PDA

View Full Version : If it was an Ali vs Marcello final 2 - who would you vote?


Benjamin
13-11-2024, 08:45 AM
It’s looking likely it’ll be these two as the final 2. Who would you vote? If you wouldn’t vote there isn’t an option for you (as you won’t be voting).

Zizu
13-11-2024, 08:48 AM
Ali


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

bots
13-11-2024, 08:51 AM
i wouldn't vote

marcelloforthewin
13-11-2024, 09:14 AM
Marcello

thesheriff443
13-11-2024, 09:24 AM
I’ve already voted Marcello for this next round
I actually want to like Ali but can’t actually find a way past her serial killer stare

MTVN
13-11-2024, 09:27 AM
Stop the count!

It's a Marcello landslide

Niamh.
13-11-2024, 10:01 AM
Ali, Marcello is a slime ball

Tizmee
13-11-2024, 10:15 AM
Marchello!
He doesn’t pretend to be holier than thou and above everyone else!

Kazanne
13-11-2024, 10:17 AM
None

Crimson Dynamo
13-11-2024, 10:18 AM
The Cello

the star of the series and Christmas Number 1

Black Dagger
13-11-2024, 11:11 AM
Marcello is diabolical and Ali isn’t so easy choice

millyrose
13-11-2024, 11:18 AM
Marcello
Ali is awful

Liam-
13-11-2024, 11:19 AM
Ali, one misogynist has already won something this month, we don’t need another!

Barry.
13-11-2024, 11:22 AM
Ali

smudgie
13-11-2024, 12:02 PM
Ali over any of the .

jones89
13-11-2024, 12:03 PM
Marcello

joeysteele
13-11-2024, 12:11 PM
Ali

However I'd vote for any of them over Marcello.

Zizu
13-11-2024, 12:15 PM
Is that 7:7 thus far ?


Pleasing given that this forum has a huge group of Ali haters … thankfully this isn’t replicated elsewhere ..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

GoldHeart
13-11-2024, 12:19 PM
Marcello of course

GlitterUK
13-11-2024, 12:42 PM
Marcello.

Adamw92
13-11-2024, 01:22 PM
Ali, I don’t support misogynist's thanks

Katmieow
13-11-2024, 03:42 PM
Marcello over the supercilious narcissistic Ali anyday.

Gusto Brunt
13-11-2024, 04:19 PM
Marcello. :)

BBXX
13-11-2024, 04:26 PM
This is why I think Marcello will win GoldHeart ... Ali I think will be ahead right up until Segun, Emma and Hanah are out. Then when the votes reopen, Marcello will sweep up those votes. Ali won't.

GoldHeart
13-11-2024, 04:29 PM
This is why I think Marcello will win GoldHeart ... Ali I think will be ahead right up until Segun, Emma and Hanah are out. Then when the votes reopen, Marcello will sweep up those votes. Ali won't.

Not sure it will happen like that, as I still think Ali is winning no matter what. But I guess we'll see.

Will be interesting to see the voting stats ,when it all ends.

Vanessa
13-11-2024, 04:30 PM
Ali

Jase.
13-11-2024, 04:50 PM
In what world would somebody pick Trump loving misogynist dullard Marcello over saviour of the series Ali? I didn't think middle aged Karen's roamed TiBB? :(

Maru
13-11-2024, 05:02 PM
https://media.giphy.com/media/cCL3Db3AQUcTvBCh5H/giphy.gif?cid=ecf05e47oncpsyfngcc9150falh9watmx2h6 f29nu1dp1jn1&ep=v1_gifs_search&rid=giphy.gif&ct=g

Zizu
13-11-2024, 05:49 PM
10 Ali - 11 for the sexpest


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

troy4783
14-11-2024, 12:12 AM
Honestly ? Probably Marcello

Mystic Mock
14-11-2024, 12:21 AM
Marcello.

Ali keeps putting me off her with the constant Misandry.

Mystic Mock
14-11-2024, 12:23 AM
Ali, one misogynist has already won something this month, we don’t need another!

So you want a victory for a Misandrist instead?

Mystic Mock
14-11-2024, 12:24 AM
In what world would somebody pick Trump loving misogynist dullard Marcello over saviour of the series Ali? I didn't think middle aged Karen's roamed TiBB? :(

Tbf neither Marcello or Ali are dull.

Or at least in the traditional sense of how we'd describe it for BB.

eternal
14-11-2024, 12:25 AM
Comfortably Marcello. He's genuinely been a great housemate and showed us multiple layers of his personality. He's a normal, real person and doesn't hide it. There's a reason why everyone pretty much loves him in there (men and women!)

