Australia : PETA sparks outrage by barbecuing fake dog to promote veganism

[arista]

[PETA sparks outrage by barbecuing fake dog to promote veganism
The canine prop was being cooked over a banner stating:
"If you wouldn't eat a dog, why eat a lamb? Go vegan!"]


The Photo
is a burnt fake dog

https://news.sky.com/story/peta-sparks-outrage-by-barbecuing-fake-dog-to-promote-veganism-11616185

[Children who saw the fake dog were said to be 'visibly upset'. ]

Typical of Down Under PETA.



And Lamb's are farmed for our Dinner
In our nation Dogs are our pets

[Niamh.]

Bad form to put that somewhere kids can see it. I mean I get their message but it's really not appropriate to hang it in a shopping centre

[Twosugars]

well they simply point out our hypocrisy in treatment of animals :shrug:

[arista]

Bad form to put that somewhere kids can see it. I mean I get their message but it's really not appropriate to hang it in a shopping centre



Yes it is wrong

[Niamh.]

well they simply point out our hypocrisy in treatment of animals :shrug:

This comment uummm I don't think so

"That supposed protest in Sydney is more inhumane than any slaughtering of animals.

[Twosugars]

the same kids who delight in playing violent computer games and experience bullying in the playground?

[Twosugars]

This comment uummm I don't think so

"That supposed protest in Sydney is more inhumane than any slaughtering of animals.

my comment or that comment?

[Niamh.]

the same kids who delight in playing violent computer games and experience bullying in the playground?

Violent video games at 3/4/5 though? I should hope not

[Niamh.]

my comment or that comment?

The one I quoted, it was a response to the protest. I agreed with yours to an extent

[Twosugars]

The one I quoted, it was a response to the protest

ta, Niamh :)

[Marsh.]

well they simply point out our hypocrisy in treatment of animals :shrug:

Good grief!

[Crimson Dynamo]

well they simply point out our hypocrisy in treatment of animals :shrug:

why who said we should treat them all the same?

[Niamh.]

why who said we should treat them all the same?

How is that an answer to what he posted? It is hypocritical to say it's not OK to kill one type of animal but it is for another

[armand.kay]

wth is wrong with them I'm SCREAMING

[Crimson Dynamo]

How is that an answer to what he posted? It is hypocritical to say it's not OK to kill one type of animal but it is for another

why is it, who says we have to treat all animals the same, we dont treat all insects, fish, humans the same so why animals?

[Niamh.]

why is it, who says we have to treat all animals the same, we dont treat all insects, fish, humans the same so why animals?

No one has to say anything, why are you obsessed with finding a person who said this as if it somehow proves your point? ................it's still hypocritical to say it's wrong to eat one but Ok to eat another

[Jordan.]

Mess, I don't think this is outrageous though it's pretty valid (although I'm still gonna ignore it :omgno:)

[Crimson Dynamo]

No one has to say anything, why are you obsessed with finding a person who said this as if it somehow proves your point? ................it's still hypocritical to say it's wrong to eat one but Ok to eat another

well if no one has said anything I cant see how you claim its hypocritical

you have to have someone or some statement that says "ALL animals MUST be treated equally"!


no one has ever said that so its not hypocrisy its just that animals are not treated equally like every living thing on earth

[Niamh.]

well if no one has said anything I cant see how you claim its hypocritical

you have to have someone or some statement that says "ALL animals MUST be treated equally"!


no one has ever said that so its not hypocrisy its just that animals are not treated equally like every living thing on earth

You really are obsessed with finding a guy who said something :laugh:

Nope, no one has to say anything for it to be hypocritical to think eating one animal is fine but it's morally wrong to eat another.

[Toy Soldier]

Meh. I'd eat a dog if it was farmed to be eaten, just as I wouldn't eat a lamb if it was my (or anyone else's) pet. It is hypocrisy to be OK with one but not the other, I just don't like the assumption that "I wouldn't eat a dog!!". Don't tell me what I would and wouldn't eat :hmph:.

[Niamh.]

Meh. I'd eat a dog if it was farmed to be eaten, just as I wouldn't eat a lamb if it was my (or anyone else's) pet. It is hypocrisy to be OK with one but not the other, I just don't like the assumption that "I wouldn't eat a dog!!". Don't tell me what I would and wouldn't eat :hmph:.

