The X Factor Live [17/11]

[Loukas]

1 hour and 35 mins to go until the show begins

the song choices are below

Alisha-Young hearts run free
Bev-I'm Every Woman
Hope-Gimme Gimme Gimme(A man after midnight)
Leon-Relight My Fire
Niki-Hot Stuff
Rhydian-Go West
Same Difference-Feels Like I'm In Love

Tonights Guests - Girls Aloud

Discuss Here

[dupin]

I think the running order will be ;;

1 - Rhydian
2 - Beverley
3 - Hope
4 - Alisha
5 - Leon
6 - Niki
7 - Same Difference

[MarkWaldorf]

Same Difference will be up first this week I think.

EDIT: Oh wait, they were firstish last week...maybe in the middle.

[GiRTh]

Girls Aloud are on. :spin::dance2:

[Loukas]

Originally posted by dupin
I think the running order will be ;;

1 - Rhydian
2 - Beverley
3 - Hope
4 - Alisha
5 - Leon
6 - Niki
7 - Same Difference

thanks for that Dupin :)

[Billy]

I really hope Alisha pulls her performance off :(

[GiRTh]

I hope they all do well

[dupin]

I'm pretty sure it's time for the groups to finish; I think actually, Alisha will be first on, so maybe;

1 - Alisha
2 - Rhydian
3 - Hope
4 - Beverley
5 - Leon
6 - Niki
7 - Same Difference

[Billy]

Dupin, they won't put Sharons only act on first

[Loukas]

Originally posted by Billy
Dupin, they won't put Sharons only act on first

i agree i think they will put her in the middle

[Shaun]

Please vote for Hope guys, even if you don't like them :laugh2:

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Shaun
Please vote for Hope guys, even if you don't like them :laugh2:

I actually think they could be the best tonight. Really good song choice for them.

[GiRTh]

They'll never put her on first or last. She's not capable of opening or closing a show.

Vote her out. She's rubbish.

[Conzors]

I really want Same Difference, Niki Or Beverly to stay lol.

[MarkWaldorf]

EEE, it's starting.

[Loukas]

yey :bouncy:

[Conzors]

Woo Same Diff Lol

[Loukas]

wooo HOPE :joker:

[Shaun]

Sharon "It's about quality, not quantity".

Yeah, shame you've got neither love.

[Conzors]

young man..
there no need feel down..
young man

bla bla bla

Y M C A

lol sorry..


lol at sharon!

[Sam]

Gotta love that judges entrance. :bigsmile:

Woo Girls Aloud!

[Shaun]

Leon's up...

[Loukas]

were starting with leon ....

[Billy]

They want Leon out I think, putting him out first, and giving him a bit song

[Sam]

Oooh Leons first and hes got a bad song choice.

This could be his exit tonight.

[Sarah.]

LOL this should be funny.

[Billy]

YAYYYYYYYYYYYY Alishas not fvae to go :D:D:D:D

[Conzors]

OMG


DID HE JUST SWEAR!!!!!!!!!!

[Sam]

lmao at Cheryl.

Your Amaaayyyyyyyzing!

[Loukas]

he looks hot.............:whistle:

great performance - :spin2:

bad vocals - :bored:

[Sam]

Its okay. Shameless pledge for scottish votes with scottish flag on his shirt. :rolleyes:

I kinda liked it though. He shouldnt go though

[Billy]

I thought it was rubbish :S

[Conzors]

Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
he looks hot.............:whistle:

great performance - :spin2:

bad vocals - :bored:

He is hot lol :P

[MarkWaldorf]

Meh. It was alright.

[Matt]

I think that was his best performance so far - he improves a little every week imo

[Billy]

Grrrrrrr he has to gooooo :|

[Loukas]

Originally posted by Conzors
Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
he looks hot.............:whistle:

great performance - :spin2:

bad vocals - :bored:

He is hot lol :P

VERY :joker:

[Sam]

I don't think it was rubbish . It was good imo.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Sam
I don't think it was rubbish . It was good imo.

