The Rule Break [Archive] - ThisisBigBrother.com

Benjamin

25-10-2023, 10:15 PM

I love Yinrun, and jail yes as punishment. The voided noms was a bit much considering Hallie and Olivia just got jail.

I put it down to BB not wanting a Trish vs Hallie head to head.

Mich3LL3

25-10-2023, 10:18 PM

I love Yinrun, and jail yes as punishment. The voided noms was a bit much considering Hallie and Olivia just got jail.

I put it down to BB not wanting a Trish vs Hallie head to head.

Exactly.

rusticgal

25-10-2023, 10:19 PM

Was it really a rule break? She wasn’t influencing anyone and no names were mentioned.. :conf:

I do agree…she just mentioned her confusion and weighing up her options on who to vote…so unless Henry can read her mind it was rather pathetic.
Last weeks rule breaks named someone and was obvious persuasion…

GoldHeart

25-10-2023, 10:39 PM

Was it really a rule break? She wasn’t influencing anyone and no names were mentioned.. :conf:

I just watched it ,and everything was ok until she asked Henry " which way shall I go " . I honestly think she might have gotten away with it otherwise :facepalm:.

But yeah she didn't name anyone,and BB's punishment wa still way too harsh .

PoppyC

26-10-2023, 12:23 AM

That wasn't a rulebreak for me. No names or even hints. No influencing

Zizu

26-10-2023, 12:25 AM

That wasn't a rulebreak for me. No names or even hints. No influencing

Yes it’s utter nonsense

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

GoldHeart

26-10-2023, 12:28 AM

Yes it’s utter nonsense

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

BB was brutal with her unfairly , but like i said i think what did it was asking Henry "which way shall i go" .... it's like she was asking him what to do re:nominations, but niether of them mentioned names... so BB is ridiculous :rolleyes: .

BBUKAUSFAN

26-10-2023, 04:23 AM

Wasnt really a rule break, but at least it gives us a chance to boot dylan out :D

XXAHFXX

26-10-2023, 04:38 AM

She literally explained in great detail what her thinking was, knowing full well that Henry would understand her perfectly and the actual names would not have to have been used, not only that she did it in full view, right in the middle of nominations! She was damned lucky they didn’t show it on the big screen for all to see how that pure, little, scheming brain of hers ticks over.

Ammi

26-10-2023, 07:17 AM

…I do think that Yinrun’s rule break merited her jail time but beyond that, there still feels no consistency with the punishment of Olivia and Hallie…to say that Zak was a game player while they were nominating, is aimed at a specific person so a possible indication of a nomination and giving a reason of him being a game player to Olivia…Yinrun, while still having the conversation during nominations, didn’t aim or infer toward any housemate, but she did still rulebreak in discussing her reasoning…those two things for me, although not the same exactly…are too similar to not have the same punishment…not having consistency with these things just leaves it open to have a feel of manipulation …mind you, Yinrun’s devastation at being thrown into jail and the uprising and campaign to free her etc…the voice of the people…?…etc…really is truly a best BB moment of any series, I think…

arista

26-10-2023, 07:20 AM

I do agree…she just mentioned her confusion and weighing up her options on who to vote…so unless Henry can read her mind it was rather pathetic.
Last weeks rule breaks named someone and was obvious persuasion…

Yes but,
speaking of her confusion
Must have been the rule break

Cherie

26-10-2023, 08:15 AM

Did Olivia and Hallies rule break happen before or after they nominated?

bots

26-10-2023, 08:19 AM

Benjamin

26-10-2023, 08:22 AM

Did Olivia and Hallies rule break happen before or after they nominated?

Same as Yinrun, during nominations.

Ammi

26-10-2023, 08:26 AM

its very simple really, Olivia and Hallie were discussing noms but Yinrun was trying to influence directly prior to the nominations. Also, punishment is a deterrent to the house as a whole. So, they made it a harsher punishment to make sure nom talk is snuffed out. The next likely punishment is ejection or auto up for eviction

…consistency snuffs out, though…it has to be one rule for all and BB set that punishment with the two ladies…to reconsider and change is unfair and open to thoughts of manipulation and targeting, even…

Ammi

26-10-2023, 08:27 AM

…it’s good the legal action was taken and balance of punishments was restored…

Zizu

26-10-2023, 09:34 AM

Maybe they should have considered that Yinrun is struggling with the English language so how she’s expected to understand the complexities of the BB rules regarding nominations is completely beyond me .