Ali on the other hand..

BBXX
14-11-2024, 04:54 AM
So you want a victory for a Misandrist instead?

Might as well level the playing field :laugh: Maybe Trump won so Ali could balance it back out.

Mystic Mock
14-11-2024, 05:24 AM
Might as well level the playing field :laugh: Maybe Trump won so Ali could balance it back out.

Trump's America's problem.:laugh:

I personally feel like if Marcello can't win then I'd be happy with a Nathan or Emma victory.

Ali is an interesting Housemate to a point, but I do feel like her pattern of behaviour is a bit one note for me, I do understand the appeal though tbf to her.

Hanah has "say it with chest" but is really just living off of that one moment imo, I'll give her credit and say that it did make me laugh though.:laugh:

And Segun is a nice guy, but he hasn't really been all that interesting imo.

Mystic Mock
14-11-2024, 05:27 AM
Controversially this would be how I would order this top 6.

1. Marcello
2. Nathan
3. Emma
4. Ali
5. Segun
6. Hanah

And I know how it looks with my bottom two.:laugh:

I honestly would have Segun above Ali if he had've been more entertaining to watch, as I do like Segun much more as a person than Ali.

BBXX
14-11-2024, 05:31 AM
Controversially this would be how I would order this top 6.

1. Marcello
2. Nathan
3. Emma
4. Ali
5. Segun
6. Hanah
.

Mine would be

1. Ali
2. Emma
3. Hanah
4. Nathan
5. Marcello
6. Segun

I think it'll be

1. Marcello
2. Ali
3. Hanah
4. Emma
5. Nathan
6. Segun

I can't make up my mind where I think Emma/Hanah will place I think it will be very close for 3rd/4th.

Mystic Mock
14-11-2024, 05:37 AM
Mine would be

1. Ali
2. Emma
3. Hanah
4. Nathan
5. Marcello
6. Segun

I think it'll be

1. Marcello
2. Ali
3. Hanah
4. Emma
5. Nathan
6. Segun

I can't make up my mind where I think Emma/Hanah will place I think it will be very close for 3rd/4th.

I think that it will be.

1. Ali
2. Marcello
3. Hanah
4. Nathan
5. Emma
6. Segun

Lostie!
14-11-2024, 06:22 AM
So you want a victory for a Misandrist instead?

She's not a man hater though, that's just one of the many outlandish accusations thrown at her over the last six weeks.

Ammi
14-11-2024, 06:35 AM
…I would have said Ali….Ali, Ali, Ali in a choice between those two….but then in yesterday’s highlights…I really liked Marcello as well…I can’t say atm, faced with that choice I’d probably vote on instinct in that moment…

joeysteele
14-11-2024, 06:36 AM
She's not a man hater though, that's just one of the many outlandish accusations thrown at her over the last six weeks.

Dead right..

BBXX
14-11-2024, 07:32 AM
She's not a man hater though, that's just one of the many outlandish accusations thrown at her over the last six weeks.

If it wasn't clear before that Ali doesn't hate men, it become so yesterday during her discussing with Hannah in the bedroom.

The way she spoke about how men are subject to body-shaming and how she dislikes it when women expect men to 'fund' their life without bringing anything to the table themselves is absolutely not the view of a Misandrist.

Zizu
14-11-2024, 08:30 AM
She's not a man hater though, that's just one of the many outlandish accusations thrown at her over the last six weeks.


The constant barrage of toxic vitriol posted UNJUSTLY about Ali has been disgusting


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

Liam-
14-11-2024, 08:48 AM
So you want a victory for a Misandrist instead?

Except she’s not that, you just don’t like strong women who don’t fawn over men just because they’re men

Ammi
14-11-2024, 09:16 AM
…I would have said Ali….Ali, Ali, Ali in a choice between those two….but then in yesterday’s highlights…I really liked Marcello as well…I can’t say atm, faced with that choice I’d probably vote on instinct in that moment…

…I went for Ali in the poll in the end and after thought…yeah, she would get my vote …

Adamw92
14-11-2024, 04:26 PM
Controversially this would be how I would order this top 6.

1. Marcello
2. Nathan
3. Emma
4. Ali
5. Segun
6. Hanah

And I know how it looks with my bottom two.:laugh:

I honestly would have Segun above Ali if he had've been more entertaining to watch, as I do like Segun much more as a person than Ali.