I agree, it was far from rubbish

[Sam]

Current betting:

Alisha Bennett 2 - 1

Leon Jackson 5 - 2

Same Difference 4 - 1

Beverley Trottman 11 - 2

Hope 6 - 1

Niki Evans 10 - 1

Rhydian Roberts 50 - 1

[Jackie]

Not Bad.

[Red Moon]

I hated it. Leon does nothing for me when sings. I thought it was rubbish.

[Sarah.]

I don't think with those vocals he should be this far in the competition.

Can't wait for Rhydians performance!

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by mrs_rko
I don't think with those vocals he should be this far in the competition.

Can't wait for Rhydians performance!

What Opera does Disco...... *yawn*

[Sam]

Poor Alisha is favourite to go now.

[Redmond]

Leon was alright, don't know why all the slights at Rhydian though. Suppose it just shows who the centerpiece of this show is.

[dupin]

His vocals were okay, but did he forget his words?! If so, it's a disgrace that they looked over it.

The fact he thinks he's anywhere near Rhydian is a joke, he's clearly the weakest act left, he should go.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Sam
Poor Alisha is favourite to go now.

Good. Ha Sharon :tongue:

[MarkWaldorf]

Leon wont go. His fanbase is too big.

[Shaun]

Didn't like it. :shrug:

[Red Moon]

God this page is taking ages to load.

[Arneldo]

Leon was brilliant!

I was nervous about his song choice but he was fantastic!
He was note perfect and although his dancing wasn't the best he had fun with it and it was great. His best so far.

[Shaun]

Note perfect? :laugh2:

[Billy]

Eeek NIki next, this is gunna be cringeyyy

[Sam]

LMAO, the seats a bit moist! :blush2:

[Matt]

Haha... Amanda was right about Hope

[Shaun]

Amanda Holden you **** ! :shocked:

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Shaun
Note perfect? :laugh2:

Yeah, his didn't mess up. You could he struggled a bit during the chorus but he did it.

[Sam]

LMAO at Louis. She hasnt had any hit records - true though. Good one Louis!

[Billy]

How can he be note perfect if he struggled a bit

[Arneldo]

What did Amanda say about Hope? I missed it...

[Billy]

Dannis bein a hypocrite. "he only picks ballad" "hes silly fiving her choreography"

[Shaun]

She referred to them as "those girls in knickers". :tongue:

Way to exaggerate.

*watches Niki*

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
How can he be note perfect if he struggled a bit

He struggled a bit but he manged to hit the note... :thumbs:

[Matt]

Oh my god, what has Niki done to her hair

[Billy]

Not enjoyingg this

[Sam]

I've got a strong feeling Niki will be bottom two tonight. I don't know why. She should stick to ballads.

[MarkWaldorf]

Louis looked worried.

[Conzors]

WOWWW..

what is niki doingg lol !!!

she looks like whoopie goldberg when shes in sister act!

[Shaun]

Niki's good...

Good choreography, good vocals...but wtf does she look like?

[Billy]

Can you blame him Mark lol

[Jack]

This performance is a bit cringe-worthy to be honest. It sounds good but it's just so tacky.

[Arneldo]

Niki, I think you've lost it.

[Billy]

I agree Jack

[Matt]

I have to say... I don't like this that much

She is definitely best with ballads

It's not rubbish though... she can still sing

[Loukas]

Originally posted by Arneldo
What did Amanda say about Hope? I missed it...

she said she was there only too keep an eye on them girl in nickers hope and simon

[Sam]

I don't like this performance at all which is a shame as I'm a fan of hers.

Its all a bit stars in their eyes again.

[Jackie]

Shes quite good.

[Shaun]

Ah good, I can justifiably dislike her if you all do then :tongue:

[Red Moon]

Well done Niki

[Loukas]

Originally posted by Sam
I don't like this performance at all which is a shame as I'm a fan of hers.

Its all a bit stars in their eyes again.


it was good and i agreed with the stars in your eyes bit

[Billy]

Shes in the bottom IMO

[Sam]

Simon's exactly right.

