Diana is completely overrated

[Tom]

I liked her in the earlier stages and was a bit unsure of her at bootcamp but now I know for definite she is overrated. She wasn't that good at all tonight and looked like she'd just got of bed and dragged through a hedge backwards.

Alex & Laura are much stronger, and one of those two are going to win.

[Annie]

She is amazing - get over it

[Locke.]

This thread will be your downfall Thomas.

[I don't think she will win though, shes a favourite on forums but I believe that Hope were last year. Austin's got it in the bag.]

[Tom]

Originally posted by Annie
She is amazing - get over it

Not tonight she wasn't. I couldn't even hear/understand her at the start of the performance.

[Wildcat!]

I dont think she is overratted. I think she is right were she needs to be, 3rd or 4th favorite to win! If she carries on getting better, she might climb up and possibly win! DOnt forget, she is the least experienced singer of all of them so, she is more likely to have a better imrovement curve than the other girls! ANyways its ridiculous to say she is over ratted this early! SHe did a great ob week one, thats it! Lets see if she is just as good or better next week, then you can say whatever!

[ThisIsMarie]

WOW! Is Diana a big favourite then!?
Yay!


(Other than Tom, obviously.)

[Wildcat!]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Annie
She is amazing - get over it

Not tonight she wasn't. I couldn't even hear/understand her at the start of the performance.

I think most of the acts were shaky at the start, just to get used to the mic, its normal!

[Locke.]

Originally posted by ThisIsMarie
WOW! Is Diana a big favourite then!?
Yay!


(Other than Tom, obviously.)

On forums, yes.

[Tom8592]

She's definately one of the best

[Tom]

Originally posted by ThisIsMarie
WOW! Is Diana a big favourite then!?
Yay!


(Other than Tom, obviously.)

I do like her, I liked her in bootcamp and kind of in the judges homes. I just think people are hyping her up to much and I don't think she deserves to be a forum fave at all when there are much stronger singers. Maybe it was a bad song choice? We'll see.

[Wildcat!]

The forums dont know what the hell they are talking about 90% of the time anyways! They liked Diana B4 sghe sang a note, so....
And most of them, thought Badlashes was wicked!!!!!!!

[Locke.]

Originally posted by nowsthebturn
And most of them, thought Badlashes was wicked!!!!!!!

They were :bawling:

[Wildcat!]

See what I mean!:tongue:

Cmon David, stop thinking with your Cokk! They were Craappp!!!

[ThisIsMarie]

Bad Lashes weren't crap. Stop being so sinical.


Yay for Diana popularity! :spin:



Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by ThisIsMarie
WOW! Is Diana a big favourite then!?
Yay!


(Other than Tom, obviously.)

I do like her, I liked her in bootcamp and kind of in the judges homes. I just think people are hyping her up to much and I don't think she deserves to be a forum fave at all when there are much stronger singers. Maybe it was a bad song choice? We'll see. I see your point but it's not all, 100% about the voice. (Although obviously it's a major percentage.)

I personally really like her and I really hope she is good and it was just nerves. If she had sung the song well tonight, it would of been absolutly amazing!


Originally posted by nowsthebturn
The forums dont know what the hell they are talking about 90% of the time anyways! They liked Diana B4 sghe sang a note, so....
And most of them, thought Badlashes was wicked!!!!!!! They do or else why bother with them, if it's just a load of wrong, stupid comments?

Whether people win or not isn't the reason people like the singer. So it's not really relivant to whether or not their opinions can be classed as 'knowing what the hell they are talking about' or not.

[AndyShields]

I think Diana did look off before the makeover and live shows but someone has shown her how to apply make up and do the messy look without looking disheveled and now she is actually pretty beautiful.
While I do think she started badly tonight when she had the louder parts she was fantastic- if you like her kind of music that is.
I think Diana's appeal lies in the fact she is something not often seen on the X Factor which is someone quite unconventional from the norm but still marketable, that's where her popularity comes from, she's a 'quirky' singer with a pretty face and you aren't likely to get her mixed up with the other contestants any time soon!
Personally I think she's a breath of fresh air from the usual Leona type singers the X Factor usually presents (Like Alexandra) and I think its her differences that make her so popular or in your opinion 'overrated'.

