The worst Eye yet

[housem8]

Just wondering what is the worst Eye to be posted on this forum or the worst big brother Eye that you have seen out of them all

[MrGaryy]

Theres been loads of eyes that are basically BB6 with a paint job done on them, I wonder why anyone would even try to pass of as official. But nobody is going to critises anyone elses work on here - were too nice.

[housem8]

Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Theres been loads of eyes that are basically BB6 with a paint job done on them, I wonder why anyone would even try to pass of as official. But nobody is going to critises anyone elses work on here - were too nice.

I think we can sift through all the official Eyes and come up with a bad one from the bunch and in regards to upsetting someone elses work on here, well thats just regrettable. Everyone has the right to criticise someone elses work and to be a designer you have to accept that critique, I know I would

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Theres been loads of eyes that are basically BB6 with a paint job done on them, I wonder why anyone would even try to pass of as official. But nobody is going to critises anyone elses work on here - were too nice.

I think we can sift through all the official Eyes and come up with a bad one from the bunch and in regards to upsetting someone elses work on here, well thats just regrettable. Everyone has the right to criticise someone elses work and to be a designer you have to accept that critique, I know I would

Why bother ?

[housem8]

Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Theres been loads of eyes that are basically BB6 with a paint job done on them, I wonder why anyone would even try to pass of as official. But nobody is going to critises anyone elses work on here - were too nice.

I think we can sift through all the official Eyes and come up with a bad one from the bunch and in regards to upsetting someone elses work on here, well thats just regrettable. Everyone has the right to criticise someone elses work and to be a designer you have to accept that critique, I know I would

Why bother ?

Because its fun

[Mrluvaluva]

This one (http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=81641#pid1173978)

[Sam!]

Why don't you make an eye then we can be critiques?.... because its fun. :thumbs:

[Shaun]

Don't lie, Baz. That's the best.

I think this thread will probably be locked / lead to arguments.

[MrGaryy]

I have a feeling we will be waiting a while before we get to see housem8's eye...

[housem8]

Originally posted by Mrluvaluva
This one (http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=81641#pid1173978)

Thats a bad Eye :laugh::laugh:

[housem8]

Originally posted by Scampi
Why don't you make an eye then we can be critiques?.... because its fun. :thumbs:

Because I dont know how to make one and if I did I would be happy for it to be criticised okay!!

[housem8]

Originally posted by Shaun
Don't lie, Baz. That's the best.

I think this thread will probably be locked / lead to arguments.

Why is going to be locked?

Are the members here that argumentative all the time

[housem8]

Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
I have a feeling we will be waiting a while before we get to see housem8's eye...

Theres no need to rub it in :sad:

[Shaun]

Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Shaun
Don't lie, Baz. That's the best.

I think this thread will probably be locked / lead to arguments.

Why is going to be locked?

Are the members here that argumentative all the time

Well, aside from the obvious answer being yes, it's inevitable that you'll offend someone by claiming their eye is the worst ever, and to be honest this isn't really productive.

It seems you just want to criticise for the fun of it, which is a bit twattish tbh. Constructive criticism is fine, but there's no point in this.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
I have a feeling we will be waiting a while before we get to see housem8's eye...

Theres no need to rub it in :sad:

There is really, when you say you enjoy saying people's eyes are crap!

[Conor]

Its 100% stingy to insult others work just for a laugh. Its not fair. People put plenty of time into making eyes. I dont see a problem with 'Its not the best, a new colour could look better' but something like 'lol thats so crap its unbeleivable!' is going to lead to even more rows and clashes. We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

However, out of the real eyes, series 8 (Test card) was horrid :P

[Matt]

Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

[housem8]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Shaun
Don't lie, Baz. That's the best.

I think this thread will probably be locked / lead to arguments.

Why is going to be locked?

Are the members here that argumentative all the time

Well, aside from the obvious answer being yes, it's inevitable that you'll offend someone by claiming their eye is the worst ever, and to be honest this isn't really productive.

It seems you just want to criticise for the fun of it, which is a bit twattish tbh. Constructive criticism is fine, but there's no point in this.

Is that (yes) to the members being argumentative and this thread being locked?

I didnt realise that this thread would cause problems, lock it then and I shall give it up as a bad job. I just thought it would be a bit of fun criticising Eyes. If members are going to be offended then just forget it.

I dont need the (twattish) remark though

[Conor]

You seriously didn't think members would be offended?

Look at it this way. You spend about a week painting a picture. Your really proud of it and then post it on TiBB. Someone suggests a 'Post rubbish art here' thread Your piece is included in it. Think how you would feel.

[housem8]

Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
I have a feeling we will be waiting a while before we get to see housem8's eye...

Theres no need to rub it in :sad:

There is really, when you say you enjoy saying people's eyes are c**p!

I dont enjoy calling members Eyes crap. I just though that a few Eyes may be posted and we would choose the bad ones from the bunch.

I have seen quite a few criticisms on Eyes on here already so dont say members dont criticise when they do.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Shaun
Don't lie, Baz. That's the best.

I think this thread will probably be locked / lead to arguments.

Why is going to be locked?

Are the members here that argumentative all the time

Well, aside from the obvious answer being yes, it's inevitable that you'll offend someone by claiming their eye is the worst ever, and to be honest this isn't really productive.

It seems you just want to criticise for the fun of it, which is a bit twattish tbh. Constructive criticism is fine, but there's no point in this.

Is that (yes) to the members being argumentative and this thread being locked?

I didnt realise that this thread would cause problems, lock it then and I shall give it up as a bad job. I just thought it would be a bit of fun criticising Eyes. If members are going to be offended then just forget it.

I dont need the (twattish) remark though

What aspect of saying other members work is rubbish could poosibly be fun? How coyld they not be offended!

[housem8]

Originally posted by Conor
Its 100% stingy to insult others work just for a laugh. Its not fair. People put plenty of time into making eyes. I dont see a problem with 'Its not the best, a new colour could look better' but something like 'lol thats so c**p its unbeleivable!' is going to lead to even more rows and clashes. We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

However, out of the real eyes, series 8 (Test card) was horrid :P

Okay I get all your points and stuff, how about just the official big brother Eyes then, or is anyone worried what Daniel might think :laugh::laugh:

[housem8]

Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

[Conor]

Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

I've only ever read constructive critisizm in the other threads (minus the joke eye threads there purposly to get joke replys)

[housem8]

Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Shaun
Don't lie, Baz. That's the best.

I think this thread will probably be locked / lead to arguments.

Why is going to be locked?

Are the members here that argumentative all the time

Well, aside from the obvious answer being yes, it's inevitable that you'll offend someone by claiming their eye is the worst ever, and to be honest this isn't really productive.

It seems you just want to criticise for the fun of it, which is a bit twattish tbh. Constructive criticism is fine, but there's no point in this.

Is that (yes) to the members being argumentative and this thread being locked?

I didnt realise that this thread would cause problems, lock it then and I shall give it up as a bad job. I just thought it would be a bit of fun criticising Eyes. If members are going to be offended then just forget it.

I dont need the (twattish) remark though

What aspect of saying other members work is rubbish could poosibly be fun? How coyld they not be offended!

Isnt criticising fun in a critics Eyes?

Take the Art world for example

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

He meant that you need to be able to defrenciate between critisising professionals work and the work of amatuers i.e us.

[housem8]

Originally posted by Conor
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

I've only ever read constructive critisizm in the other threads (minus the joke eye threads there purposly to get joke replys)

I havent been here long enough to know that. I just saw members making critical remarks about Eyes and house designs so I felt it worth a try bunching them together

[Jack]

Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

There's a difference between making constructive criticism against an eye in a thread which was posted by a member, with the intention to receive opinions and comments, to criticisng something for the sake of criticism and "fun", without their permission. No one takes themselves seriously when posting fan made eyes, like Conor said we do it for fun, we are not professional graphic designers.

[housem8]

Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

He meant that you need to be able to defrenciate between critisising professionals work and the work of amatuers i.e us.

Please give me a chance to get my replies in, there is only so much time and my typing aint that fast okay. I have said (if you read) that I have seen Eyes and houses criticised in other threads and I chose to bunch it together in one thread which I felt was okay. Apparently I can see it is a bad idea and have requested that the opinions of the members in this thread be taken into accouint and the thread can be locked

Is that enough for you mate

[housem8]

Originally posted by Jack
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

There's a difference between making constructive criticism against an eye in a thread which was posted by a member, with the intention to receive opinions and comments, to criticisng something for the sake of criticism and "fun", without their permission. No one takes themselves seriously when posting fan made eyes, like Conor said we do it for fun, we are not professional graphic designers.

Thanks for you post Jack but I have pretty much emphasised my reasons in my various posts within

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

He meant that you need to be able to defrenciate between critisising professionals work and the work of amatuers i.e us.

Please give me a chance to get my replies in, there is only so much time and my typing aint that fast okay. I have said (if you read) that I have seen Eyes and houses criticised in other threads and I chose to bunch it together in one thread which I felt was okay. Apparently I can see it is a bad idea and have requested that the opinions of the members in this thread be taken into accouint and the thread can be locked

Is that enough for you mate

Its not my problem if me and Conor happen to post at the same time.

[housem8]

Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Originally posted by housem8
Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Conor

We are not proffesional graphics designers, so we shouldn't be critisized.

Exactly - a line has to be drawn somewhere...

So its alright to criticise Eyes in other threads but not all in one thread like mine?

He meant that you need to be able to defrenciate between critisising professionals work and the work of amatuers i.e us.

Please give me a chance to get my replies in, there is only so much time and my typing aint that fast okay. I have said (if you read) that I have seen Eyes and houses criticised in other threads and I chose to bunch it together in one thread which I felt was okay. Apparently I can see it is a bad idea and have requested that the opinions of the members in this thread be taken into accouint and the thread can be locked

Is that enough for you mate

Its not my problem if me and Conor happen to post at the same time.

Fair enough.

I have opened another thread which I hope is more satisfactory