View Full Version : Which judge has most chance of winning?
Shaun
22-10-2007, 05:37 PM
All in the title! Which of the 4 judges do you think is most likely to have a winning act?
For me it's between Simon and Louis again.
Billy
22-10-2007, 05:38 PM
Simon, Sharon has ZERO chance
Arneldo
22-10-2007, 05:38 PM
Simon.
He has before the show he wanted a group to win and then, by coincidence, he got groups :rolleyes:
Ruth*Star
22-10-2007, 05:39 PM
Deffo Simon, He seems to have the strongest catagory.
XxShortyxX
22-10-2007, 05:39 PM
I agree with you. I think the final will be etween Niki and Hope, I ent saying that because they are my favs, but they are the best singers.
Niki has the best singing voice though.
Harry!
22-10-2007, 05:40 PM
not Sharon after she threatened to leave the show!
GiRTh
22-10-2007, 05:41 PM
Sharon:laugh2:
Spike
22-10-2007, 05:41 PM
Simon followed by Dannii both have strong category's. Sharon has no chance and Louis has a slim chance with Niki.
Wasted
22-10-2007, 05:42 PM
I agree, Simon or Louis will win again.
If the public warmed to Rhydian more Dannii might have small a chance too. Sharon has no chance.
Sarah.
22-10-2007, 05:42 PM
Simon, of course. :rolleyes:
Red Moon
22-10-2007, 05:53 PM
The best two groups in the show are Louis Walsh's and Simon Cowell's. I would like someone from Louis's group to win it. However somehow I think Simon will win it in the end mainly due the his performers being younger and appealing more to the younger audience members that tend to vote like mad on their Mum and Dads telephone bills.
BigSister
22-10-2007, 05:55 PM
As much as i dont like to say it i think Louis has the best chance with simon 2nd and danni 3rd
Loukas
22-10-2007, 05:59 PM
simon
Red Moon
22-10-2007, 06:11 PM
Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
simon
Why?
GiRTh
22-10-2007, 06:13 PM
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
simon
Why? Yes. Why?
Tom4784
22-10-2007, 06:18 PM
It's gonna be simon, he always seems to get the winning catagorey, well most times he does. If not then i'll bet on Danii taking the crown.
Callum
22-10-2007, 06:25 PM
Sharon, she has the best two. :thumbs2:
Originally posted by Callum
Sharon, she has the best two. :thumbs2:
:laugh: they will both go before the half way stage.
Sharon has no chance I dont think, because she doesnt really look after her category. Imo, Simon and Louis have the best chances, as they have acts like Niki, Beverley and Hope. But Danii does have Rhydian so I dunno.
Callum
22-10-2007, 07:33 PM
Originally posted by Dan_
Originally posted by Callum
Sharon, she has the best two. :thumbs2:
:laugh: they will both go before the half way stage.
Aw don't say that. I love Emily, and Alesha is also good. Hopefully they'll be proper good next week.
Originally posted by Callum
Originally posted by Dan_
Originally posted by Callum
Sharon, she has the best two. :thumbs2:
:laugh: they will both go before the half way stage.
Aw don't say that. I love Emily, and Alesha is also good. Hopefully they'll be proper good next week.
With Sharon mentoring them they've not got much chance.
Red Moon
22-10-2007, 07:42 PM
Originally posted by Callum
Aw don't say that. I love Emily, and Alesha is also good. Hopefully they'll be proper good next week.
I wouldn't worry too much it's not the worse acts that go. People have favorites and vote for them even if they can't sing a note. You just have to look at Saturday's show to see that.
In theory you could get a Butch the tone deaf singing Dog to win if it managed to generated enough fans!
Callum
22-10-2007, 07:52 PM
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Callum
Aw don't say that. I love Emily, and Alesha is also good. Hopefully they'll be proper good next week.
I wouldn't worry too much it's not the worse acts that go. People have favorites and vote for them even if they can't sing a note. You just have to look at Saturday's show to see that.
