PDA

View Full Version : Michael Gaine: Full timeline of mysterious disappearance of Kerry farmer


Cherie
21-05-2025, 09:32 AM
You might not be aware of this story but its a real life horror

Michael Gaine: Full timeline of mysterious disappearance of Kerry farmer

News first broke of missing Kerry farmer Michael Gaine on the 21st of March. Known to friends and family as Mike, the 56-year-old had not been seen since the previous day, Thursday 20th March.

Michael has a colossal 1,000 acre farm near Kenmare and so an unprecedented search was launched involving hundreds of volunteers, gardai, Civil Defence, the Coast Guard, Defence Forces, helicopters and drones. Yet for almost two months, there was no trace of Michael to be found.

The case took a dramatic turn over the weekend when matter that was later determined to be human flesh was discovered as slurry was being spread over the farmland on Friday evening.

A man continues to be questioned in the case and gardai have until this evening to charge or release him. Here, we breakdown the timeline of the mysterious case that began as a missing person investigation two months ago.

Thursday, March 20
The last official sighting of Michael. The well-known farmer is seen around Kenmare and reported to be in good spirits with no signs of distress. CCTV captures him purchasing phone credit from a local Centra at 9.48am. Gardai say the last sighting of Michael was in Kenmare town at about 11am.

Friday, March 21
Michael's wife Janice reports him missing after he failed to come home. His jeep is found unattended in the yard of his farm with his phone and wallet inside. That day, close friends begin conducting a search of the farm while gardai set up an incident room at Killarney Garda Station.

Saturday, March 22
Gardai issue the first press release in the missing persons appeal. It asks for the public's assistance in tracing Michael's whereabouts, stating that his family are "concerned for his well being".

Following the appeal, a massive search begins involving more than 250 volunteers from the local community, the Coast Guard, Civil Defence, gardai and Kerry Mountain Rescue. That afternoon Michael's jeep is removed from the land and taken away for forensic testing.

Over the following days Michael is making headlines across the country and the search for him intensifies. Hundreds of locals get involved, a Garda helicopter is utilised, as well as drones to search the vast farmland and mountainous terrain of the MacGillycuddy's Reeks surrounding it.

Several slurry tanks were identified around the land – while diggers were brought in to assist the search. The tanks were emptied and extensively searched but no sign of the missing man was found. Searches continued around outhouses on the land – and sniffer dogs were also utilised.

Wednesday, March 26
The Garda Water Unit are drafted in and carry out extensive searches around an old disused quarry up the road from Michael's old farmhouse. They searched around the shore of the nearby Barfinnihy Lake as well as the Looscaunagh Lake about an hour's walk from Michael's old farm house. A stream around his land was also searched to no avail.

Thursday, March 27
Gardai renew their appeal to the public, however this time they also ask to speak to anyone who travelled on the N71 on Thursday March 20 and/or any person who may have any camera footage, including dash cam or CCTV, or any other images (video or still) from March 20/21 in the Kenmare town / Moll's Gap (N71/ R568) area to provide that imagery to the Garda investigation team.

A week on from the disappearance, hopes of finding Michael alive are fading while newspaper reports suggest gardai are probing the possibility of foul play.

Thursday, April 1
Gardai issue a new update and say the Irish Defence Forces will be assisting the search. Up to 50 members combined from the 12th Infantry Battalion, Limerick and the 3rd Infantry Battalion, Kilkenny began assisting in the search of rough open terrain and higher altitudes.

Wednesday, April 7
Several calves belonging to Michael as well as dozens of sheep are sold by his devastated wife Janice. Those close to Michael tell reporters that the sheep were scheduled to be sold and point out that nobody is available to care for the animals. The Irish Mirror reports an American man, who had been residing on Michael's land, is cooperating with gardai and is being treated as a witness in the case.

Tuesday, April 29
More than a month after Michael went missing, the case is upgraded to a homicide investigation.

Gardai said: "Based on the entirety of the information available to the investigation team, Garda can confirm today Tuesday, April 29, this missing person investigation has now been reclassified as a homicide investigation, and a formal criminal investigation has now commenced."

Saturday, May 17
A major development in the case emerges. On Friday evening there is a discovery of human tissue while slurry was being spread on Michael Gaine's farmland, it leads to the area being designated as a crime scene. The State Pathologist and Garda forensic team are called. A huge examination of the farmyard and surrounding area begins and more human tissue is found.

