X Factor reach a decision over Kimberley

[Harry!]

http://i23.tinypic.com/4j5mz8.jpg

from heatworld

For all of you guys who thought it was wrong that Kimberley was voted off Saturday's X Factor because millions of viewers missed the opportunity to see her perform due to a last minute scheduling change, we have some disappointing news – she WILL NOT be given a second chance to perform. A spokesperson for the show confirmed to heatworld: "Kimberley will not be given a second chance. The rules are the rules."

[Ross]

pathetic.

[Matt]

I don't see why they should bring her back to be honest. She was voted off fair and square.

[Arneldo]

Did we really think she would come back?

Unless their was a mix up in the votes then I don't see why she should come back.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Matt
She was voted off fair and square.

Sort of. She didn't get enough public votes to stay and then the Judges voted her off.

It's only the judges that get to vote people off.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Matt
She was voted off fair and square.

Sort of. She didn't get enough public votes to stay and then the Judges voted her off.

It's only the judges that get to vote people off.

In which case, she was voted off square. :wink:

[XxShortyxX]

Awwww I surpose rules are rules, but I think she should be allowed to come back again, as I think she would of got through, as she has a lovely voice and can sing, plus she had the best personlaity.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Matt
In which case, she was voted off square. :wink:

Yes, like she was really the worse performer on Saturday *yawn*. We all know it was Leon.

If you listened to the so called judges they voted off Kimberly because she had less promise not because she was the worse performance of the two.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Matt
In which case, she was voted off square. :wink:

Yes, like she was really the worse performer on Saturday *yawn*. We all know it was Leon.

If you listened to the so called judges they voted off Kimberly because she had less promise not because she was the worse performance of the two.


Defo Leon was the worst! I still can't believe he wasn't in the bottom two! It's a joke! Stupid teenage girls voted for him, that's all I can think of.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Defo Leon was the worst! I still can't believe he wasn't in the bottom two! It's a joke! Stupid teenage girls voted for him, that's all I can think of.

I wouldn't have used the word stupid, but that is about right.

[Chri$]

Boooooooooooooo!

Thats a Load of Bull

I Hate Simon!

[Billy]

Its a joke that Kimberley did that song on Saturday anyuways. listening to her audition and bootcamp she is the talent factor, not the fun factor, and has just as good vocals as Alisha

[Spike]

It doesn't matter if millions of viewers missed her performance. If she was good enough to stay in the competition the judges would have kept her in.

[Billy]

If the judges voted on talent and not on there own acts, the past 3 series would have been really different

[Nicola]

Yeah, the rivalry between the judges really seems to affect some of the results, for example when Maria was voted off in Series 2 because Simon wanted to keep the Conways in. Kimberley was seen by the judges as a "fun" act, probably like cabaret rather than someone with the potential to be a popstar, maybe they thought Alisha had the qualities a lot of female soloists have. I think Leon, Daniel and Andy will get a lot of female votes even when they get negative comments from the judges because a lot of young girls will vote for them on their looks alone.

[SairBabi92]

I think it is completly unfair. I missed her performance because i thought it was going to be on at 5:45!

[001steven]

I think its all a fix Simon was glad it wasnt his act and so was louis i think Kimberly was great.... it is so obvious Simon will win again this year Sharon should win

[Ruth*Star]

Tbh i never expected them to bring her back.