With all due respect, that’s an awful ranking and it makes me sad :laugh:

marcelloforthewin
14-11-2024, 04:27 PM
With all due respect, that’s an awful ranking and it makes me sad :laugh:

Stop hating on Marchy :nono:

Adamw92
14-11-2024, 04:28 PM
Stop hating on Marchy :nono:

Why? Someone has to combat the sheer amount of threads you’ve created about why he should win, how much are your bosses at ITV paying you?

marcelloforthewin
14-11-2024, 04:30 PM
Why? Someone has to combat the sheer amount of threads you’ve created about why he should win, how much are your bosses at ITV paying you?

I wish they was i am allowed to support and speak for a HM i feel strongly about when almost everyone else does is hate on him and moan about his sense of humour since when did the world become such a boring place that someone as miserable and humourless as Ali is deemed more popular :shrug:

millyrose
14-11-2024, 04:30 PM
I don't think Ali's a man hater she just doesn't like chauvinist's which to be fair who does. But i do find her very devious and manipulative, she is also a bare face liar, she lied to Emma saying her and Lily wasn't talking about her when she clearly was.

Adamw92
14-11-2024, 04:32 PM
I wish they was i am allowed to support and speak for a HM i feel strongly about when almost everyone else does is hate on him and moan about his sense of humour since when did the world become such a boring place that someone as miserable and humourless as Ali is deemed more popular :shrug:

Of course you’re allowed just as I’m allowed to “hate” on him as you put it, plenty of people on here hate Ali but a scary amount of people on here find Marcello to have not done anything wrong so it’s rather balanced, don’t you think?

marcelloforthewin
14-11-2024, 04:33 PM
Of course you’re allowed just as I’m allowed to “hate” on him as you put it, plenty of people on here hate Ali but a scary amount of people on here find Marcello to have not done anything wrong so it’s rather balanced, don’t you think?

Fair Fair

rusticgal
14-11-2024, 04:46 PM
I don't think Ali's a man hater she just doesn't like chauvinist's which to be fair who does. But i do find her very devious and manipulative, she is also a bare face liar, she lied to Emma saying her and Lily wasn't talking about her when she clearly was.


Exactly...she is very calculating.

GlitterUK
14-11-2024, 11:18 PM
Neck and neck on this at the moment, more even than I expected.

Mystic Mock
15-11-2024, 02:34 AM
She's not a man hater though, that's just one of the many outlandish accusations thrown at her over the last six weeks.

Her four main targets throughout the series.

Khaled
Marcello
Sarah
Segun

Three out of four people that she didn't like or had issues with are men.

And I could say that Marcello being called a Misogynist is outlandish considering the two people that he hasn't liked in this series were Ali and Dean, one each.

Mystic Mock
15-11-2024, 02:45 AM
Except she’s not that, you just don’t like strong women who don’t fawn over men just because they’re men

Where have I said that Liam?

In fact when have I ever said that over the years that you've seen me post on here Liam?

For god sake my favourite in BB13 was Deana, who would stand up for herself against anyone, and especially against Conor and Luke S.

The difference there is that Conor deserved to be disliked by Deana because he was horrible about her in a way that I've rarely ever seen on BB before or after.

Admittedly she got a bit extreme towards Luke S near the end of the series, but I did understand why she found his and Ashleigh's relationship to be fake.

And back to Ali, even if you want to justify her behaviour towards Marcello, what excuse can she have about Khaled and Segun?

Instead of just throwing out "Misogyny" claims at me like you've done twice this series Liam, can you actually come up with a reason why two largely harmless Housemates have been targeted by Ali? I mean she was friends with Lily who hammed up a wannabe Nikki Graham routine, yet Ali doesn't target her for being fake, but she threw/currently throwing out at Khaled & Segun.:think:

Mystic Mock
15-11-2024, 02:50 AM
With all due respect, that’s an awful ranking and it makes me sad :laugh:

:laugh:

I'm judging on three different criteria.

1. Entertainment
2. Who actually seemed to enjoy the experience
3. Who has shown different sides to themselves, the good and the bad if you will.

To me nobody in that top six has ticked those boxes quite like Marcello and Nathan.

Mystic Mock
15-11-2024, 02:59 AM
Where have I said that Liam?

In fact when have I ever said that over the years that you've seen me post on here Liam?

For god sake my favourite in BB13 was Deana, who would stand up for herself against anyone, and especially against Conor and Luke S.

The difference there is that Conor deserved to be disliked by Deana because he was horrible about her in a way that I've rarely ever seen on BB before or after.

