who had the most sucessfull comeback?

[001steven]

i think britney did i mean her album got to no.2 and the her singles have done really well WITHOUT promotion. where as kylies promotion was eveywhere i.e GMTV ,papers ect and her album flopped and entred at no.4.

[001steven]

and kylie has barley sold 400,000 copies

[MarkWaldorf]

Britney, she had her most successful chartings since "Baby One More Time", and Gimme More has sold almost 5 Million copies WW. 2 Hearts hasn't had an impact what so ever.

[001steven]

wot gimme more has sold over 5million?? or her album? kylie was OVER promted shes blaming EMI for her flop but really people are tired of kylie... she tries to copy madonna everytime kylie was hoping she would do better then confessions... which was no.1 in 40 countrys

[Billy]

Kylies album went in at number 4? Thats not a flop thats good. If Britney's life wasnt a mess she wouldnt have been as successfull, but I prefer Kylies new material omre

[001steven]

it was a flop my aunt is a hardcore kylie fan and she was dissapointed with it...britneys album was better then X what sort of names that for an album... kylie tries to be madonna who is 100 times better

[Billy]

Number four in the charts is not a flop atalll =| And in my opinion Kylies album is better than Britneys, although I love them both

[Shaun]

Both have done well.

[Jack]

On sales etc, Britney has done better (and I prefer her album). They're not exactly competing though and Kylie still done extremely well, especially considering she overcame cancer.

However, Britney's reputation is tarnished and unfortunately will never make a true "comeback" (in the sense that she returns to how she used to be).

[SairBabi92]

Kylie IMO.

[Ross]

I love them both.

But Britney's comeback was like "WOW!", so I voted her.

[001steven]

and britney is sexy...so is kylie

[Princess]

Take That :bigsmile: Always go for option C :tongue:

Outta those 2 though I'd say its pretty equal-Britney with songs and Kylie with tour.

[Wasted]

I'm not really a fan of either of them, but I prefer Britney's songs and I think she's sold more. But Kylie's new material is good too, they're good at what they do but it's not the sort of thing I'd listen too.

But obviously Kylie has had the better year overall, because of everything that's been going on in Britney's life, and Kylie defeating cancer.