I wasn't telling you what you would or wouldn't eat. I was saying pretty much what you did there

[Niamh.]

Sorry you were replying to the OP not my post, I think :laugh:

[Toy Soldier]

Sorry you were replying to the OP not my post, I think [emoji23]Yes I was talking to PETA. Assuming I wouldn't eat a dog when they don't even know me :hmph:.

[Niamh.]

Yes I was talking to PETA. Assuming I wouldn't eat a dog when they don't even know me :hmph:.

https://media1.tenor.com/images/3fe2a6db3b340d8a5060f18d2672f898/tenor.gif?itemid=4514235

[Kazanne]

Well speaking of PETA,I saw a video today that was most upsetting and this is real animals with feelings that feel pain , watch that video and tell me it doesn't make you cringe ? Peta does do a lot of good work for animals hopefully this one will be highlighted , and this isn't for meat either, I notice the people that do this have their faces pixelated out ,not seen a video this vile for ages. just how low can humans sink?

https://secure.peta.org.uk/page/24121/action/1?utm_source=PETA+UK%3A%3AFacebook&utm_medium=Social&utm_campaign=%3A%3Agen%3A%3APETA+UK%3A%3AFacebook% 3A%3ATell+Farfetch+to+Stop+Selling+the+Fur+of+Torm en%3A%3A%3A%3Apost&ea.url.id=1737983&fbclid=IwAR2rJ7dSTU20B1K_6V3Fxkj6v04I6GwISu5fAcbOT FtHUyPSUr_kXcB-ftw

[Scarlett.]

PETA kills animals (https://www.petakillsanimals.com/)

[Kazanne]

Bad form to put that somewhere kids can see it. I mean I get their message but it's really not appropriate to hang it in a shopping centre

Yes agree with this ,there is a time and a place.

[montblanc]

aren’t they anti-pitbull anyways? **** them

[Toy Soldier]

Well speaking of PETA,I saw a video today that was most upsetting and this is real animals with feelings that feel pain , watch that video and tell me it doesn't make you cringe ? Peta does do a lot of good work for animals hopefully this one will be highlighted , and this isn't for meat either, I notice the people that do this have their faces pixelated out ,not seen a video this vile for ages. just how low can humans sink?

https://secure.peta.org.uk/page/24121/action/1?utm_source=PETA+UK%3A%3AFacebook&utm_medium=Social&utm_campaign=%3A%3Agen%3A%3APETA+UK%3A%3AFacebook% 3A%3ATell+Farfetch+to+Stop+Selling+the+Fur+of+Torm en%3A%3A%3A%3Apost&ea.url.id=1737983&fbclid=IwAR2rJ7dSTU20B1K_6V3Fxkj6v04I6GwISu5fAcbOT FtHUyPSUr_kXcB-ftw

I mean they do also kill the vast majority of healthy animals in their "care" and have been caught essentially kidnapping people's dogs from their gardens and cats off the street...

[Beso]

Well speaking of PETA,I saw a video today that was most upsetting and this is real animals with feelings that feel pain , watch that video and tell me it doesn't make you cringe ? Peta does do a lot of good work for animals hopefully this one will be highlighted , and this isn't for meat either, I notice the people that do this have their faces pixelated out ,not seen a video this vile for ages. just how low can humans sink?

https://secure.peta.org.uk/page/24121/action/1?utm_source=PETA+UK%3A%3AFacebook&utm_medium=Social&utm_campaign=%3A%3Agen%3A%3APETA+UK%3A%3AFacebook% 3A%3ATell+Farfetch+to+Stop+Selling+the+Fur+of+Torm en%3A%3A%3A%3Apost&ea.url.id=1737983&fbclid=IwAR2rJ7dSTU20B1K_6V3Fxkj6v04I6GwISu5fAcbOT FtHUyPSUr_kXcB-ftw



Wtf...nope, I ain't got words.:nono:

[rk3388]

OK for those of you who said it's wrong because there are kids- where do you think their meat is coming from? We get so disconnected from what we eat on our plates because we buy them in pretty packages, not having to deal with raising and killing animals. I eat meat but I think it's completely valid that if you do eat meat, you should understand where your meat is coming from.

[Tom4784]

PETA are the ****ing worst, hypocritical too considering they put a startlingly high number of animals to death in their shelters. It's all stunts and no substance with them and this stunt is just plain stupid. There's a difference between pets and livestock and it's that difference that completely invalidates PETA's 'point'. Nobody, regardless of the animal would eat it if they considered it a pet.

This is just shock tactics to get their name in the press again. PETA are the Katie Hopkins/Piers Morgan of charities.

[Tom4784]

the same kids who delight in playing violent computer games and experience bullying in the playground?

This point bothers ms, there's a major difference between violence in a video game and violence in real life. You can blow someone's head off in a game but not be affected before it's simulated and you don't experience the true horror that you would if you witnessed someone's head being taken off in real life.

The dog might have been fake but the kids wouldn't have known that, they would have seen a dog being barbecued in front of them and thought it was real.

[Niamh.]

OK for those of you who said it's wrong because there are kids- where do you think their meat is coming from? We get so disconnected from what we eat on our plates because we buy them in pretty packages, not having to deal with raising and killing animals. I eat meat but I think it's completely valid that if you do eat meat, you should understand where your meat is coming from.I'm a vegetarian and I think it's wrong to show something like that to 3/4/5 year olds and even older. it's like something out if a horror film. As a parent you decide what your child eats, so unless you're prepared to allow them decide to not eat meat after they see bloodied slaughtered animals like the one in the OP then no I wouldn't be showing them that and then forcing a pork chop down their throats

[Toy Soldier]

This point bothers ms, there's a major difference between violence in a video game and violence in real life. You can blow someone's head off in a game but not be affected before it's simulated and you don't experience the true horror that you would if you witnessed someone's head being taken off in real life.

The dog might have been fake but the kids wouldn't have known that, they would have seen a dog being barbecued in front of them and thought it was real.

I think it's easy to observe this effect with TV / movies vs real life recordings even. You can watch people being beheaded and gutted on telly all day long, but when you see an actual death on something like LiveLeak - or if you've been unfortunate enough to witness a death in real life, the horrible fight-or-flight adrenaline spike and just that feeling of "dread" in your gut is completely different. The difference in reaction is on a really basic, instinctual level but if a "fake" is convincing enough and the person observing it isn't aware, the emotional response in that moment is going to be exactly the same as if it was real.

[Toy Soldier]

That said - I showed my eldest a video of chicks being "sorted" - the females for egg cages, the males basically put into a giant blender - strays being thrown around and sort of... mashed... into giant vats, and she found it hilarious. Raising a little sociopath :umm2:.

[Niamh.]

That said - I showed my eldest a video of chicks being "sorted" - the females for egg cages, the males basically put into a giant blender - strays being thrown around and sort of... mashed... into giant vats, and she found it hilarious. Raising a little sociopath :umm2:.Oh dear [emoji102]

[Beso]

This point bothers ms, there's a major difference between violence in a video game and violence in real life. You can blow someone's head off in a game but not be affected before it's simulated and you don't experience the true horror that you would if you witnessed someone's head being taken off in real life.

The dog might have been fake but the kids wouldn't have known that, they would have seen a dog being barbecued in front of them and thought it was real.



All that said you can still.sit and gape at your telly and go online on it and repeatedly.watch someone's head being blown off for real. I wonder what percentage of COD over 21 game players have watched **** like that.

[Beso]

I think it's easy to observe this effect with TV / movies vs real life recordings even. You can watch people being beheaded and gutted on telly all day long, but when you see an actual death on something like LiveLeak - or if you've been unfortunate enough to witness a death in real life, the horrible fight-or-flight adrenaline spike and just that feeling of "dread" in your gut is completely different. The difference in reaction is on a really basic, instinctual level but if a "fake" is convincing enough and the person observing it isn't aware, the emotional response in that moment is going to be exactly the same as if it was real.

Or this....my sentiments as well
.

[rk3388]

I'm a vegetarian and I think it's wrong to show something like that to 3/4/5 year olds and even older. it's like something out if a horror film. As a parent you decide what your child eats, so unless you're prepared to allow them decide to not eat meat after they see bloodied slaughtered animals like the one in the OP then no I wouldn't be showing them that and then forcing a pork chop down their throats

All I'm saying is people are perfectly fine eating animals that are stuffed into cages, pumped with steroids so they can't walk, and living in their own bodily fluids, yet go crazy when they see a fake dog on a barbecue. If they are mad about this, they really shouldn't be a meat eater. And this is coming from a meat eater

[bots]

PETA did it with the intent to shock. Is that a good or bad idea .... I personally don't think that shocking the public with some gruesome sight will change eating habits in any way as the gruesomeness is disconnected from what is presented on the dining table. So I would consider it a fail.

