Claudia or Alan

[UserSince2005]

Who is the better host?
Or maybe one of the international hosts is better?

[Benjamin]

No contest. Claudia by far.

I did also love the Australian host.

[rusticgal]

No contest. Claudia by far.

I did also love the Australian host.


Yes he is quite good…not keen on the American one…he overplays it too much.

[UserSince2005]

Alan is so theatrical though, he is such a pro, and really plays a role.

Claudia is just a bit all over the place. Yes it’s fun, but you never really feel like she is in command of the game like Alan is.

[Benjamin]

Alan is so theatrical though, he is such a pro, and really plays a role.

Claudia is just a bit all over the place. Yes it’s fun, but you never really feel like she is in command of the game like Alan is.

I can’t stand Alan. He’s very annoying.

[UserSince2005]

I can’t stand Alan. He’s very annoying.

In general or as the host?

[Benjamin]

In general or as the host?

Both.

[Barry.]

I like both but Claudia has the edge

[Mystic Mock]

Claudia as she makes me laugh.

Although I'm not always keen on her trying to make both Strictly and The Traitors extra sappy.:laugh:

[Ammi]

I like both but Claudia has the edge

…I like both as well in terms of their personality…I love Alan and Miriam Margolyes especially on their road trips as they bounce so well with each other and they meet some great quirky characters etc…but as a Traitor host I just feel a bit that Alan is less himself and more being asked to play into a ‘stereotypical’ Scotsman who is the Laird of the Castle/type thing …I don’t know, it just doesn’t work so well for me because it feels less that he’s bringing himself into the presenting and more bringing what the producers want to see as what they feel the part should be…

…with Claudia and Rodger Corser/who is quite dry with his humour …they seem as though they’re more being themselves and injecting themselves into the part so just have a hugely better fit….for me, anyway…but I do like Alan as a personality…