605
not the same but i see your point, thers a chance bb will be pulled of air theres such a mix of origins theres bound to start a racist row, charley hates nicky and tbh i think its racialy pushed.

I didn't really mean the racism issues Rocky, I was referring more to the 'class' issues.

Emily/Shilpa - 'Posh'

Charley/Jade - 'Chav'

I suppose the correct terms would be something like 'working class' and 'upper class', but I'm not sure about the girls' backgrounds.

Originally posted by SiMoN!
well Emily is like shilpa - both annoying fake tarts

I disagree about them being 'fake'. I think that's a different thing (for example, Charley seems quite fake, even though she's a chav). Though, if you believe Emily is 'fake' as well as being 'posh', that's fair enough.

[Pipergun]

I don't believe Charley and Emily's relationship has any minor indication of being race-related, like some argued the Shilpa - Jade issue had.

To put it simply: Jade and Charley are both thick, and Shilpa and Emily are both considerably more intelligent.

Whether Charley recognises and/or envies that remains to be seen, but I believe that's the root of the disagreement.

[Pipergun]

I'm confused:

The C4 site writes that Emily told Ziggy something along the lines of 'if I could nominate one person, it'd be Charley.'

(In the 'Charley vs Emily' article)

Does this mean Emily has therefore discussed nominations and requires punishment, or can this be overlooked?

I think it's borderline - what's your opinion?

[Dan_]

Originally posted by Pipergun
I'm confused:

The C4 site writes that Emily told Ziggy something along the lines of 'if I could nominate one person, it'd be Charley.'

(In the 'Charley vs Emily' article)

Does this mean Emily has therefore discussed nominations and requires punishment, or can this be overlooked?

I think it's borderline - what's your opinion?

I think that's pretty much overstepped the line in terms of talking about nominations.Say for instance Ziggy took that on board and to get on side with Emily by nominating Charley's he has been influenced by what she has said and that's a rule break for sure.