When you listen into conversations it’s clear that she’s still learning about our ways and culture .

I’d guess that she thought that everything was fine unless you mention actual names or you make it clear by a description .. ‘ that Welsh guy ‘ for example

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Atake25

26-10-2023, 09:40 AM

Liam-

26-10-2023, 09:41 AM

She was asking whether she should go with her heart or her head, I don’t think she was trying to influence or even really taking about it like Hallie and Olivia were, so the overreaction from BB is a bit baffling, but it gave us a buffer to try and save both Trish and Hallie and it gave us my favourite moment of the serious so far as a result so I’m not all that mad about it

Zizu

26-10-2023, 09:50 AM

Was she asking should she nominate in who she dislikes or how it would affect her friends chances of staying in the house ?
I suppose that was to do with Kerry ? As Kerry is a friend to the group and wouldn’t nominate them ?
I’m confused by what she was actually asking

That’s what I was thinking

If the majority of us are confused how on Earth would she know it was a rule break given she’s still learning our language and ways

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Niamh.

26-10-2023, 09:59 AM

its very simple really, Olivia and Hallie were discussing noms but Yinrun was trying to influence directly prior to the nominations. Also, punishment is a deterrent to the house as a whole. So, they made it a harsher punishment to make sure nom talk is snuffed out. The next likely punishment is ejection or auto up for eviction

Hallie and Olivia did it during nominations as well :shrug:

Cherie

26-10-2023, 10:05 AM

Same as Yinrun, during nominations.

Yes but had they actually nominated at that point or no

Benjamin

26-10-2023, 10:13 AM

Yes but had they actually nominated at that point or no

I think Hallie had.

Cherie

26-10-2023, 10:14 AM

Hallie and Olivia did it during nominations as well :shrug:

After that BB said there would be more consequences if they did it again so I don't really see the issue, also it put up Dylan, so its likely Trish will be saved, in a head to head with Hallie, its anyones guess who would go

Cherie

26-10-2023, 10:14 AM

I think Hallie had.

Okay, cheers

Benjamin

26-10-2023, 10:15 AM

After that BB said there would be more consequences if they did it again so I don't really see the issue, also it put up Dylan, so its likely Trish will be saved, in a head to head with Hallie, its anyones guess who would go

Oh Hallie would defo go in a head to head with Trish. I still believe this is why BB did it to try and save Hallie as Dylan is unpopular too.

Mich3LL3

26-10-2023, 11:08 AM

Oh Hallie would defo go in a head to head with Trish. I still believe this is why BB did it to try and save Hallie as Dylan is unpopular too.

I feel the same about it.

Zizu

26-10-2023, 11:09 AM

I feel the same about it.

Just need everyone to vote for Halle and not get too clever

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Mich3LL3

26-10-2023, 11:12 AM

Just need everyone to vote for Halle and not get too clever

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

I cant vote so im keeping my fingers crossed

rusticgal

26-10-2023, 11:34 AM

BB was brutal with her unfairly , but like i said i think what did it was asking Henry "which way shall i go" .... it's like she was asking him what to do re:nominations, but niether of them mentioned names... so BB is ridiculous :rolleyes: .

But Henry said he couldn't say anything....so she asked the question but got shut down.

Its almost like someone just saying to someone I dont know who to nominate this week can you help me?...and not getting an answer. It was pathetic.

rusticgal

26-10-2023, 11:40 AM

I guess she was discussing Nominations....but it was like anyone waking up that morning saying 'Oh god its nominations today I dont know what to do...'
Where do you draw the line???

GoldHeart

26-10-2023, 11:46 AM

But Henry said he couldn't say anything....so she asked the question but got shut down.

Its almost like someone just saying to someone I dont know who to nominate this week can you help me?...and not getting an answer. It was pathetic.

It was pretty pathetic and like BB grasping at straws , especially when Hallie & Olivia did worse.