If you was a judge

[Spike]

If you was a judge what would you have said to each act after their performance tonight.
Alisha -
Andy -
Beverley -
Daniel -
Emily -
Futureproof -
Hope -
Leon -
Niki -
Rhydian -
Same Difference -

[Tom4784]

Alisha - Good, I liked her performance but she can do better.
Andy - Kinda Boring, I nearly fell to sleep.
Beverley - Really good, It was quite fabulous
Daniel - YAWN!!!!!
Emily - Not good, needs to improve badly.
Futureproof - Standard Boyband Affair, We don't need another Westlife, in fact we didn't need westlife in the FIRST place.
Hope - I enjoyed it, it was fun and sizzling.
Leon - A better song, I thought it was very good, he just needs to find his confidence then he'll be excellent.
Niki - Simply Perfection, Asolutely Amazing.
Rhydian - Rhydian used to annoy me but tonight he was fantastic.
Same Difference - It was very fun, it made me smile and their vocals were quite good i thought.

Best Acts: Niki, Rhyd, Beverley.

[Wasted]

Alisha - I like you, but you could do much better.

Andy - There's not much I can say, it was bland.

Beverley - Great performance, you need to be careful about shouting though.

Daniel - I hated the dancing, I hated the song choice, I hated the vocals, I hated everything about this performance.

Emily - It was a weak performance, you were flat.

Futureproof - It was good vocally, but what makes you different to any other boyband?

Hope - Great performance, much better than last week.

Leon - An improvement on last week but it was very dull. You need to be more consistent to win this competition.

Niki - Best of the night, even though you struggled a bit at the end.

Rhydian - Another great performance, but not as great as last week. I couldn't hear you over the backing track (but this may not be Rhydian's fault as they did play it very loud, I thought)

Same Difference - You sang it well but it was way too cheesy for me.

[Spike]

Alisha - Very good but you can do better
Andy - Very boring you are Mr no personality and poor vocals
Beverley - Much better than last week but I don't think you can win
Daniel - The same as Andy poor vocals boring and Mr no personality 2
Emily - Not good need to improve a lot or you could be out
Futureproof - Good but not great
Hope - Great performance
Leon - Get off the stage
Niki - Brilliant vocals, great performance
Rhydian - Best performance of the night, Fantastic
Same Difference - Good fun performance you have shown that you can sing and perform

[Red Moon]

Alisha - Weak Vocals. I starting to think your wasting your time.

Andy - Rather so so. Better pull your socks up boy.

Beverley - Superb voice. Get song choice and wonderfully sung.

Daniel - Wrong song. Couldn't hear the words. What are you doing man?

Emily - You too young come back in a couple a few years time.

Futureproof - Okay but you need to do better to stay in.

Hope - Not just the newest Girl Band on the Big Stage but one of the best.

Leon - Your a waste of space. Now get on your bike son and don't stop to you reach Glasgow.

Niki - Perfect. Very Moving. If you carry on like that you will be in the final for sure.

Rhydian - It's not an opera talent show. The stage door is that way. Now sling it.

Same Difference - Guess you can dance at least.

[Billy]

RM - What kinda talent show is it then

[CassetteFinger]

I dont get it i dident think nikis high note were as great as people are saying her last not was good which was just a long note.

[xDramatick]

Alisha;; The song suited your voice and it was better than last week but I think we're yet to see a good performance from you.
Andy;; Not bad. Great dancemoves but hated how the song was transposed for your voice. Wrong song.
Beverley;; Fantastic performance. Much better than last week.
Daniel;; Good performance, but awful song choice. I'd like to see more from you.
Emily;; Understandable song, but really flat. I think you're vulnerable tonight.
Futureproof;; Sounded good together, most solo parts weak.
Hope;; Amazing choreography, great together, but the solo parts should have been given to Emily and Charlie.
Leon;; Brilliant performance and I prefer it to Westlife's. I wanna see him sing something different though.
Niki;; Incredible. Potential to become a finalist.
Rhydian;; As much as you scare me, that was pretty good.
Same Difference;; Amazing performance! Loved the choreography, loved the vocals. Fantastic.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Billy
RM - What kinda talent show is it then

Well it's not opera that is covered by Britians Got Talent.

[Indierock&roll]

Alisha - Better than last week! Liked your performance
Andy - Could of had a better song but your vocals were great and great moves ;)
Beverley - who? Oh it was good
Daniel - definatly wrong song :/ was getting boring
Emily - poor vocals ! need a stronger song
Futureproof - was good but who needs another boy band
Hope - was good but who needs another girl band
Leon - good vocals but you need to relax and enjoy yourself on the stage
Niki - very good.. try something a bit different
Rhydian - really entertainingg! born performer
Same Difference - Cr*p!

[Dan_]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Billy
RM - What kinda talent show is it then

Well it's not opera that is covered by Britians Got Talent.

Should it really be that way though? It's about finding talented singers and Rhydian is clearly one of them.

I prefer a whole variety of singers, rather than just a bunch of ballad singers.It's just a shame there's nobody with a rock voice this time.

[dupin]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Billy
RM - What kinda talent show is it then

Well it's not opera that is covered by Britians Got Talent.

It obviously is opera, otherwise acts like Rhydian or G4 wouldn't be allowed to apply. Duh.

[Red Moon]

Okay maybe they should have other types of singers like opera. But do they fit in with the format of the show?