Hope vs W4

[Tom]

Just been watching the judges homes stage on youtube and I came across the clip of the groups which is here (http://youtube.com/watch?v=LPwCnaSonV0).

It is pretty obvious that either Hope or W4 would have got through, not none and not both. 6 weeks on, did Simon make the right decision?

[Billy]

No, W4 were better singers

[XxShortyxX]

W4 are better singers, I do like Hope. Me thinks W4 should of got through.

[GiRTh]

Both. W4 were better singers but Hope are more glamorous. Simon should have put both of them through and got rid of Same difference. He's the one who keep going on about how it's a talent competition.

[Shaun]

Guess who I chose :shocked:

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Both. W4 were better singers but Hope are more glamorous. Simon should have put both of them through and got rid of Same difference. He's the one who keep going on about how it's a talent competition.


He should of put both of them through and not Chav-Proof.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Originally posted by GiRTh
Both. W4 were better singers but Hope are more glamorous. Simon should have put both of them through and got rid of Same difference. He's the one who keep going on about how it's a talent competition.


He should of put both of them through and not Chav-Proof. Thats a good option too.:thumbs:

[Tom]

W4 were better vocally but Hope look more the part, I would say it was a hard one but my vote would *just* go to W4.

[Shaun]

His 3 should have been Hope, W4 and Ghostt.

[Tom]

Originally posted by Shaun
His 3 should have been Hope, W4 and Ghostt.

I think Futureproof and Ghostt are interchangeable and probably would have gone when Futureproof did but I do think that they should have been his three.

[xDramatick]

W4
they actually looked like a band, and all of them could sing.

Hope.
they don't look like a band, always fighting, and only one shows she can sing.

Such a hard decision :wink:

[Wasted]

I like Hope but W4 were better. I hate the fact that in boot camp, they were great but all Simon could say was that they looked like the Stepford Wives or something.

[CassetteFinger]

W4 were better. Had much better voices but just wernt as sexy as hope even though two aint good lookers. Same difference of course should have been put through in the first place. there the only band which hasent been in the bottom two, or voted off. It should have been Same difference,W4 and Ghostt.

[SairBabi92]

W4 Should have got through above Hope
&
Pheobe should have got through a solo artist instead of Emily!

[Ruth*Star]

They both should be there, FP shouldn't of got though, they were flat.