Paula Abdul is going to judge All Stars

[Denver]

According to the Sun she is replacing Nicole and will sit alongside Louis and Simon

[Mitchell]

LOL k

[MB.]

That'll bring the viewers in

[Morgan.]

Nnn :skull:

[Morgan.]

If its an all stars series get an all star panel ... no? Surprised Cheryl wasnt up for it tbh

[DouglasS]

We want Sharon

[Strictly Jake]

Nick grimshaw was too busy?

[Morgan.]

We want Sharon

I mean yes and the get the og panel back would be ideal but I think the last we heard she hated simon and never wanted to see him again so :shrug:

[Liam-]

Paula :love:

[Denver]

Screaming though at the fact a guest judge is considered an All Star judge

[Black Dagger]

She did US and was on American Idol for years. It's not like she's not qualified. She's one of Simon's best friends.

[Denver]

She did US and was on American Idol for years. It's not like she's not qualified. She's one of Simon's best friends.

I dont think anyone is doubting her credentials i think people were expecting an All Star panel

[Black Dagger]

Nicole is unbearable after about 2 weeks. Sharon doesn't ever give a ****, Cheryl is pretty irrelevant herself now and lol at Tulisa.

I will happily have Paula!

[Denver]

Nicole is unbearable after about 2 weeks. Sharon doesn't ever give a ****, Cheryl is pretty irrelevant herself now and lol at Tulisa.

I will happily have Paula!

Poor Mel B

[Morgan.]

Poor Mel B

Not Mel B being eligibe for an all star panel after 1 series :suspect:

[Morgan.]

In that case lets consider Rita Ora, Nick Grimshaw, Ayda Williams and Brian Friedman too :hee:

[MB.]

Nicole is unbearable after about 2 weeks. Sharon doesn't ever give a ****, Cheryl is pretty irrelevant herself now and lol at Tulisa.

I will happily have Paula!

Poor Mel B

In that case lets consider Rita Ora, Nick Grimshaw, Ayda Williams and Brian Friedman too :hee:

This Kelly Rowland erasure!

[Morgan.]

This Kelly Rowland erasure!

When luv takes ovaaaaaaaaayeahhyeahh :dazzler:

[Denver]

Not Mel B being eligibe for an all star panel after 1 series :suspect:

She was also guest judge and a long term X Factor Aus judge similar credentials to Paula

[Liam-]

Surely ‘all stars’ only applies to the contestants, I don’t see the need for the judges to be previous ones as well

[Liam-]

Besides, Paula is a legend

[Denver]

Surely ‘all stars’ only applies to the contestants, I don’t see the need for the judges to be previous ones as well

I guess it makes sense for them to have some personal connections?

[Morgan.]

Surely ‘all stars’ only applies to the contestants, I don’t see the need for the judges to be previous ones as well

More for the nostalgia and familiarity than anything.

[Maxxie.]

It’ll be good chemistry I think, quite happy with that choice

[Withano]

Sharon
Maybe Mel B

Failing that; get rid of age categories and split it men, women and groups

Paula is a ****ing stupid idea lol.

[Withano]

Kelly will do too

[Daniel-X]

It’s going to be Love Island meets everything?

[Maxxie.]

Maybe they might have internationals if Paula is doing it, has any non UK stars except fifth harmony been internationally successful? (At least briefly)