[GiRTh]

I was worried but I think niki did well. it was a terrible song choice but she showed she can sing uptempo songs.

[MarkWaldorf]

Lmfao "Mum at a wedding."

[Billy]

Niki seriousl cant take criticism, she was like this last week too

[Redmond]

And people call Rhydian big-headed! Rhyd would never talk back like Niki. Simon was right.

[GiRTh]

Simon is wrong, for once. I think he's a bit threatened by Niki.

[Shaun]

Oh great remark Niki. "Why don't you come up here and have a go?"

Because he's not one of the performers, you dappy tart, now stop being rubbish and GO HOME.

[Sam]

I think shes in bottom two for sure tonight..

[Billy]

LMFAO Shaun I agree

[Arneldo]

So far, I'd say....

Leon - 7/10
Niki - 5/10

[Shaun]

Rhydian already... :conf2:

[Matt]

Originally posted by Shaun
Oh great remark Niki. "Why don't you come up here and have a go?"

Because he's not one of the performers, you dappy tart, now stop being rubbish and GO HOME.

Woo... I totally agree :hello:

[Sarah.]

Rhydddiannnn:spin2:

[Jack]

Originally posted by Billy
Niki seriousl cant take criticism, she was like this last week too

Exactly. You can't defend yourself by saying "I'd like to see you do it". Simon's doing his job by telling her what he thought was wrong with the performance. He's not there to sing himself.

[GiRTh]

He had to admit that the vocals were good. He's threatened. I'm telling you.

[Conzors]

Originally posted by Shaun
Oh great remark Niki. "Why don't you come up here and have a go?"

Because he's not one of the performers, you dappy tart, now stop being rubbish and GO HOME.

id love to see you go up there and have a go shaun.

[Matt]

Here we go... I'm looking forward to Rhyd

[Loukas]

wow its Rhydian :colour:

but i dunno if it will be good

[Arneldo]

Niki's getting too big for her boots.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Conzors
Originally posted by Shaun
Oh great remark Niki. "Why don't you come up here and have a go?"

Because he's not one of the performers, you dappy tart, now stop being rubbish and GO HOME.

id love to see you go up there and have a go shaun.

LMAO.

Shut it, you mum-at-a-wedding.

[Sam]

Current odds:

Alisha Bennett 2 - 1

Leon Jackson 3 - 1

Same Difference 4 - 1

Beverley Trottman 5 - 1

Hope 5 - 1

Niki Evans 9 - 1

Rhydian Roberts 50 - 1

[Jack]

Woot Rhydian!

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by GiRTh
He had to admit that the vocals were good. He's threatened. I'm telling you.

:laugh2::laugh2::laugh2:

I doubt it.

[Sam]

I really hope Niki is bottom two.

OMG Rhydian!

[Arneldo]

Oh god.....

[Billy]

Is this the song from the Amrbosia advert??

[MarkWaldorf]

Oh my god...I can't take this man seriously.

[Jack]

Good God!

[Shaun]

Oh good God. What was Danni thinking?

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Billy
Is this the song from the Amrbosia advert??

Isn't it the go east ad?

[Sam]

It's just completely and untterly bizzare.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Billy
Is this the song from the Amrbosia advert??

The Sharwoods advert uses a version of this song re-written as Go East

[Billy]

It was in the Ambrosiacustard too but they changed the words too OOO ERRRR ITS AMBROSIA

[MarkWaldorf]

WTF is this. :conf:

[Arneldo]

Dannii needs to get the sack immeditly....

[Conzors]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by Conzors
Originally posted by Shaun
Oh great remark Niki. "Why don't you come up here and have a go?"

Because he's not one of the performers, you dappy tart, now stop being rubbish and GO HOME.

id love to see you go up there and have a go shaun.

LMAO.

Shut it, you mum-at-a-wedding.

Your Nice :)

[Shaun]

I believe Ms. Minogue is about to release her debut advice-book, "How To Make A Balls-Up Of A Talented Performer".

[Sam]

The whole irony is that Rhydian is pointing his east.

[Red Moon]

All he needs is the grannies taking off their knickers and waving their furry bits in his face.

He is so 70's Tom Jones.

Boring

[Jack]

Originally posted by Billy
It was in the Ambrosiacustard too but they changed the words too OOO ERRRR ITS AMBROSIA

LMAO! Yeah :laugh:

[Matt]

Dannii is to blame for this... this was so a wrong choice of song.

Great vocals, but it's not his best performance

[Billy]

I actually liked it

[Sarah.]

What a ridiculous song choice..

[MarkWaldorf]

He should stick to opera.

[Jack]

Dannii is rediculous. That performance had no credability for me and it was all down to song choice.

[Matt]

Dannii should be sacked. Terrible choice of song.

[Sam]

Hes right. Dannii does think hes won it already.

[Jackie]

I think he was very good.

[Billy]

May hvae a problem? Be quiet Simon hes obviously safe

[Loukas]

bad song :bored:

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

[MarkWaldorf]

It's not really down to the song, it was disco week, and he couldn't sing that genre.

[Sarah.]

I still liked it :tongue:

[Billy]

No he isnt RM

[Shaun]

For once I agree with both Louis and Simon.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

Yeah it is ridiculous to have an extremely talented person on a talent contest

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by MarkChap©
He should stick to opera.

I agree....... 100%

[Jack]

Does it say HMS Dannii on the hats? That says it all really. Someone deflate that woman's ego... fast. :rolleyes:

[Sam]

Originally posted by MarkChap©
It's not really down to the song, it was disco week, and he couldn't sing that genre.

But the whole thing was bizarre! He could easily have sung another song from that genre, its just the wrong song imo.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Jack
Does it say HMS Dannii on the hats? That says it all really. Someone deflate that woman's ego... fast. :rolleyes:

Does it? :shocked:

LMAO. What a bitch.

[Loukas]

Camp VERY camp :tongue:

same difference - will either be bad, very bad or ok
Alisha - good
hope- wait and see

[Matt]

Originally posted by MarkChap©
It's not really down to the song, it was disco week, and he couldn't sing that genre.

It wasn't a terrible performance. If he had the right song I'm sure he could have pulled it off.

[Arneldo]

Odds after Rhydian's performance...

Alisha - 2/1
Leon - 3/1
SD - 4/1
Beverley - 5/1
Hope - 5/1
Niki - 10/1
Rhydian - 25/1

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

Yeah it is ridiculous to have an extremely talented person on a talent contest

It's ridiculous having an Opera Singer in a Pop Music Talent show.

I would just love to see him go tonight.

[Jack]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by Jack
Does it say HMS Dannii on the hats? That says it all really. Someone deflate that woman's ego... fast. :rolleyes:

Does it? :shocked:

LMAO. What a bitch.

I could see "HMS Dan...". So I guess it was.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by MarkChap©
It's not really down to the song, it was disco week, and he couldn't sing that genre.

It wasn't a terrible performance. If he had the right song I'm sure he could have pulled it off.

Name a disco song you believe he could have pulled off then?

Sam, it was very bizarre, yes. :laugh:

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by MarkChap©
It's not really down to the song, it was disco week, and he couldn't sing that genre.

It wasn't a terrible performance. If he had the right song I'm sure he could have pulled it off.

An Opera Song....... LMFAO

[Sam]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

Yeah it is ridiculous to have an extremely talented person on a talent contest

It's ridiculous having an Opera Singer in a Pop Music Talent show.

I would just love to see him go tonight.

I would too actually. Id like to see a pop music act win this show.

[Sarah.]

Regardless of whether he goes or not now, I'm sure he'll get some kind of recording contract, he's amazing.:thumbs:

[dupin]

Niki was okay, but the second she said "Why don't you come up and give it a go?" made me dislike her.

Rhydian was crap.

[Jack]

Dannii may as well have given him the YMCA to sing, whilst wearing a Red Indian head dress, it was that rediculous.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

Yeah it is ridiculous to have an extremely talented person on a talent contest

It's ridiculous having an Opera Singer in a Pop Music Talent show.

I would just love to see him go tonight.

It's not a pop music talent show. It's a talent show.

Steve, Leona - They are not pop singers.
Shayne was buts that just one example.

There have been plenty of different types of singers on XF over the years and they have done great. Opera, Soul, Balled, Rock...

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Sam
Originally posted by Red Moon
It's ridiculous having an Opera Singer in a Pop Music Talent show.

I would just love to see him go tonight.

I would too actually. Id like to see a pop music act win this show.

Me too.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by mrs_rko
Regardless of whether he goes or not now, I'm sure he'll get some kind of recording contract, he's amazing.:thumbs:

He'll release an opera album full of covers, get a number 1, then fade away.

That's why I don't believe he should win. If Dannii can't even give him the right songs, how will his career pan out? Bad covers.

He's an excellent singer, but doesn't belong in this show.

[Matt]

Hope... hmm

[Loukas]

HOPE :joker: :joker: :joker:

[Sam]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

Yeah it is ridiculous to have an extremely talented person on a talent contest

It's ridiculous having an Opera Singer in a Pop Music Talent show.

I would just love to see him go tonight.

It's not a pop music talent show. It's a talent show.

Steve, Leona - They are not pop singers.
Shayne was buts that just one example.

There have been plenty of different types of singers on XF over the years and they have done great. Opera, Soul, Balled, Rock...

Leona's not a pop singer?

[Arneldo]

Simon: "5 talents girls..."

Make that 1 talented girl and 4 back-up singers.

[Jack]

Now Rhyd's flopped, Hope have the oppurtunity of performance of the night.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Simon: "5 talents girls..."

Make that 1 talented girl and 4 back-up singers.

:laugh:

[Sarah.]

It's called "X Factor" not Pop Music Factor. X Factor is about something different, and that's Rhydian.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Simon: "5 talents girls..."

Make that 1 talented girl and 4 back-up singers.

**** off :)

Yaaaaaaaaay Hope!

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Arneldo
It's not a pop music talent show. It's a talent show.

Steve, Leona - They are not pop singers.
Shayne was buts that just one example.

There have been plenty of different types of singers on XF over the years and they have done great. Opera, Soul, Balled, Rock...

I don't care to me it's about modern music not a load of rubbish that hasn't been main stream since the 1880's.

Opera is boring that why it's not in the chats.

[Loukas]

Good Start :hello:

[Jack]

This is really good.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Sam
Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

Yeah it is ridiculous to have an extremely talented person on a talent contest

It's ridiculous having an Opera Singer in a Pop Music Talent show.

I would just love to see him go tonight.

It's not a pop music talent show. It's a talent show.

Steve, Leona - They are not pop singers.
Shayne was buts that just one example.

There have been plenty of different types of singers on XF over the years and they have done great. Opera, Soul, Balled, Rock...

Leona's not a pop singer?

No, she is a balled singer. Same Difference are pop.

[Loukas]

:spin2: BETTER middle

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by mrs_rko
It's called "X Factor" not Pop Music Factor. X Factor is about something different, and that's Rhydian.

Yes he is different he is a freak from the past.

[MarkWaldorf]

Good start from Hope.

[Sam]

Originally posted by mrs_rko
It's called "X Factor" not Pop Music Factor. X Factor is about something different, and that's Rhydian.

But your only saying that because there hasnt been many opera singers on it before. If you have a show full of pop singers, the opera singer is bound to stand out - thats not having the x factors, its being an opera singer.

[Arneldo]

Phoebe is great tonight......

[Matt]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Yes he is different he is a freak from the past.

:rolleyes:

[Loukas]

YEY great :thumbs2: :thumbs2: :thumbs2:

[Redmond]

This is awful.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Phoebe is great tonight......

Yup. She is carrying the band.

[Sam]

Originally posted by MarkChap©
Originally posted by mrs_rko
Regardless of whether he goes or not now, I'm sure he'll get some kind of recording contract, he's amazing.:thumbs:

He'll release an opera album full of covers, get a number 1, then fade away.

That's why I don't believe he should win. If Dannii can't even give him the right songs, how will his career pan out? Bad covers.

He's an excellent singer, but doesn't belong in this show.

I couldnt agree more. He wont release single after single. I cant see him releasing an album of new songs either.

Hope are much worthy winners imo.

[Jack]

Best performance so far.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Sam
Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

Yeah it is ridiculous to have an extremely talented person on a talent contest

It's ridiculous having an Opera Singer in a Pop Music Talent show.

I would just love to see him go tonight.

It's not a pop music talent show. It's a talent show.

Steve, Leona - They are not pop singers.
Shayne was buts that just one example.

There have been plenty of different types of singers on XF over the years and they have done great. Opera, Soul, Balled, Rock...

Leona's not a pop singer?

No, she is a balled singer. Same Difference are pop.

And Ballads don't get in the charts do they?

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by Arneldo
Simon: "5 talents girls..."

Make that 1 talented girl and 4 back-up singers.

**** off :)

Yaaaaaaaaay Hope!

It's against fourm rules to insult members :nono:

[Loukas]

Better Than The Spice Girls :cheer2:

even tho i disagree

[MarkWaldorf]

Best performance of the night.

[Matt]

That was good.

Why did they have to add the Hung Up references though...

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
Better Than The Spice Girls :cheer2:

Anything is better than the Spice Girls live.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
Better Than The Spice Girls :cheer2:

Anything is better than the Spice Girls live.

Anything is better than the Spice Girls...

[Redmond]

Only one of Hope can sing, the rest were flat as hell.

[Sam]

Originally posted by Matt
That was good.

Why did they have to add the Hung Up references though...

Oh my.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Matt
That was good.

Why did they have to add the Hung Up references though...

Because that was in the original. Madonna's version was based on it.

[Sarah.]

I hated that performance. Hope to go.. ;]

And.. Rhydian isn't a freak. . . .wtf? He's a talented guy and has proved he can sing in different genres. :) I really hope he wins it now. He deserves it.

[Shaun]

Fantastic :bigsmile:

So far:

1 - Hope
2 - Leon
3 - Rhydian
4 - Niki

[Loukas]

Originally posted by Matt
That was good.

Why did they have to add the Hung Up references though...

maddona had that part in her song

so it was like a moden twist

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
Better Than The Spice Girls :cheer2:

Anything is better than the Spice Girls live.

The Spice Girls don't sing live anyway. :laugh:

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Redmond
Only one of Hope can sing, the rest were flat as hell.

Agreed. The backing track carried them through as well. The rest are just their to make up the numbers.

[Sam]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Sam
Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by mrs_rko
What a ridiculous song choice..

Well he is a ridiculous person to have on the X-Factor.

Yeah it is ridiculous to have an extremely talented person on a talent contest

It's ridiculous having an Opera Singer in a Pop Music Talent show.

I would just love to see him go tonight.

It's not a pop music talent show. It's a talent show.

Steve, Leona - They are not pop singers.
Shayne was buts that just one example.

There have been plenty of different types of singers on XF over the years and they have done great. Opera, Soul, Balled, Rock...

Leona's not a pop singer?

No, she is a balled singer. Same Difference are pop.

Its still classed as pop actually.

[Jack]

Originally posted by MarkChap©
Originally posted by Matt
That was good.

Why did they have to add the Hung Up references though...

Because that was in the original. Madonna's version was based on it.

Matt means the lyrics from Hung Up, i.e. "I'm hung up" and "Time goes by so slowly" etc.

[Shaun]

Gah! Can we have a filter which attacks other members of Hope than Phoebe please? :tongue:

It's hurtful to read you know...

[Billy]

Hope were horrible tonight, they have got to stop acting like slappers or else there gunna be out

[Sam]

Originally posted by Jack
Originally posted by MarkChap©
Originally posted by Matt
That was good.

Why did they have to add the Hung Up references though...

Because that was in the original. Madonna's version was based on it.

Matt means the lyrics from Hung Up, i.e. "I'm hung up" and "Time goes by so slowly" etc.

