Two weeks on; did the judges make the right decision?

[dupin]

Of the four the judges chose, did they make the right decisions? I'd say no, this is how it should have been;


BOYS
Charlie
Dominic
Rhydian

GIRLS
Analisa
Alisha
Victoria

OVER 25s
Niki
Zyta
Daniel M or the wedding singer (forgotten his name)

GROUPS
Hope
Same Difference
I Sette Cantanti

[CassetteFinger]

Zyta should of been there change her with daniel nothing wrong with having 3 women in the over 25's.

[Billy]

Stephanie
Kim H
Analisa

Dont care bout the rest

[Spike]

No i think it should have been

BOYS
Charlie
Dominic
Rhydian

GIRLS
Kimberly
Alisha
Emily

OVER 25s
Niki
Zyta
Daniel M

GROUPS
Hope
Same Difference
Futureproof

[Wasted]

The only boy I agree with Dannii putting through is Rhydian. Dominic was the best of the boys by a mile, and probably one of the best in the entire contest, and it was a mistake not to bring him through. I also think Charlie should've gone through, he was't so consistent but neither are Andy and Leon, but Charlie had a more interesting voice.

I agree with Sharon putting Kimberley and Alisha through, but not Emily. Ironically, the public seem to agree on Emily but disagree on the other two. Instead of Emily I would've put Stephanie through.

In the Over 25s, I think Zyta or the other Daniel should've gone through over Daniel.

In the groups, it would've been more fair to have W4 and Ghostt instead of Hope and Futureproof.