Sunday, May 18
A man in his 50s who is known to Michael Gaine is arrested on suspicion of murder.

Monday, May 19
The suspect was released without charge from Gardai custody on Monday night. Gardai confirmed that the man, who in his 50s had been released following questioning.

In a statement a Garda spokesperson said: "The male (aged in his 50s) arrested in connection with this investigation has been released without charge from the provisions of Section 4 Criminal Justice Act 1984. Search operations, supported by local, regional, and national Garda units, other emergency services and the Defence Forces, are ongoing at Carrig East, Kenmare, Co. Kerry.

"The family of Michael Gaine have been kept informed of this update and An Garda Síochána continue to support Michael's family through a Family Liaison Officer. The family have requested privacy at this time. Gardaí continue to appeal to the public for assistance in this investigation. The Garda investigation team can be contacted at Killarney Garda Station on 064 667 1160, the Garda Confidential Line at 1800 666 111, or speak with any member of An Garda Síochána."Gardaí will now prepare a file for the Director of Public Prosecutions."

Dublin Live




Now over to our reporter on the ground Niamh.

Niamh.
21-05-2025, 09:43 AM
Yeah awful story, that's very near where we are in Kerry too

Cherie
21-05-2025, 10:09 AM
Yeah awful story, that's very near where we are in Kerry too

Neem and Gav being interviewed as suspects :pipe:

I hope there is an outcome to this, and they get the person who did it, these cases are so rare in Ireland the Garda are not that up to speed with protocols like in the case of Sophie Toscan de Plantier, I wonder if they did really drain the slurry tanks because if so that raise questions as to where his body was kept

Niamh.
21-05-2025, 10:12 AM
Neem and Gav being interviewed as suspects :pipe:

I hope there is an outcome to this, and they get the person who did it, these cases are so rare in Ireland the Garda are not that up to speed with protocols like in the case of Sophie Toscan de Plantier, I wonder if they did really drain the slurry tanks because if so that raise questions as to where his body was kept

Rumour is he had a man staying on his land in a Caravan I think and they believe he's responsible

Cherie
21-05-2025, 10:15 AM
Rumour is he had a man staying on his land in a Caravan I think and they believe he's responsible

Is that the guy who was interviewed and released, or the American who is living on his land

Niamh.
21-05-2025, 10:17 AM
Is that the guy who was interviewed and released, or the American who is living on his land

The American I think (but don't quote me on that)

thesheriff443
21-05-2025, 10:46 AM
Did he fall in the slurry tank or was he put in there
That’s the question

Niamh.
21-05-2025, 10:50 AM
Did he fall in the slurry tank or was he put in there
That’s the question

And can it be proven either way?

thesheriff443
21-05-2025, 10:54 AM
And can it be proven either way?

My thoughts exactly

Cherie
21-05-2025, 12:11 PM
If the slurry tanks were drained as is claimed in the article, then he was put there afterwards? and how did he get chopped into bits, not sure a body would go through a muck spreader, I dont know but I am thinking no

thesheriff443
21-05-2025, 12:21 PM
If the slurry tanks were drained as is claimed in the article, then he was put there afterwards? and how did he get chopped into bits, not sure a body would go through a muck spreader, I dont know but I am thinking no

I think the slurry would dissolve a body fast

Beso
21-05-2025, 01:30 PM
Is it a pig farm?

Niamh.
21-05-2025, 01:34 PM
Is it a pig farm?

I wouldn't think so, it's mostly sheep farming down that direction

Cherie
21-05-2025, 01:52 PM
I think the slurry would dissolve a body fast

Not the bones, and human tissue was found in the slurry put out on the fields how did an intact skeleton get through a muck spreader

thesheriff443
21-05-2025, 02:28 PM
Not the bones, and human tissue was found in the slurry put out on the fields how did an intact skeleton get through a muck spreader

I’m trying to google the effects that slurry would have on the human body

arista
21-05-2025, 02:31 PM
Rumour is he had a man staying on his land in a Caravan I think and they believe he's responsible


That is tragic.

Ammi
21-05-2025, 02:33 PM
…this all sounds very grizzly…so he didn’t live alone, he was married…?…I’m reading that his mother had not long died either so the whole family are going through grief as well as his disappearance….

Benjamin
21-05-2025, 09:40 PM
This has intrigued me. I hope they solve how it all happened. His poor wife though.

LaLaLand
21-05-2025, 10:14 PM
Christ this is awful! Poor man.

