shabnam vs samanda

[Harry!]

which song is better?

Shabnam - Shout
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9pIuJVJBsI

Samanda - barbie girl
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yMKAjS0isAE

[Wasted]

Shabnam - Shout. It's actually her "singing" and she's covering a better song than Samanda did. The video looks really cheap though.

[Jack]

I prefer Shabnam's to be honest.

[Sarah.]

Shabnams Shout :)

[Arneldo]

For the simple fact that it is actually her singing, Shabnam.

[xDramatick]

SAMANDA
better video.
better song.
less out of tune.

[CassetteFinger]

Shabnam but dont like any.

[SairBabi92]

Samanda. Shabnam's looked cheap and she doesn't have any likeablity factor for me...so Samanda defo!

[starr.x]

i like em both but the samanda videos better

[xXxCharlottexXx]

They're both great but I prefer Samanda!

[Sticks]

Shabnam has the edge, sorry, due to the fact that Barbie Girl had the electronic alteration, but had Whistle for a Hottie been in the Mix, that would have walked it.

[farhad]

shabnam, and plus she's cool to watch.

[Captain.Remy]

OMG Shabnam is just pathetic, I can't belive she has done that. What a fame hungry.
Samanda rocks !!!!:lovedup:

[farhad]

Originally posted by sunshine30
OMG Shabnam is just pathetic, I can't belive she has done that. What a fame hungry.
Samanda rocks !!!!:lovedup:

Why shouldn't she, atleast she sang this tham the twins.

[andybigbro]

Samanda

[Billy]

Originally posted by sunshine30
OMG Shabnam is just pathetic, I can't belive she has done that. What a fame hungry.
Samanda rocks !!!!:lovedup:

the twins have done the exact same thing, so that makes them just as fame hungry

[Ross]

Shabnam's is better song.

Samanda is better video.

But you listen to song more than the video so, Shabnam.

[Wasted]

Originally posted by sunshine30
OMG Shabnam is just pathetic, I can't belive she has done that. What a fame hungry.
Samanda rocks !!!!:lovedup:

Umm... the twins have done the exact same thing as Shabnam, so you also think Samanda are pathetic and fame hungry?

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : Wasted
Originally posted by sunshine30
OMG Shabnam is just pathetic, I can't belive she has done that. What a fame hungry.
Samanda rocks !!!!:lovedup:

Umm... the twins have done the exact same thing as Shabnam, so you also think Samanda are pathetic and fame hungry?

The twins aren't fame hungries, they just enjoy the situation, they didn't go on BB for fame. Shbnam did, she has done some auditions and claimed even in the house that she has done it for fame. The song and the clip are just rubbish, it's even not a club song. Barbie girl is a club and entertaining song.

[Wasted]

Both sound like club songs to me. I agree that Shabnam is fame hungry because she said it herself, and I also saw her audition for Britain's Got Talent which shows how desperate she is. But you're calling her pathetic for doing a song when the twins have done the exact same thing, which is what I don't understand.

[Jack]

Originally posted by sunshine30
Barbie girl is a club and entertaining song.

I don't now what clubs you go to but I wouldn't be seen dead on the dance flor if that came on in a club :laugh:

[farhad]

Originally posted by Wasted
Both sound like club songs to me. I agree that Shabnam is fame hungry because she said it herself, and I also saw her audition for Britain's Got Talent which shows how desperate she is. But you're calling her pathetic for doing a song when the twins have done the exact same thing, which is what I don't understand.

Exactly. Shabnam has proved she has a bit of singing talent, and I dont see why anyone has a problem with that, atleast she is trying her level best best even though she hasn't got a strong fanabase like the twins and Channelle, who are getting offers without any hard word, as their popularity has helped them.

[BBCH:fan]

samanda all the way

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : Wasted
Both sound like club songs to me. I agree that Shabnam is fame hungry because she said it herself, and I also saw her audition for Britain's Got Talent which shows how desperate she is. But you're calling her pathetic for doing a song when the twins have done the exact same thing, which is what I don't understand.

I don't call her pathetic because she made a song, that's her right but she can't sing at all, she's so desesperate. The twins have done that for fun, because some producers gave them the opportunity to sing something they loved. Shabnam was ready to do everything she can in order to shout like a cow on an amateur video clip.

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : Jack
Originally posted by sunshine30
Barbie girl is a club and entertaining song.

I don't now what clubs you go to but I wouldn't be seen dead on the dance flor if that came on in a club :laugh:

And I don't know what type of music you listen but as an electro/techno/house/dance music addict I can confirm thi sis a club song. If it's remixed (I listen only remixed songs) it's far better but listen the song one more time and you will see what I mean.
The twins have done it for fun, they are young and sexy so if they don't do it now, they won't do it anymore.

[Wasted]

Shabnam did it for fun, just like the twins though. And obviously, she wants a bit of fame too, and I'm very sure that's the same with the twins. And although Shabnam is often deluded about a lot of things, she hasn't kidded herself into thinking she can sing, she knows she can't. She just did it for a laugh and because she was given the oppurtunity and made the most of it, just like the twins. She said all of this on the "What the HMs did Next" show.

The twins however, don't actually sing Barbie Girl. That's a lot more pretentious than Shabnam displaying her awful vocals, because at least we know what Shabnam sounds like, that she can't sing, and at least it doesn't look like she's trying to make us think she can. Barbie Girl doesn't sound like the twins made it at all, but at least you can tell from Shout that Shabnam was involved in recording it.

[Jack]

Originally posted by sunshine30
Message original : Jack
Originally posted by sunshine30
Barbie girl is a club and entertaining song.

I don't now what clubs you go to but I wouldn't be seen dead on the dance flor if that came on in a club :laugh:

And I don't know what type of music you listen but as an electro/techno/house/dance music addict I can confirm thi sis a club song. If it's remixed (I listen only remixed songs) it's far better but listen the song one more time and you will see what I mean.
The twins have done it for fun, they are young and sexy so if they don't do it now, they won't do it anymore.

It's pop music, targeted at young girls most definately. My little cousin plays it all the time. It may have some synthesised techno flare to it but somehow I can't see it being played at Pacha.

[Conor]

Shabnam, although it's a bit unfair because I detest the twins.

[supernoodles!]

oh my god there both terrible but there a bit of fun i guess

[farhad]

Shabnam has a good voice but a few lessons wouldn't hurt. she could also get a better choreographer, the moves are there, they just look out of sync. The video also could have been better if the budget wasn't so obviously tiny. I'd like to see shabs sing a new song and see if there is any potential there. Twins are just overrated, who cares about the video, they were very lucky it was produced in better production, but no credit should be given if they mimed to the songs.

[12bigbrother12]

:elephant::spin2::dance:Samanda:dance::spin2::elep hant:

[goroos1994]

I liked them both... but i like Samandas a bit more

[richard23]

samanda:elephant:

[Kristen]

Both are equally terrible and boring!
It makes me sick that two talentless people who spent time in a house can get a record contract and release a dull cover when there are talented singer/songwriters out there.

Saying that though I voted for Shabnam because it's so incredibly bad it's funny.

[cgimusic]

Samanda :lovedup:

[JeanP!]

Samanda

Loved it

[Loukas]

DEFFO SAMANDAS :bigsmile:

[Captain.Remy]

Samanda leads by far ! Barbie Girl is awesome !:hugesmile: