Should John have got immunity to the final?

[Mike]

Can't deny that John did a great job but do you think he deserved immunity to the final this early on?

[Loukas]

i dunno... i think its a little too early but hes a good housemate!

[Shaun]

I loved it, but I imagine in a couple of days time I'll wish he hadn't...

[Arneldo]

Nope, not for an hour and half work. Maybe if he did it for a day or two.

[BigSister]

no even though i like him i dont think he should have got uimmunity maybe escaping first nomos and a party

[Callum]

Not sure. He seems like a good housemate though

[Wasted]

If you look at Makosi and the secret missions she did, they were less embarassing but much more difficult to do, and yet she only earned a week's immunity with each task. So I think his immunity should only be a week long too. And if he failed, the punishment should've been being up for the first public vote only instead of every public vote. A pass to the final, as well as a party, is a bit much.

I think they should've forced him to choose between the immunity and the party at least. :bigsmile:

[Gemmer-x]

I think he did a great job, tried his best, had me in stiches but im not sure if it was enough to win immunity...

[DamonJ]

In my opinion, I think he deserved it. The embarassment he had to go through must have been torture, especially when it was people he didn't even know. And I am glad he has won immunity as I like him as a housemates, so, in a sentence, yes and I am glad he has immunity. :thumbs2:

[DamonJ]

In my opinion, I think he deserved it. The embarassment he had to go through must have been torture, especially when it was people he didn't even know. And I am glad he has won immunity as I like him as a housemates, so, in a sentence, yes and I am glad he has immunity. :thumbs2:

[DamonJ]

In my opinion, I think he deserved it. The embarassment he had to go through must have been torture, especially when it was people he didn't even know. And I am glad he has won immunity as I like him as a housemates, so, in a sentence, yes and I am glad he has immunity. :thumbs2:

[Redmond]

The thing I think is, even if he didn't get the immunity until the Final...after doing all that he would've made the final week anyway, he seems a genuinely decent chap.

[CassetteFinger]

Nah to early, but i like him. So its alright.

[Geraldo]

I dont think he should have won a place in the final !! Not on day one !

He seems a nice guy ! but i dont see him as a winner ! not from my first impressions anyway !!

I posted a topic earlyer saying .....

when matt lucas is finished as the hijacker could the next hijack change the rules matt has made

ie. John place in the final ??

[andybigbro]

Yes
He was Hilarious

[Spike]

He was great last night but it's too early to be giving people a ticket to the final

[Nicky.]

No, definetly not,
it wasnt like he did anything major, all he did was massage someone and shouted cramp..

[x_mel_x]

Maybe saved from eviction for a week but not getting to the final-its too early!

[Dan_]

Getting a passage to the final is a bit much for me.He did great but perhaps being illegible to be nominated for the first couple of evictions may have been better.

[cgimusic]

I don't actually mind. I think that he hasn't "earned" his place in the final but it will be funny now he doesn't have to worry about what the other housemates think of him.

[Captain.Remy]

He deserved it because what he has done was very very embarassing, it was very hards and unpredictable ! Well done !

[ProjectWeirdo]

Hmm... I'm not sure. He definitely deserved a prize after all he did last night, but I think that prize is just TOO good.

And plus, it's not really fair...

[Jackie]

No i don't think that was fair maybe first week but not all the way through.

[Ruth*Star]

No...It's way to early to have a pass to the final, its unfair on the other housemates.

[:)tom:)]

it was really mean and hard what he had to do but if it was immune from the first nomonation it would have been better

[Matt]

No. Far too early.

[Dan_]

Do you think another Hijacker could set another task to put his immunity in jeopardy? Or is his place in the final assured?