The pool cleaner with a sob story was rubbish

[Tom]

He couldn't even sing, if he hadn't said his sob story (or rather the producers hadn't forced him to say it) he wouldn't have got through :yuk:

[KKBL]

same as the guy who wanted to make his real parents proud.but he was even worse:yuk:

[Billy]

Thank god someone agreed. He was crap

[Jackie]

It did bring tears to my eyes though.

[Legend]

The experts seemed to think different. :dazzler:

[Dan_]

I wouldn't go as far as to say he was rubbish but yeah, without the sob story he probably wouldn't have made it.

[xDramatick]

He wasn't rubbish but he wasn't great.
He wouldn't have gotten through without a sob story.

[LemonJam]

He really was awful. If he makes it to the final 12 the show is a joke.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Legend
The experts seemed to think different. :dazzler:

The same experts who put teh McDonald Brothers through?

[Legend]

Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Legend
The experts seemed to think different. :dazzler:

The same experts who put teh McDonald Brothers through?

No, just 2 of them.

And again, they could sing, much worse people have gotten through.

[Matt08]

Surely that audition was a joke? The XF rules should state that you can't use a sob story in the auditions. He was bloody awful, a dustbin could sing better than he did.

[jcdub]

Is it wrong that the first thing that came to mind was a press scandal tomorrow morning with his wife professing that she actually spoke to him a week ago?

[Tom]

Originally posted by Legend
The experts seemed to think different. :dazzler:

Do you think he'd get through without a sob story?

[\PJ/]

Well,the cheryl was just a joke when she started crying talk about FORCED!

[Tom4784]

He wasn't great, his sob story got him through. So much about not having so many sob stories this year...

[Legend]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Legend
The experts seemed to think different. :dazzler:

Do you think he'd get through without a sob story?

Probably not, who knows. But he weren't awful.

[markofthebeast]

when rowette and brenda didnt win i was pissed off!

[30stone]

Originally posted by KKBL
same as the guy who wanted to make his real parents proud.but he was even worse:yuk:

That alan turner?


if so he was good and would have got throught with no sob story.

[XxShortyxX]

Yeah he was, I like him as a person, but I think they are better singers there then him.

[Billy]

I hated his audition, but he improved last night

[Princess]

I don't even remember Alan Turner having a sob story! I like him.

[KKBL]

Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by KKBL
same as the guy who wanted to make his real parents proud.but he was even worse:yuk:

That alan turner?


if so he was good and would have got throught with no sob story.

no he wouldnt.his voice is nothing more then average.

but yaeh the pool cleaner was so much better last night

[30stone]

Originally posted by KKBL
Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by KKBL
same as the guy who wanted to make his real parents proud.but he was even worse:yuk:

That alan turner?


if so he was good and would have got throught with no sob story.

no he wouldnt.his voice is nothing more then average.

but yaeh the pool cleaner was so much better last night

He would hes better than a lot of people still in there now!

[xDramatick]

Alan Turner and the pool cleaner are nothing to write home about. lmfao.

I don't like either, though the pool cleaner bothers me a lot.

[KKBL]

Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by KKBL
Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by KKBL
same as the guy who wanted to make his real parents proud.but he was even worse:yuk:

That alan turner?


if so he was good and would have got throught with no sob story.

no he wouldnt.his voice is nothing more then average.

but yaeh the pool cleaner was so much better last night

He would hes better than a lot of people still in there now!

but thats not the point.he has an average voice and average isnt enough.he didnt deserve to get passed auditions.

[XxShortyxX]

Yeah both guys are very, very average, nothing to get exicted about.