Beverley Out - Right Decision?

[SairBabi92]

?

[Jackie]

No wrong decision.

[Shaun]

Yes and No - she shouldn't have gone, but I wanted her to against Hope, of course. Leon should have gone.

[Sarah.]

Definitely the wrong decision.

[BigSister]

no wrong decsion out of the 2

[KKBL]

wrong desicion but atleste shes not sad about it.

[Billy]

Right decision shes not gunna sell any records

[xDramatick]

NO.
Hope should've gone.
They were much worse, and have been.

Then again, only two people actually sung tonight >.> Bev&Phoebe.

[XxShortyxX]

Why is Leon still there!!! He is rubbish, Bev is a milion times better then him! The show is a joke.

She shouldn't of gone.

[CassetteFinger]

Yeah out of the two anyway, but Leon shoul be out of there. Beverley was the weakest this week though.

[Z]

No, she was better than Hope, but yes because I love Hope + they will sell records, Beverley wouldn't, she shares the same demographics as Niki. Very talented singer though, I hope she pursues a career.

[Bells]

No, completely wrong - I'm upset about it. She delivered such a great performance, bless her - even if it wasn't her best. I predicted correctly in that people just don't pick up the phone and vote for her... and they didn't. I'm surprised Sharon didn't keep her in, but there you go.

I actually am shocked - it's kind of put me off a bit now.

[Arneldo]

No.

Worst decision of the series. Beverley actually had talent.

[Matt08]

I think it was the right decision in the long run. I think Hope have the most potential in today's music industry and I think Beverley will probably be offered a record deal anyway.

[Tom]

Beverley was brilliant but she had a bad night, and the worst performance of the night so she deserved to go. People just assumed she would be safe because she is good. Hopefully it will be a shock to the rest of them so they all feel the need to up their games next week as tonight proved a bad performance and you are out.

[Red Moon]

Commercially yes it was the right decision. However in terms of pure talent Beverley was far better than all of Hope with the possible exception of Phoebe Brown who is a very very promising singer for a 16 year old. She saved Hope tonight.

[Hugo]

The whole show is a completely contrived planned joke, it's quite funny. Sharon will have knew who was bottem in the voting and she didn't want to look bad.

[XxShortyxX]

For me, the show is a joke, and it's no longer a talent show where people who can actually sing stay. It's about who the teeage girls fancy, as in Leon, who Bev is miles better.

[Matt]

It was the worst decision ever. I'm not too happy about it.

[Billy]

Aw was it fixed tooperfect? Beverley got the lowest votes, which is fair. Shes out, as she got the lowest votes, which is fair

[Matt]

Originally posted by Billy
Aw was it fixed tooperfect? Beverley got the lowest votes, which is fair. Shes out, as she got the lowest votes, which is fair

You never know with telephone voting nowadays :thumbs:

[Billy]

No way would ITV risk rigging the votes, after everything thats happened the past year

[XxShortyxX]

ITV have been known to rig the votes.

[Billy]

No they havent? Theres been mistakes, as in the votes have been received too late, but they wouldnt rig something as big as x factor

[XxShortyxX]

In other programmes, GMTV, I'm A Celeb. So if they can do it on there, what's to say they don't with the X Factor? And who's know's for sure who had the lowest votes or the height's.

[Red Moon]

They wouldn't dare to rig a vote again they would get jumped on from a great height.

[Billy]

they dindt intetnionally do it for them I dont think,anyways it would defeat the purpose nof the show, why would they try and get an upopular act thorugh, if nobodys gunna buy their records

[Tom]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
In other programmes, GMTV, I'm A Celeb. So if they can do it on there, what's to say they don't with the X Factor? And who's know's for sure who had the lowest votes or the height's.

GMTV isn't a program its a seperate channel to ITV

[Red Moon]

Interesting hearing the judges comments on the ITV2 repeat. I bet they were as surprised as her fans she went tonight. They all seemed to think she should have made it to the final 5.

[Wasted]

It was the right decision to have her in the bottom, but she performed better than Hope so the overall decision wasn't the right one IMO.

[Captain.Remy]

No it's the worst decision of the series.

[Callum]

Yes. She was good but she wouldn't have sold millions of records or anything, and Hope outsung Bev by miles in the sing off.

[Kristen]

It was the wrong decision.
Excuse the pun but Hope are hopeless!

[Sunny_01]

I think if you are talking in terms of talent then no it was not the right decision, however if you are talking in terms of marketability then I suppose the group Hope will be far easier to sell as a package.

[Spike]

I think it was the right decision. Beverley has more vocal talent but she isn't the X Factor. In 5 years time I can see Hope getting hit records but I can only see Beverley in a hotel.

[:)tom:)]

no way it should have been leon

[TopzTom]

Terrible decision, although maybe Louis will finally wake up and realise Niki could make the final with the right song choices... She's statistically the public's favourite 25+, but will only get the votes if she gets the songs.

[Nicky.]

Deffinetley!
I have never liked her since 1st audition!
FINALLY someone saw sense!