has anybody won an argument with charley

[.x.x.laura.x.x.]

i really do not remember anybody winning an argument with charley, i know most have tried, but they didnt win.

like it was her v billi in the bedroom, he was shouting back at her, but he was shaking and his voice was too, he was terrified, liam was too, i think the only person who has isnt actually scared of her in nicky

[Meerkat]

[quote]Originally posted by .x.x.laura.x.x.
i really do not remember anybody winning an argument with charley, i know most have tried, but they didnt win.

like it was her v billi in the bedroom, he was shouting back at her, but he was shaking and his voice was too, he was terrified, liam was too, i think the only person who has isnt actually scared of her in nicky [/quote

Why do you think people are scared/terrified of her???
Isn't it just that they simply don't wish to get involved in her usual big mouth rants?

[Wildcat!]

Originally posted by .x.x.laura.x.x.
i really do not remember anybody winning an argument with charley, i know most have tried, but they didnt win.

like it was her v billi in the bedroom, he was shouting back at her, but he was shaking and his voice was too, he was terrified, liam was too, i think the only person who has isnt actually scared of her in nicky

The only one I remember somebody winnin, was the argument with Shabnam, and the Bananas. Charley ended up backing off, and went to complain about shabs in the diary room. So she clearly lost that one!:blush2:

[MR.K!]

and Gerry with the water... she backed off into the bedroom

[Callum]

Shabnam over the bananas

[CassetteFinger]

yeah i say Shabnam.

[lily.]

Shouting someone down does not constitute "winning" an argument. In my opinion the fact that Charley never has a point and continues to shout down the other HMs means that she loses everytime. To win an argument, you don't have to out-shout your opponent - you have to make a valid point which can't be disputed. She fails to do that.

[.x.x.laura.x.x.]

Originally posted by Callum
Shabnam over the bananas

oh my god yeah!!! go shabs!

[.x.x.laura.x.x.]

Originally posted by Caw
and Gerry with the water... she backed off into the bedroom

she didnt win that one! yes, she did back off into the bedroom, but not before throwing a glass of water directly over him!

[serensilver]

ME :tongue:

[speedking]

Charley doesnt really win arguements she just comes back with a load of quick fire rubbish that hardley ever makes any sense that doesnt mean shes won,anyone could do that if they really wanted to.