Ammi
22-05-2025, 06:15 AM
This has intrigued me. I hope they solve how it all happened. His poor wife though.

…I think that they may solve some of what happened with forensics but sadly I think anyone being held answerable for his death/killing is much more unlikely…

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 09:39 AM
Chainsaw recovered
The Irish Times has just confirmed that Gardaí have recovered a chainsaw from Mr Gaine’s farmyard and have sent it for forensic analysis.

Investigators suspect that the chainsaw may have been used to dismember the farmer’s body after he was murdered at his farm.

Gardaí believe that Mr Gaine was killed near the cow shed in his farmyard at Carrig East soon after he was last seen at Whyte’s Centra Shop in Kenmare on 20th March, media reported.

https://www.farmersguide.co.uk/rural/rural-crime/updates-released-in-relation-to-michael-gaines-murder/

Beso this article confirms he was a Sheep Farmer

Beso
22-05-2025, 10:31 AM
Thank you.
.



I wonder if the wife and the American were having an affair.

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 10:36 AM
Thank you.
.



I wonder if the wife and the American were having an affair.

There's absolutely nothing to suggest that at all

Beso
22-05-2025, 10:52 AM
There's absolutely nothing to suggest that at all

Obviously..

Ammi
22-05-2025, 12:24 PM
…I was trying to work out the dynamics etc in terms of Michael Gaine’s wife and family…had they met this person who was living in a caravan on the farmland etc…but of course, they possibly never had met because he wasn’t living on the farm…I know that one of my dad’s brother’s kept the childhood family farm going with some livestock etc but never lived there…it was quite a little way from where he lived as well…and I guess that it was a similar thing…?…that only Michael Gaine might have been the one to have met his killer…

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 12:44 PM
…I was trying to work out the dynamics etc in terms of Michael Gaine’s wife and family…had they met this person who was living in a caravan on the farmland etc…but of course, they possibly never had met because he wasn’t living on the farm…I know that one of my dad’s brother’s kept the childhood family farm going with some livestock etc but never lived there…it was quite a little way from where he lived as well…and I guess that it was a similar thing…?…that only Michael Gaine might have been the one to have met his killer…

Actually I read earlier that it wasn't a caravan he was living in but a derelict property on Michael's land, he was an ex US Marine, sleeping rough around the Kenmare area and Michael allowed to set up camp in that property

Ammi
22-05-2025, 12:52 PM
Actually I read earlier that it wasn't a caravan he was living in but a derelict property on Michael's land, he was an ex US Marine, sleeping rough around the Kenmare area and Michael allowed to set up camp in that property

…I just read that Michael had allowed him to live there for 3 or 4 years…so he must have also been very known in the community…

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 12:54 PM
…I just read that Michael had allowed him to live there for 3 or 4 years…so he must have also been very known in the community…

Maybe, it also said he rarely left the property so who knows? So many rumours milling around with this one, I hope it doesn't go unsolved

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:00 PM
Maybe, it also said he rarely left the property so who knows? So many rumours milling around with this one, I hope it doesn't go unsolved

…yeah, I hope that it doesn’t become an unsolved, either…I read this in the same article…

So desperate was one friend of Mike’s, said the man, that he visited a ‘diviner’ looking for those answers.

“He paid €50 and was told Mike would be found in his hayshed among his animals with a light shining down on him,” the man said.

“But the shed had already been searched and the septic tanks emptied at that stage.

“He wasted his money – but it shows how worried and desperate people are.”




…also that Michael was the man to call if anyone needed anything/help with anything…he was always the man to help others…awful, awful for his family and loved ones right now…

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:01 PM
Maybe, it also said he rarely left the property so who knows? So many rumours milling around with this one, I hope it doesn't go unsolved

…provisions/food etc though…I wonder how he procured anything he needed…

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 01:03 PM
…provisions/food etc though…I wonder how he procured anything he needed…

Yeah i don't know, he must have had to go in to the town sometimes

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:07 PM
Yeah i don't know, he must have had to go in to the town sometimes

..I’m just thinking also that the townsfolk/surrounding local community would have been very welcoming and chatty with him also, as he was obviously someone who Michael had welcomed into his farm cottage and allowed him to make a homebase….I wasn’t sure how long he’d been staying there but it feels like 3/4 years, he would have had a reasonable contact/connection with the surrounding community…

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 01:12 PM
..I’m just thinking also that the townsfolk/surrounding local community would have been very welcoming and chatty with him also, as he was obviously someone who Michael had welcomed into his farm cottage and allowed him to make a homebase….I wasn’t sure how long he’d been staying there but it feels like 3/4 years, he would have had a reasonable contact/connection with the surrounding community…

And I can tell you from personal experience people around this area are very............inquisitive :laugh:

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:19 PM
And I can tell you from personal experience people around this area are very............inquisitive :laugh:

…inquisitive is a good word, I was trying to think of a descriptive but where my thoughts are is that even with someone who fairly much wanted to keep themselves to themselves…?…he’d lived there for 3/4 years in the property of a very popular local man who was a huge part of the community and very well liked…?…they wouldn’t allow themselves to not fully extend Irish hospitality, would they…they would be welcoming and they would also be inquisitive…so that’s something that I was thinking…also reading this….

THE man arrested over Michael Gaine’s murder was in dispute with the Department of Justice prior to the farmer’s death, we can reveal.

The Irish Sun has learned that the man, in his 50s, had interactions with the authorities, which also involved the Gardai.

…and the articles say that the questioned man had ‘extensive networks in another country’, whatever that would mean…but he was released without restriction and not considered a flight risk…

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:21 PM
And I can tell you from personal experience people around this area are very............inquisitive :laugh:

…’so what will you and Gav be watching in TV this evening…?’….:laugh:…

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 01:24 PM
…inquisitive is a good word, I was trying to think of a descriptive but where my thoughts are is that even with someone who fairly much wanted to keep themselves to themselves…?…he’d lived there for 3/4 years in the property of a very popular local man who was a huge part of the community and very well liked…?…they wouldn’t allow themselves to not fully extend Irish hospitality, would they…they would be welcoming and they would also be inquisitive…so that’s something that I was thinking…also reading this….

THE man arrested over Michael Gaine’s murder was in dispute with the Department of Justice prior to the farmer’s death, we can reveal.

The Irish Sun has learned that the man, in his 50s, had interactions with the authorities, which also involved the Gardai.

…and the articles say that the questioned man had ‘extensive networks in another country’, whatever that would mean…but he was released without restriction and not considered a flight risk…

Maybe he doesn't have an in date passport or something that they think he won't run? I don't know

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 01:24 PM
…’so what will you and Gav be watching in TV this evening…?’….:laugh:…

:laugh:

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:28 PM
Maybe he doesn't have an in date passport or something that they think he won't run? I don't know

…yeah I guess that could be an explanation, that they know that he can’t leave the country…I guess that I was probably over-thinking in terms of …was any type of diplomatic immunity involved when they had released him without seemingly applying to question/holding him for longer while the search continued…I really do hope this has a resolve for the family…no matter how awful, not knowing is an horrendous thing…

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 01:34 PM
…yeah I guess that could be an explanation, that they know that he can’t leave the country…I guess that I was probably over-thinking in terms of …was any type of diplomatic immunity involved when they had released him without seemingly applying to question/holding him for longer while the search continued…I really do hope this has a resolve for the family…no matter how awful, not knowing is an horrendous thing…

Yeah awful, looks like they won't have a body either to bury.

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:42 PM
Yeah awful, looks like they won't have a body either to bury.

…there are shades of a few cases I’m thinking of in this…I was thinking of Steven Avery and how it was known where Theresa’s body was burned …the Garda seem to know where on the farmland that Michael was killed…but will it lead to charges and conviction…I was also thinking about a local case that we had a few years ago…not in any similarities of the stories as such but more, the absence of a body ….this was the case that I’m thinking about as well atm …

https://www.itv.com/news/anglia/2022-03-23/the-missing-airman-and-the-bin-how-corrie-mckeague-vanished-without-a-trace

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 01:47 PM
…there are shades of a few cases I’m thinking of in this…I was thinking of Steven Avery and how it was known where Theresa’s body was burned …the Garda seem to know where on the farmland that Michael was killed…but will it lead to charges and conviction…I was also thinking about a local case that we had a few years ago…not in any similarities of the stories as such but more, the absence of a body ….this was the case that I’m thinking about as well atm …

https://www.itv.com/news/anglia/2022-03-23/the-missing-airman-and-the-bin-how-corrie-mckeague-vanished-without-a-trace

That's an odd one isn't it? Says he was sleeping in a doorway before he went in by the bins, could he have been with his phone inside a rubbish truck? Maybe he decided to get in one of the bins and sleep and ended up in the truck? Howe big was the land fill, big enough that he could have ended up there and just not been found?

