Louis choice

[Dan_]

Anyone else think that Louis was silly to put through two girl groups? It's not like that are overly different, so they could end up splitting the vote.I'd have much rather 4 instinct have gone through instead of Girl Band.

[BigSister]

oooh I think same Dan I would have liked 4 instinct to have got through as well

[Billy]

I think he made the best choices.
4 Instict wouldn't have split votes, but they weren't good. We saw what they wer elike during the bootcamp stages, and Priority weren't great either. He put through the 3 most talented imo.

[Indierock&roll]

yeah it was a bit stupid actually.. should of chose different kinds because otherwise the public wont care about two girlbands and they wont get that many votes because there both a girlband of 4 young girls

[Tom]

Girl band are rubbish. 4 Instinct are really good and there is definitely a gap for a Motown-esque band, and I'm sure a hell of a lot of people would like bands like that to return

[Billy]

Originally posted by Tom
Girl band are rubbish. 4 Instinct are really good and there is definitely a gap for a Motown-esque band, and I'm sure a hell of a lot of people would like bands like that to return

Motown bands don't do well on the XF though. 4 instict crumbled at bootcamp and Louis can't rely on them to do well.

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Tom
Girl band are rubbish. 4 Instinct are really good and there is definitely a gap for a Motown-esque band, and I'm sure a hell of a lot of people would like bands like that to return

Motown bands don't do well on the XF though. 4 instict crumbled at bootcamp and Louis can't rely on them to do well.

Theres never been one so how do we know?

[Billy]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Tom
Girl band are rubbish. 4 Instinct are really good and there is definitely a gap for a Motown-esque band, and I'm sure a hell of a lot of people would like bands like that to return

Motown bands don't do well on the XF though. 4 instict crumbled at bootcamp and Louis can't rely on them to do well.

Theres never been one so how do we know?

4Sure + 4tune were all in the Motown genre, sang the Motown songs and they didn't make the halfway point.

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Tom
Girl band are rubbish. 4 Instinct are really good and there is definitely a gap for a Motown-esque band, and I'm sure a hell of a lot of people would like bands like that to return

Motown bands don't do well on the XF though. 4 instict crumbled at bootcamp and Louis can't rely on them to do well.

Theres never been one so how do we know?

4Sure + 4tune were all in the Motown genre, sang the Motown songs and they didn't make the halfway point.

They weren't. They sung Motown songs but they also did other stuff. Those bands weren't in a specific genre. They also simply weren't that good.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Tom
Girl band are rubbish. 4 Instinct are really good and there is definitely a gap for a Motown-esque band, and I'm sure a hell of a lot of people would like bands like that to return

Motown bands don't do well on the XF though. 4 instict crumbled at bootcamp and Louis can't rely on them to do well.

Theres never been one so how do we know?

4Sure + 4tune were all in the Motown genre, sang the Motown songs and they didn't make the halfway point.

They weren't. They sung Motown songs but they also did other stuff. Those bands weren't in a specific genre. They also simply weren't that good.

4Sures were definitely motown. Both songs they sang were Motown, along with their bootcamp and audition stages.
4tune sung one motown song out of a possible two.