Yeah exactly. Those lines are in the original of 'Gimme Gimme Gimme'.

Madonna just took bits from that song and made her own.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Shaun
Gah! Can we have a filter which attacks other members of Hope than Phoebe please? :tongue:

It's hurtful to read you know...

Why?

[Arneldo]

so far...

1. Leon
2. Rhydian
3. Hope
4. Niki

I liked Hope, its just Rhydian has better vocals, and I loved Leon all round performance.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Shaun
Gah! Can we have a filter which attacks other members of Hope than Phoebe please? :tongue:

It's hurtful to read you know...

Why?

What a stupid question.

Because my friend is one of them...*pulls a duh face*

[Billy]

1. Rhydian
2.Leon
3.Niki
4.Hope

[MarkWaldorf]

1. Hope
2. Niki
3. Leon
4. Rhydian

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by mrs_rko
I hated that performance. Hope to go.. ;]

And.. Rhydian isn't a freak. . . .wtf? He's a talented guy and has proved he can sing in different genres. :) I really hope he wins it now. He deserves it.

He is an opera freak on the X factor which is show full of contemporary singers.

He is on the wrong type of talent show for his talent and I hope he gets the boot soon.

[dupin]

Hope were good...

Shaun, you can't angry just because people may not like Hope, or think that some of the members are good...I think they need to let Emily/Leah do more, as it's just Phoebe at the moment.

[Sam]

1. Hope
2. Leon
3. Rhydian
4. Niki

[Matt]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Shaun
Gah! Can we have a filter which attacks other members of Hope than Phoebe please? :tongue:

It's hurtful to read you know...

Why?

What a stupid question.

Because my friend is one of them...*pulls a duh face*

Oh. That explains a lot. :laugh:

[Sarah.]

Well we'll see how far he gets then.

so far;
1. Rhydian
2. Niki
3. Leon
4. Hope

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Shaun
Gah! Can we have a filter which attacks other members of Hope than Phoebe please? :tongue:

It's hurtful to read you know...

Why?

What a stupid question.

Because my friend is one of them...*pulls a duh face*

Then don't read them, or dont come onto a XF discussion topic. You can't expect everyone to like them just because your mate is in them

[Billy]

I kinda agree with Aaron, not everyone is gonna like them

[Jack]

Originally posted by Sam
Originally posted by Jack
Originally posted by MarkChap©
Originally posted by Matt
That was good.

Why did they have to add the Hung Up references though...

Because that was in the original. Madonna's version was based on it.

Matt means the lyrics from Hung Up, i.e. "I'm hung up" and "Time goes by so slowly" etc.

Yeah exactly. Those lines are in the original of 'Gimme Gimme Gimme'.

Madonna just took bits from that song and made her own.

Madonna only took the sample. Those lyrics weren't in the original at all.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by dupin
Hope were good...

Shaun, you can't angry just because people may not like Hope, or think that some of the members are good...I think they need to let Emily/Leah do more, as it's just Phoebe at the moment.

I can get as angry as I like - it's annoying to read words being thrown around like "flat", "slappers", "girls in knickers" etc...

I know it's just a part of showbiz, and that not everybody likes them, but just put yourselves in my position; it's not a nice thing to read.

[Sam]

Current Betting

Alisha Bennett 13 - 8

Leon Jackson 7 - 2

Same Difference 7 - 2

Beverley Trottman 5 - 1

Hope 8 - 1

Niki Evans 10 - 1

Rhydian Roberts 33 - 1

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Shaun
Gah! Can we have a filter which attacks other members of Hope than Phoebe please? :tongue:

It's hurtful to read you know...

Why?

What a stupid question.

Because my friend is one of them...*pulls a duh face*

Then don't read them, or dont come onto a XF discussion topic. You can't expect everyone to like them just because your mate is in them

I can read this if I want...I'm watching the X Factor, and am a forum member just like you.

[Shaun]

Beverley nooow :)

[MarkWaldorf]

Good start from Beverley.