In theory you could get a Butch the tone deaf singing Dog to win if it managed to generated enough fans!
Very good point there Red. Just take a look at Leon, literally rubbish on Saturday, but you see some people probally consider him as 'eye candy' and thefore vote him in. And also Dan, I think you could be right there mate. I love Sharon, always have, always will but on Saturday there was signs of a unprepared judge, and that's what I don't like. Hopefully she'll realise from her mistakes and mentour the girls great.
Red Moon
22-10-2007, 09:12 PM
Originally posted by Callum
Very good point there Red. Just take a look at Leon, literally rubbish on Saturday, but you see some people probally consider him as 'eye candy' and thefore vote him in.
Precisely. We all knew that Leon should have gone on Saturday and not Kimbley but because the voting system is vote for the best act, rather than vote for the worse act the fans of any contestant can easily keep their act in.
It easy to see that this must be going on from the the number of fan clubs for acts we have on here. The fans won't be judging what their act does each week, they will just be trying to keep them in the show.
CassetteFinger
22-10-2007, 10:13 PM
Simon,danni or louis sharon has no chance even though my fav is in sharons Alisha will go this week or next week and Emily will get to like the final 6 then go.
Originally posted by Callum
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Callum
Aw don't say that. I love Emily, and Alesha is also good. Hopefully they'll be proper good next week.
I wouldn't worry too much it's not the worse acts that go. People have favorites and vote for them even if they can't sing a note. You just have to look at Saturday's show to see that.
In theory you could get a Butch the tone deaf singing Dog to win if it managed to generated enough fans!
Very good point there Red. Just take a look at Leon, literally rubbish on Saturday, but you see some people probally consider him as 'eye candy' and thefore vote him in. And also Dan, I think you could be right there mate. I love Sharon, always have, always will but on Saturday there was signs of a unprepared judge, and that's what I don't like. Hopefully she'll realise from her mistakes and mentour the girls great.
It is a shame really that Sharon seems to lapse with her acts, the song choices were poor and she needs to work harder with the acts.I like Alesha and think she would be great with the right song but it's just not happening yet.
Red Moon
22-10-2007, 11:10 PM
Originally posted by Dan_
It is a shame really that Sharon seems to lapse with her acts, the song choices were poor and she needs to work harder with the acts.I like Alesha and think she would be great with the right song but it's just not happening yet.
I agree her song choices were poor but I guess her thinking might have been not to push the hopefuls to far when it is their fast time on Live TV.
In theory you would think it is better to be safe than to take a risk and getting it all wrong. However that theory was blown apart by Leon getting through when he was absolutely rubbish. I put this down to his fan base how that can effect the voting system.
Hopefully she has learnt her lesson and will come back fighting and the girls she has left will be better next week.
GiRTh
23-10-2007, 10:18 AM
Both Sharon’s act will be gone in the next few weeks and hopefully she'll throw her toys again and leave for good. I don't think Sharon takes her acts seriously enough. I remember a couple of years ago she had Maria Lawson, Andy Abrahams and Brenda Edwards. All three were potential finalists, with Maria probably being the best of the three. After a couple of weeks Sharon told Maria to sing Brown Sugar by the Rolling stone. A song that most of the X factor audience would never have heard of. What a surprise she ended up in the bottom and was eliminated when Louis Walsh risibly saved the terrible Conway Sisters. I must say I had to laugh at all the backlash Louis got for that.
Indierock&roll
23-10-2007, 09:11 PM
simon :| Oh god no a boy band who will get nowhere .. who needs another boyband there OVER old news sorry !
Another..... pussycat dolls , girls aloud , spice girls :/
No thanks there okay but cant see them going that far!
And same difference they wont get that far in the show..
i think danni has a strong group
Leon has a great voice he just needs a better song this week!
Andy has a different voice wich is amazing and he will get the welsh vote aqnd votes from a lot of girls!
Rhidian he is just different and also got a great voice and he will get welsh vote too !
vBulletin® v3.8.11, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.