Will Simon give other Hope members a chance?

[MarkWaldorf]

After last nights disaster, do you think Simon will start giving the other girls more lines? If he wants them to survive, I think he should.

I actually can't remember their auditions so I can't comment on how good they are, apart from Phoebe.

[Arneldo]

He hasn't given them a chance to sing for a reason, they can't.

[XxShortyxX]

Yeah I think he should, although Phoebe is the best singer. Ther others are good if I remember.

[MarkWaldorf]

LOL Arneldo.

Well there are two songs each next week, so they should get a chance.

[Billy]

Aaron youve changed yer tune. You said Emily was fantastic in auditions

[KKBL]

yeah i think next week the lead vocalist should be anyone except for Phoebe

[XxShortyxX]

They can sing, just not as good as Niki or Rydian.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
Aaron youve changed yer tune. You said Emily was fantastic in auditions

Of the 1.2 seconds we saw her, yes she was good. But I also thought Emily (The Happy Slapping One) was good when I saw her. People's opinions change. Simon knows his stuff and he obviously inst allowing Woo-Woo Girls to sing for a reason, they can't. The other 4 are there for one reason only, to look good, and IMO they don't even do that well.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Billy
Aaron youve changed yer tune. You said Emily was fantastic in auditions

Of the 1.2 seconds we saw her, yes she was good. But I also thought Emily (The Happy Slapping One) was good when I saw her. People's opinions change. Simon knows his stuff and he obviously inst allowing Woo-Woo Girls to sing for a reason, they can't. The other 4 are there for one reason only, to look good, and IMO they don't even do that well.


Whe nthey sung Back to Black they all sung that really well, they can sing, but like I said, just not as good as Rydian or Niki.

Look good or not, if that was the case they would be getting through.

I think that about Leon, he is only there because he looks good (which he don't anyway)

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Originally posted by Arneldo
Originally posted by Billy
Aaron youve changed yer tune. You said Emily was fantastic in auditions

Of the 1.2 seconds we saw her, yes she was good. But I also thought Emily (The Happy Slapping One) was good when I saw her. People's opinions change. Simon knows his stuff and he obviously inst allowing Woo-Woo Girls to sing for a reason, they can't. The other 4 are there for one reason only, to look good, and IMO they don't even do that well.


Whe nthey sung Back to Black they all sung that really well, they can sing, but like I said, just not as good as Rydian or Niki.

Look good or not, if that was the case they would be getting through.

I think that about Leon, he is only there because he looks good (which he don't anyway)

Neither of Hope got through on their own for a reason, they weren't good enough, and that is still the case. Phoebe carries the band, and shown in last night show, she messed up and I can see now why she didn't make it into Top 3 girls. If you put any half decent girls together, with a good backing track they will sound okay.

i think you are obsessed with people looking good, and you suspect that the only reason guys go far in every competition. You bring Leon into almost every XF topic. This is about Hope :thumbs:

[XxShortyxX]

Because it is true, more women watch Reality TV programmes then guys. They vote more, and they ent going to vote a girl, they are going to vote for a good looking guy, 9/10 a guy will win a reality TV show, wheather they are rubbish or not, if Leon was a girl he would of been out by now.

I think Phoebe should of gone sole, and audtioned on her own.

[Billy]

"neither of hope got throug for a reason, they werent good enough" Wrong. There was only 6 places available, they were obviously allt alented tog et through to bootcamp, its just htere werent enough places

[dupin]

Simon confirmed that they'll all be singing next week on Xtra Factor.

I think some people's opinions are bizarre ... clearly they're good enough, they're in the final 5.

[Wildcat!]

He probably will because the public definitely isnt buying into this Phoebe is great propaganda that he is trying to make us believe. Phoebe has got an immature voice. She is OK, but she cant carry the group or be solo. She sounds horrible when she tries to lead, and off key all the time. Hope was alright when they all sang together is harmony. Like their Umbrella performance, that was pretty good, but ever since they singled out Phoebe, they are hopeless!

[Matt]

Originally posted by Arneldo
He hasn't given them a chance to sing for a reason, they can't.

:hello::hello::hello::hello::hello:

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Because it is true, more women watch Reality TV programmes then guys. They vote more, and they ent going to vote a girl, they are going to vote for a good looking guy, 9/10 a guy will win a reality TV show, wheather they are rubbish or not, if Leon was a girl he would of been out by now.

It's funny how you only think this about acts you don't like. Bitter much?

"neither of hope got throug for a reason, they werent good enough" Wrong. There was only 6 places available, they were obviously allt alented tog et through to bootcamp, its just htere werent enough places

They weren't good enough to make further alone because the judges were right in thinking they were not good enough alone. As a group they were better, but IMO they have got into Top 5 on hype and only mildly on talent. At the beginning I said this group were the most over rated XF act ever, and I stand by that. None of them are brilliant singers. A group of oka-ish singers with one stand out star, who last night messed up.

[XxShortyxX]

It's not about being bitter, I have no liked Leon.

Phoebe (I have always thought this) should of sung on her own, as she has the best voice, but the others can sing, just not as good as her.