[Sam]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by dupin
Hope were good...

Shaun, you can't angry just because people may not like Hope, or think that some of the members are good...I think they need to let Emily/Leah do more, as it's just Phoebe at the moment.

I can get as angry as I like - it's annoying to read words being thrown around like "flat", "slappers", "girls in knickers" etc...

I know it's just a part of showbiz, and that not everybody likes them, but just put yourselves in my position; it's not a nice thing to read.

Yeah, i think theres a difference between not liking someone and just throwing around pointless insults that are just rude.
But its a forum, so within reason, anyone can say what they want.

[Loukas]

1)Hope
2)Bev
3)Rhydian
4)Leon

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by dupin
Hope were good...

Shaun, you can't angry just because people may not like Hope, or think that some of the members are good...I think they need to let Emily/Leah do more, as it's just Phoebe at the moment.

I can get as angry as I like - it's annoying to read words being thrown around like "flat", "slappers", "girls in knickers" etc...

I know it's just a part of showbiz, and that not everybody likes them, but just put yourselves in my position; it's not a nice thing to read.

I'm sure its not nice, but maybe try and fend them, instead of telling people to "**** off".

People have their own opinions of Hope. I'm certainly not gonna hold back just because your mate is in the band. I would expect you to hold back if my mate was in the band. If you're hurt by the comments then the XF discussion topic isn't the best place to be.

[Matt]

Beverley is great. Definitely the leading female in the competition.

[Shaun]

Great start, but she sounded flat in the "oh, oh oh" bits...

Loving it overall. She looks great too.

[Sam]

1) Hope
2) Bev
3) Leon
4) Rhydian
5) Niki

[Jack]

Great performance. Totally out shines Niki now, as she's done for the past 3 weeks.

[MarkWaldorf]

Great performance from Beverley.

Shouldn't be bottom 2 tonight.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Sam
1) Hope
2) Bev
3) Leon
4) Rhydian
5) Niki

Agreed!

[Arneldo]

Bev was good, I enjoyed that.

[Sarah.]

It gave me a headache.

[Jackie]

Bev was good her choice of song was good.

[Shaun]

It's not very fair that Beverley gets her whole class in the audience :sad:

Emily's given 3 tickets to give to people. Just 3.

[Arneldo]

1. Leon/Bev
3. Rhydian
4. Hope
5. Niki

[Sam]

I liked Beverly.

[Jack]

She needs to build a fanbase, because technically she's great.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Jack
She needs to build a fanbase, because technically she's great.

Mhm! Much better than Niki.

[Matt]

Beverley was fantastic... by far the best performance tonight

[MarkWaldorf]

Alisha's turn.

[Sam]

Yay Alisha, i so hope she gets through to next week.

[Arneldo]

Odds after Bev's song....

Alisha - 13/1
Same Difference - 3\1
Leon - 7/2
Beverley - 7/1
Hope - 9/1
Niki - 10/1
Rhydian - 33/1

Alisha has her work cut out for her. This needs to be good

[MarkWaldorf]

I'm mixed with her tonight.

She's got a boring song.

[Shaun]

Grrr...sister decides to start hoovering. Much shouting from me ensues :)

[Jack]

I'd like to see Niki go this week, even though it isn't going to happen. She's been consistantly bad for the past 3 weeks or so.

[Arneldo]

I've hated this song ever since Chenai sang it in series 2.

[Conzors]

Alishas good this week.

[Jack]

Her voice isn't strong enough for this song.

[MarkWaldorf]

Chenai went bottom 2 with this song. I hope this song isn't a jinx.

[Matt]

I don't like it that much... I think Alisha will go tonight

[Sam]

I think shes got a bad song choice this week. Quite forgetful but a nice try. I really like her personality though.

[Arneldo]

Oh.. Alisha. It's okay. Bit hiccupee. Also, what is she wearing?

[Shaun]

Quite a lot of awful notes from Alisha...

[Jack]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Oh.. Alisha. It's okay. Bit hiccupee. Also, what is she wearing?

LMAO! She looks like a caveman.