Admittedly she got a bit extreme towards Luke S near the end of the series, but I did understand why she found his and Ashleigh's relationship to be fake.

And back to Ali, even if you want to justify her behaviour towards Marcello, what excuse can she have about Khaled and Segun?

Instead of just throwing out "Misogyny" claims at me like you've done twice this series Liam, can you actually come up with a reason why two largely harmless Housemates have been targeted by Ali? I mean she was friends with Lily who hammed up a wannabe Nikki Graham routine, yet Ali doesn't target her for being fake, but she threw/currently throwing out at Khaled & Segun.:think:

And just to add, I hope that you can respond without accusing me of not liking strong women or some other prejudice accusation.

I bit my tongue the first time that you did it this series, but you've actually pissed me off now.

Either debate like an actual adult, or don't bother.

I don't go and talk about Big Brother Housemates and say my opinions on them just to have baseless accusations thrown around just because I'm not kissing ass to Liam's favourite.

Honestly get a grip.
Liam-

BBXX
15-11-2024, 03:37 AM
And just to add, I hope that you can respond without accusing me of not liking strong women or some other prejudice accusation.

I bit my tongue the first time that you did it this series, but you've actually pissed me off now.

Either debate like an actual adult, or don't bother.

I don't go and talk about Big Brother Housemates and say my opinions on them just to have baseless accusations thrown around just because I'm not kissing ass to Liam's favourite.

Honestly get a grip.
Liam-

I like you Mock (and don’t think you hate strong women) but if you’re happy to throw baseless accusations at other people such as them being a misandrist and a man hater it does seem strange you are unwilling to be the subject of the same thing you are also the perpetrator of.

Mystic Mock
15-11-2024, 03:55 AM
I like you Mock (and don’t think you hate strong women) but if you’re happy to throw baseless accusations at other people such as them being a misandrist and a man hater it does seem strange you are unwilling to be the subject of the same thing you are also the perpetrator of.

I am accusing someone that agreed to go on a TV Show of something that I believe that they've displayed in the house, just like every other member on here has done about the Housemates.

I at least have a legit reason based on who Ali has targeted in the house.

Where as Liam is throwing baseless accusations around about another Forum member, there is a huge difference in that with all due respect.

He has zero evidence to back his claim up, he is just upset because I am not worshipping at the altar of Ali.

I don't even dislike Ali, I can think that someone might have a prejudice and still think that they're overall a decent person.

BBXX
15-11-2024, 05:20 AM
I am accusing someone that agreed to go on a TV Show of something that I believe that they've displayed in the house, just like every other member on here has done about the Housemates.


That's fair, personally though I think anyone willing to go on a public forum (forum or social) and name-call people on a public forum (TV) should be willing to take it. If we're willing to risk the person we're calling names seeing what we've called them, we should at least be prepared to take that risk for ourselves.

There is also a difference between calling out things people have said and certain behaviour traits and labelling them with the 'ist' based on just a few things we've witnessed them say. And I say that on behalf of all HMs.

This is just a general opinion, and not one I want to level closely at you though Mock as generally I find you a really fair FM and I very much enjoy reading what you have to say about all HMs :)

On the point of Ali/Marcello. I think you're really simplifying the definition of Misogyny/Misandry by thinking it simply as who someone doesn't get along with people of the opposite gender. Misogyny/Misandry isn't really about that.

You're calling Ali a misandrist because she has clashed with men. Well... she also hasn't clashed with men. She didn't clash with Dean or Nathan or Izzaz. Moreover, I think there is a distinct difference between clashing with men and clashing with men bout their maleness. Ali has clashed with Marcello, Khaled and Segun, but the clashes have been totally unrelated to the fact they are men.

On the flip side, the accusations of Marcello's misogyny aren't linked with him clashing with a woman at all. They're based on things he has said and the subject and context about women and/or their womanhood, which have at times been derogatory or demeaning. Specific thoughts that are in line with how Misogynists think and the types of things they say.

The only time Ali has ever spoken about maleness is to discuss Toxic Masculinity, which as we've discussed in depth before isn't about maleness or men. Her critique hasn't been about men, it's been about certain negative behaviour traits that some men exhibit that is closely linked with them being men.

Ali's discussion with Hanah the other day about men being subject to body shaming and being taken advantage by women in a financial capacity absolutely to not align with the thoughts of a Misandrist.

Mystic Mock
15-11-2024, 05:51 AM
That's fair, personally though I think anyone willing to go on a public forum (forum or social) and name-call people on a public forum (TV) should be willing to take it. If we're willing to risk the person we're calling names seeing what we've called them, we should at least be prepared to take that risk for ourselves.

There is also a difference between calling out things people have said and certain behaviour traits and labelling them with the 'ist' based on just a few things we've witnessed them say. And I say that on behalf of all HMs.

This is just a general opinion, and not one I want to level closely at you though Mock as generally I find you a really fair FM and I very much enjoy reading what you have to say about all HMs :)

On the point of Ali/Marcello. I think you're really simplifying the definition of Misogyny/Misandry by thinking it simply as who someone doesn't get along with people of the opposite gender. Misogyny/Misandry isn't really about that.

You're calling Ali a misandrist because she has clashed with men. Well... she also hasn't clashed with men. She didn't clash with Dean or Nathan or Izzaz. Moreover, I think there is a distinct difference between clashing with men and clashing with men bout their maleness. Ali has clashed with Marcello, Khaled and Segun, but the clashes have been totally unrelated to the fact they are men.

On the flip side, the accusations of Marcello's misogyny aren't linked with him clashing with a woman at all. They're based on things he has said and the subject and context about women and/or their womanhood, which have at times been derogatory or demeaning. Specific thoughts that are in line with how Misogynists think and the types of things they say.

The only time Ali has ever spoken about maleness is to discuss Toxic Masculinity, which as we've discussed in depth before isn't about maleness or men. Her critique hasn't been about men, it's been about certain negative behaviour traits that some men exhibit that is closely linked with them being men.

Ali's discussion with Hanah the other day about men being subject to body shaming and being taken advantage by women in a financial capacity absolutely to not align with the thoughts of a Misandrist.

If Ali sees my posts and objects to them, then that's fair enough as she is the one that is being discussed by me in a negative light on this particular thread.

I don't believe that a Forum member should be accusing another member of "not liking strong women" because I dare to think something negative about their favourite Big Brother Housemate, I would get it more if I was hating on every woman in the series, or every woman bar Rosie and Martha (who did seem to not really be very strong willed) but that has not been the case.

- Sarah was my favourite, and she weren't exactly shy with clashes against the men in the house.

- I really like Emma and find her to be one of the funniest Housemates of the series.

- I was probably the number one Daze and Martha defender on here, feeling that both of them were being harshly treated by the public.

- I never went in really harsh on BP like I really should've for being incredibly dull, like I have done to Thomas tbf. Yet Liam's never accused me of being Ableist because he also doesn't give a **** about Thomas, so it doesn't concern him what I think of Thomas, or what I think about anyone other than Ali.

- And I did soften towards Lily as the series went along.

- And Hanah has my favourite saying of the series. Admittedly I do have issues with Hanah away from that though.

For me I'm willing to address any issues that people might have with what I've actually posted, not make belief stuff that hasn't even been remotely said.

And thanks for the compliment BBXX, I have enjoyed your posts as well, and the debates that we've both had with each other throughout the series, I have honestly really enjoyed it.

And I do still like Liam's contribution to the Forum (I always have) but I do strongly dislike him posting stuff about me that isn't remotely true.

And with Marcello's comments, I get why they can be viewed as Misogynistic tbf, and who knows he might have issues in that area that he needs to sort out when he gets out of the house, but by and large I do think that he just likes to make very controversial jokes (like Sarah ironically) so I don't really think that he is that Misogynistic as some of his detractors are thinking.

Admittedly his reason for nominating Rosie makes me think that there might be something possibly there though, along with his love of Trump that makes me think that he holds some politically incorrect opinions about feminism at the very least, and Misogyny at the very worst, I don't believe that he has an Incel mindset or a sex offender though, like I know that some people on here have accused him of throughout the series.

And with Ali I do just find it interesting that most of her targets have been men, I can't attack John James during BB11 for constantly targeting women, but not when I feel like it is being done the other way.

I do honestly appreciate this debate with you though BBXX.:blush:

Zizu
15-11-2024, 06:09 AM
I don't think Ali's a man hater she just doesn't like chauvinist's which to be fair who does. But i do find her very devious and manipulative, she is also a bare face liar, she lied to Emma saying her and Lily wasn't talking about her when she clearly was.


I haven’t been watching the series of late - as you probably know - BUT surely that is a frequently occurring scenario found in all our lives at work or in family gatherings or whatever ?

We all chat about other people to friends/colleagues and if the person in question asks you about it you would deny it … just to avoid embarrassment or aggravation just to stay on good terms with them ??

It’s not an example of someone being an untrustworthy, bare-faced liar imho


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro