Vote to Save or Vote to Evict, which do you think gives a better result?….

[Ammi]

…so with a vote to save season, how have you found it…how has it impacted the house group in terms of evictions and do you think there would have been many positive/negative differences in order of housemate’s leaving with a vote to evict season…?…

[Vicky.]

Vote to save but there needs to be 3+ up for normal eviction and 4+ for double

[FromBB8]

I don't think the change has really made a difference up until now. I do think, if the vote just gone, was vote to evict then Jenny would be at a greater risk of going than she is, and Marcus would have a better chance of surviving.

But for previous weeks:
Gani v Zelah - Same result
Cameron v Elsa v Richard - Same result
Feyisola v Nancy v Tate v Teja - Same result, I think. This is slightly tougher to call
Farida v Richard v Zelah - Same result
Nancy v Sam - Same result
Caroline v Jenny v Nancy - Same result, I think. But perhaps more competitive between Jenny and Nancy?

[bots]

whats the point in a vote to save in a head to head :laugh:

[benthebbyapper]

VTS - in evictions with more than 2 nominees. Head to head votes really don't change based on what type of vote they end up with. Imagine this eviction with a VTE? Emily and Jenny would've probably been gone

[JingleJones]

It’s a weird one because it doesn’t really seem to have had much of an impact this series.. but then i remember series’ past where it would have made an impact… if that makes sense :dance:

[Merry Mockmas]

I don't think the change has really made a difference up until now. I do think, if the vote just gone, was vote to evict then Jenny would be at a greater risk of going than she is, and Marcus would have a better chance of surviving.

But for previous weeks:
Gani v Zelah - Same result
Cameron v Elsa v Richard - Same result
Feyisola v Nancy v Tate v Teja - Same result, I think. This is slightly tougher to call
Farida v Richard v Zelah - Same result
Nancy v Sam - Same result
Caroline v Jenny v Nancy - Same result, I think. But perhaps more competitive between Jenny and Nancy?

I think that Elsa would've gone against Cameron B under VTE.

The Showmance plus Feyisola haters would've made sure of it.

[Zizu]

I think that Elsa would've gone against Cameron B under VTE.

The Showmance plus Feyisola haters would've made sure of it.


Do we know how close their odds were on the night ?

That could prove / disprove your theory

[Yuki Maru Hoshi]

Vts with multiple with zero ****ery from prod regarding noms. Vte for head to head...

[joeysteele]

I prefer vote to save.
However it's no good with just 2 or 3 up.
At least 4 should be.

I don't like vote to evict, never have.

We've recently had the sad loss of life for Ben Duncan who is one of my all time BB favourite housemates.
Had we had vote to save in his series, he wouldn't have been evicted I doubt

However in this series, with evictions messed about with.
Nominations messed about with.
Too much immunity for some too.
Then rarely more than only 2 to 3 up.

Then it was pointless to even change the vote from evict to save in my view.

[Merry Mockmas]

Do we know how close their odds were on the night ?

That could prove / disprove your theory

Elsa was the favourite to leave at one point with the bookies.

[Shaun]

generally Save, but there have historically - especially in the Celebrity series - been evictions where something disastrous has happened

- Leslie Jordan being evicted second in a vote to save against 6 other housemates was baffling - especially when some of those others were George Gilbey, Stephanie Pratt, and Kellie Maloney :umm2:
- In the next eviction, Frenchy was evicted despite being "the drama" and up against 5 other HMs including Ricci from Geordie Shore and Lauren Goodger :umm2:
- In CBB17, one of the most beloved/revered series, you still had Gemma Collins getting evicted over Stephanie and Danniella Westbrook :umm2:
- And in the last series we had Jack P Sheppard constantly being saved because he is a household name in the UK and people care more about "I recognise him from Corrie" than "he is entertaining" so we lost Michael and Trisha over him :bored: