Whos your fave judge? (BGT)

[Harry!]

If this thread has been done before dont worry ok.
http://talent.itv.com/images/contents/judgesAndHosts/simonCowell.jpg
Simon Cowell
http://talent.itv.com/images/contents/judgesAndHosts/piersMorgan.jpg
Piers Morgan
http://talent.itv.com/images/contents/judgesAndHosts/amandaHolden.jpg
Amanda Holden

Amanda if in a disagreement with Piers she usaly refers to the 'forth judge'

[Riz]

Simon always.

[*mazedsalv**]

Simon and Amanda.

[Spike]

Simon

[Sam]

Simon, the other two just irritate me. :tongue:

[Harry!]

Amanda, The other twos voises (especily Simon) irritate me.

[_Tom_]

Amanda.

[Nicola]

Simon Cowell for me! Although I also keep getting told I fancy Piers (which I don't, everyone I know will already be ribbing me about it before long!)

[Princess]

Simon or Amanda. Piers is just beyond annoying.

[Dan_]

Simon all the way.Amanda is too nice and Piers is just a prick.

[Jack_]

Simon, he tells it like it is and he's the only one there who I think is actually on this planet. :laugh:

[Hugo]

Simon he is honest. Amanda is just plastic and fake who always agrees with Piers. Piers is just desperate and tries to act clever.

[*mazedsalv**]

I think Amanda's far from plastic.

[Christina]

Deffo Simon! x

[Chri$]

Simon

I like Amanda but she likes the naked men acts a lot

[MrGaryy]

Simon is the only one who knows what he's talking about!

[BigSister]

Simon for me pires annoys me lol. Amandas ok though but yeah simon for me

[Princess]

Originally posted by ©hris
Simon

I like Amanda but she likes the naked men acts a lot

Well she's not exactly going to dislike them! :laugh:

[Hugo]

Originally posted by *mazedsalv**
I think Amanda's far from plastic.

When I mean plastic I mean personality and crocodile tears ect. And look around her lips tonight. Surgery gone wrong or natural disaster?

[supernoodles!]

Amanda,on the whole she gets it right and i did like simon cowell but after he pressed amandas buzzer when visage were performing i think hes a noooob!I just think piers is a tosser full stop.

[*mazedsalv**]

Originally posted by tooperfect
Originally posted by *mazedsalv**
I think Amanda's far from plastic.

When I mean plastic I mean personality and crocodile tears ect. And look around her lips tonight. Surgery gone wrong or natural disaster?

I know what plastic means :rolleyes: Lol

[Tom]

Amanda has had loads of botox but shes still my favourite judge by far. Simon Cowell just believes his own hype and is only really interested in the singers and Piers is just a miserable old man with no sense of reality. Amanda knows how to criticise without taking it too far. I really don't understand the hate some people show towards her.

[stacey]

I really like both Simon and Amanda but Piers really grates on me it's like he's trying to be Simon when he's being mean and it just really doesn't work

[jkp44]

I like amanda and simon, i find that piers tries to be like the nasty one.

[MR.K!]

haha thats such a funny pic of Amanda.. i guess i like Simon as he tells the blatent truth i also like Amada although she is so weak to Kiddie acts Arghh !

[JeanP!]

Amanda. I hate Simon and i hate Piers too

[Sam1994]

Simon, he seems to be the only one who knows what he's talking about.

How did Piers get picked as a judge for this, he's a newspaper editor. What's that got to do with talent?

[Bells]

I tend to agree with Simon the most when it comes to opinions, and I think he can bring humour to the show in his own way. He seems to have commanded a lot of respect, which is a good thing.

Amanda annoys me. I'll look past the fact that I had no idea who she was before BGT, and only knew her for cheating on her husband (Les Dennis, for those of you that don't know). Anyone who cheats on Les Dennis after years of marriage can't be the most likeable person. Anyway, based on her judging skills, the way she behaved with Strike made uncomfortable viewing - although the same could be said for Simon and Sophie Mei, I agree. She seems to have a fairly decent head on her shoulders compared to other female judges I've seen - I'll give her that. But her annoying shoulder dance and constant 'agreeing with Piers' starts to bug me after a while.

And Piers is just cringeworthy in general - won't even go into details. But overall, I think all three are a good panel (when they're not bickering too much), and add their own unique perspectives to the show. I just really don't agree with some of the acts Piers/Amanda jointly agreed to put through, that Simon stood against. That's another reason why I prefer Simon.

[Billy]

Simon Cowell :) I agree with Ash on manda, although I really dislikeher espeally her attitude with the magician

[Tasha_x]

Simon, he's my favourite on X factor as well