ETA oh yeah, should have read to the end, shame they never found his body :(

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:56 PM
That's an odd one isn't it? Says he was sleeping in a doorway before he went in by the bins, could he have been with his phone inside a rubbish truck? Maybe he decided to get in one of the bins and sleep and ended up in the truck? Howe big was the land fill, big enough that he could have ended up there and just not been found?

….yeah I think that it’s been established now that he was in the bin/dumpster sadly and taken to land fill…not with any actual physical evidence at the land fill though and his mom had to fight many times to have areas of land fill searched…they are very high to have climbed into one of those dumpsters when he was very drunk and staggering but he obviously did…there was incorrect information for good long while, though in that it was said that the land fill theory couldn’t be a possibility because the dumpster wasn’t ‘overweight’ /…it was impossible for his body weight to have been in there…?….but then it was several years later that, that was said to have been incorrect information given and that the dumpster was overweight by almost exactly Corrie’s body weight…..there are still the odd signs that haven’t been taken down of ‘did you see anything/Corrie that evening…’…they were everywhere at that time…

….another sad aspect is after he disappeared/died…?….it was revealed that his fiancé was pregnant and that he had been going to be a dad…

Ammi
22-05-2025, 01:58 PM
…actually Corrie disappeared/died in 2016 …the same year as Michael watched his slurry pits being installed on the farmland…

Niamh.
22-05-2025, 02:00 PM
….yeah I think that it’s been established now that he was in the bin/dumpster sadly and taken to land fill…not with any actual physical evidence at the land fill though and his mom had to fight many times to have areas of land fill searched…they are very high to have climbed into one of those dumpsters when he was very drunk and staggering but he obviously did…there was incorrect information for good long while, though in that it was said that the land fill theory couldn’t be a possibility because the dumpster wasn’t ‘overweight’ /…it was impossible for his body weight to have been in there…?….but then it was several years later that, that was said to have been incorrect information given and that the dumpster was overweight by almost exactly Corrie’s body weight…..there are still the odd signs that haven’t been taken down of ‘did you see anything/Corrie that evening…’…they were everywhere at that time…

….another sad aspect is after he disappeared/died…?….it was revealed that his fiancé was pregnant and that he had been going to be a dad…

Very sad for his family and that he never got to meet his child

Ammi
22-05-2025, 02:05 PM
Very sad for his family and that he never got to meet his child

…yeah it really is awful to think that worlds can change in such a way so suddenly and randomly…I really do hope that Michael’s family get full resolve as to what happened and that there is answerability for his life…

Niamh.
23-05-2025, 06:44 AM
https://www.corkbeo.ie/news/local-news/michael-gaines-killer-cut-body-31705217?int_source=amp_continue_reading&int_medium=amp&int_campaign=continue_reading_button#amp-readmore-target

Ammi
23-05-2025, 06:48 AM
…sickeningly grizzly….its difficult to find words…for Michael, for his wife and family and loved ones…a nightmare that couldn’t be imagined…


…I’m reading this also…there was a link to it in the article you posted, Niamh….



https://www.corkbeo.ie/news/local-news/michael-gaine-suspect-makes-first-31705784#source=breaking-news

Niamh.
23-05-2025, 06:59 AM
…sickeningly grizzly….its difficult to find words…for Michael, for his wife and family and loved ones…a nightmare that couldn’t be imagined…





…I’m reading this also…there was a link to it in the article you posted, Niamh….







https://www.corkbeo.ie/news/local-news/michael-gaine-suspect-makes-first-31705784#source=breaking-newsThanks :love:

Even if they find the guys fingerprints or DNA on these tools that may not be enough, if he lived on that land he could explain that away, saying he uses them before. Proving this is going to be so difficult

Ammi
23-05-2025, 07:02 AM
Thanks :love:

Even if they find the guys fingerprints or DNA on these tools that may not be enough, if he lived on that land he could explain that away, saying he uses them before. Proving this is going to be so difficult

…the article kind of clarified that he doesn’t seem to have been an isolated loner, type thing…if he regularly played his music in the town …he obviously became in some way, a part of the community…I wonder what the local people think atm…

Cherie
23-05-2025, 12:35 PM
I wonder why they have honed in on this guy so quickly, if he can chop up a body he really is a psycho whoever did it