[Northern Monkey]

I don’t see the hypocrisy.Just because (in the west) we have some animals for food and some for other things.We don’t have to eat every animal just because we eat some.
If they’d shown that poster in China it wouldn’t even be shocking.They eat Guinea Pigs in Peru,The Romans ate mice.We Don’t.It depends on the culture and what was readily available and what meats make the best food.

[Northern Monkey]

All I'm saying is people are perfectly fine eating animals that are stuffed into cages, pumped with steroids so they can't walk, and living in their own bodily fluids, yet go crazy when they see a fake dog on a barbecue. If they are mad about this, they really shouldn't be a meat eater. And this is coming from a meat eater

Never understood this argument.

‘You eat cows so you must eat pets too or you shouldn’t be eating meat’

Makes no sense to me.

[armand.kay]

I don’t see the hypocrisy.Just because (in the west) we have some animals for food and some for other things.We don’t have to eat every animal just because we eat some.
If they’d shown that poster in China it wouldn’t even be shocking.They eat Guinea Pigs in Peru,The Romans ate mice.We Don’t.It depends on the culture and what was readily available and what meats make the best food.

I don't think the hypocrisy is in people in the west not eating every animal on the planet, it's more in people's outrage at the image of a dog on the bbq but being perfectly fine with the image of a pig on a spit roast. Saying that I do think PETA are a bit ott... Even if the thought of them just grilling a dog as the onlookers watch is disgust and the children weep has me SCREAMING

[Toy Soldier]

I don’t see the hypocrisy.Just because (in the west) we have some animals for food and some for other things.We don’t have to eat every animal just because we eat some.
If they’d shown that poster in China it wouldn’t even be shocking.They eat Guinea Pigs in Peru,The Romans ate mice.We Don’t.It depends on the culture and what was readily available and what meats make the best food.

Well to be fair, they've also gone for the shock value of just showing an entire dog, fur 'n' all, on a barbeque... the people who eat them do tend to butcher them like we do with cows and piggies etc.

I think it would still be pretty shocking here to see an entire cow on a bonfire, eyes bubbling out of its skull :omgno:. Or like... a whole unplucked chicken roasting in an oven.

That would actually be some pretty effective vegan advertising. They should hire me :hee:.

[Northern Monkey]

Well to be fair, they've also gone for the shock value of just showing an entire dog, fur 'n' all, on a barbeque... the people who eat them do tend to butcher them like we do with cows and piggies etc.

I think it would still be pretty shocking here to see an entire cow on a bonfire, eyes bubbling out of its skull :omgno:. Or like... a whole unplucked chicken roasting in an oven.

That would actually be some pretty effective vegan advertising. They should hire me :hee:.

Well yeah there is that.PETA were just being totally unrealistic.

Even if you eat dog you’re not gonna eat the fur and paws.

People will see it and think ‘Ew that’s awful,I’m never gonna eat a dog now’ then go and grab a Quarter Pounder with Cheese on their way home.

[Niamh.]

All I'm saying is people are perfectly fine eating animals that are stuffed into cages, pumped with steroids so they can't walk, and living in their own bodily fluids, yet go crazy when they see a fake dog on a barbecue. If they are mad about this, they really shouldn't be a meat eater. And this is coming from a meat eater

Again, I agree with you if you're talking about adults who make decisions on what they eat but kids don't (generally)

[Niamh.]

I don't think the hypocrisy is in people in the west not eating every animal on the planet, it's more in people's outrage at the image of a dog on the bbq but being perfectly fine with the image of a pig on a spit roast. Saying that I do think PETA are a bit ott... Even if the thought of them just grilling a dog as the onlookers watch is disgust and the children weep has me SCREAMING

:laugh:

[Kazanne]

Wtf...nope, I ain't got words.:nono:

They aren't even killed parmy,just chucked in a cage ready for when their fur grows back then they have to endure that all over again, they would be better off dead,I haven't seen anything so barbaric in a long time, and all for the sake of Angora wool,pfft,scum.