PDA

View Full Version : Should bands be allowed?

podge2007
27-01-2008, 11:05 PM
Do you think that bands with instruments should be allowed to audition?

I know it is predominately a pop orientated show but I think having bands would make the live shows more interesting. The X-Factor could find the next U2 or the Arctic Monkeys and it would increase the chances of the Groups Category winning. Bands are more commercial in recent years with some of the biggest selling albums of the decade being released by bands such as Coldplay, The Killers, Snow Patrol, The Scissor Sisters, Keane and McFly.

The public could have more choice and it might stop the boring Shayne Ward types winning. It could also make the show more credible and relevant to today's music industry.
KKBL
27-01-2008, 11:15 PM
i think they should.every year the winners been pop we need something different.
ThisIsMarie
27-01-2008, 11:24 PM
No! X Faxtor is pop.
Z
28-01-2008, 08:51 PM
They had the MacDonald brothers, who were rubbish, but I agree they should encourage all genres to audition - though it is a pop contest, so I think it really depends on the type of music the group plays.
FictitiousHouse
28-01-2008, 08:55 PM
It will happen exactly how Simon Cowell wants it to happen. Its like that game, "Simon says" :laugh:
FictitiousHouse
28-01-2008, 08:56 PM
Originally posted by Z
They had the MacDonald brothers, who were rubbish, but I agree they should encourage all genres to audition - though it is a pop contest, so I think it really depends on the type of music the group plays.

I hated the Macdonald brothers, utter rubbish imo :bored:
xDramatick
28-01-2008, 09:12 PM
Originally posted by ThisIsMarie
No! X Faxtor is pop.

No its not.
Not everyone there sang pop.
Ray - Swing/Jazz/Blues.
Ben - Rock.
Leona - Ballad.
Tabby - Rock.
Rhydian - Opera.
Kimberley - Country.

They all specialize in certain genre, like every singer does.

I think bands should be allowed.
Then we'd see proper music, proper talent, and it'd definately be interesting to see vocal groups against bands.
Dan_
28-01-2008, 10:38 PM
It would be good to see some acts that played their own instruments.I think we'd end up getting better performances as they would have songs better suited to the acts.
GiRTh
29-01-2008, 06:49 PM
There's not much point. they'll never win.
Billy
29-01-2008, 06:51 PM
I dont think theres a rule against it tbh, buut, acts like that have more credibility imo