I'm a huge Rhydian Fan......

[Tom4784]

But I'm not sure if I want him to win. I feel as though the X factor will just turn him into another Paul Potts (like we need another) He's got so much potential but X Factor will take him down the cover albums route. I think he'd be great going down a Josh Groban route (classical voice mixed with contemporary sounds) Which is possible but not likely. Another route he could be great at is a Nightwish route (operatic sounds mixed with rock) Which he could be very good at but He wouldn't be able to go down that route since it doesn't mesh with the X Factor image.

I think Rhydian is better then a cheap cover album, which winning the X factor will provide so I don't think he should win, let him get a contract on his own terms....I think.

So what's your opinion?

[Red Moon]

I dislike opera and it belongs in the Opera House and not on ITV and defiantly not on the X Factor.

[Mrluvaluva]

Well done you for sharing your problem with us. :joker: I bet you feel better for offloading that.

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Red Moon
I dislike opera and it belongs in the Opera House and not on ITV and defiantly not on the X Factor.

I so agree.

[Bells]

However wise an opinion that may be, fans don't tend to think about things in the long term when it comes to voting for a winner. Furthermore, Rhydian himself would really want to win as winning a big show like TXF is such an achievement. Nobody tends to think about the consequences.

Whilst I would like to see him win for the reasons I mentioned, I don't think he's cut out for doing just cover albums for the next year. At the same time though the choice doesn't lie within Rhydian's control at all: it's something the show needs to take into consideration, which it clearly isn't.