[Wildcat!]

good post! That why I thought she was the special one (not JOse Mourinho) in the auditions. I love her voice and her strange hand movements. But I didnt think she was the best singer!

[ThisIsMarie]

Originally posted by AndyShields
I think Diana did look off before the makeover and live shows but someone has shown her how to apply make up and do the messy look without looking disheveled and now she is actually pretty beautiful. I think she was all before. (From what little I've seen.)


Originally posted by AndyShieldsI think Diana's appeal lies in the fact she is something not often seen on the X Factor which is someone quite unconventional from the norm but still marketable, that's where her popularity comes from, she's a 'quirky' singer with a pretty face and you aren't likely to get her mixed up with the other contestants any time soon!
Personally I think she's a breath of fresh air from the usual Leona type singers the X Factor usually presents (Like Alexandra) and I think its her differences that make her so popular or in your opinion 'overrated'. 100% hit the nail on head. :thumbs: Perfect!

[Spike]

She is good but she is also overrated

[xDramatick]

She did have a shaky start but she IS a good singer.
Obviously if you compare vocal talent, she would be weaker than the other two girls.
However, the X-Factor isn't just about vocal talent [though I admit, I do wonder sometimes =|] and she is extremely likeable, and unique. No-one else like her in the charts today. I find her totally captivating, and if she was to win [in an ideal world] she'd be the first UNIQUE winner.

[XxShortyxX]

There is something about Diana that I just luv, her voice is so unique, it's different from the others. I agree that Laura and Alex are much stronger then Diana, but I still say that the girls and Rachel are by far the best.

[M X]

I think Diana's voice is beautiful.

[andybigbro]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Annie
She is amazing - get over it

Not tonight she wasn't. I couldn't even hear/understand her at the start of the performance.

Try Listening then.

She was fab! Really great and Unique.

[SammyAyee]

[b]She Was Great

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by nowsthebturn
Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Annie
She is amazing - get over it

Not tonight she wasn't. I couldn't even hear/understand her at the start of the performance.

I think most of the acts were shaky at the start, just to get used to the mic, its normal! #

Defo right there, only Alexandra, Laura and Eoghan had a good start.

[Tom]

Originally posted by Darenn
She did have a shaky start but she IS a good singer.
Obviously if you compare vocal talent, she would be weaker than the other two girls.
However, the X-Factor isn't just about vocal talent [though I admit, I do wonder sometimes =|] and she is extremely likeable, and unique. No-one else like her in the charts today. I find her totally captivating, and if she was to win she'd be the first UNIQUE winner.

Not all of them had a really bad start where you couldn't hear though ...

Originally posted by andybigbro
Originally posted by Tom
[i]Originally posted by Annie
She is amazing - get over it

Not tonight she wasn't. I couldn't even hear/understand her at the start of the performance.

Try Listening then.

She was fab! Really great and Unique.

I did, it was really quiet.

[Fom]

I liked her :)
I think there was trouble with Mic's all night, everyone seemed really quiet. But her voice amazes me... she reminds me of The Cranberries... She really needs to sing this song next week, this will prove how talented she is!:

The Cranberries - Zombie
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MShJ8h7cEbE



Edit: Well a week that the theme would fit!

[Z]

I can see what you're saying Tom, but I think the reason for the hype is that she's really unique. I don't think she's going to win though, she's too far out for the general public to really 'get' but I think she'll maybe finish 5th/6th/7th (though I hope she does better)

[Adamw92]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Annie
She is amazing - get over it

Not tonight she wasn't. I couldn't even hear/understand her at the start of the performance.

Well thats not what the judges thought, Simon loved it and so did we so get over it, DIANA TO WIN!

[Tom4784]

Ithought her performance was the best yesterday. She's just so captivating.

[Annie]

When Diana sang last night I was totally caught up in her voice, its so soft and angelic and lovely.

She reminds me a little bit of Kate Bush with her quirkiness.

I love her

[Arneldo]

I love the tone of her voice, and her performance last night gave me goosebumps. She's great.

[rayheartbliss]

i kinda agree a bit.....

buh i thought she nailed her performance that night out of everyone....
laura is a bit overrated too....so that leaves alexandra ^,^

i think shes the best out of everyone based on last night's show

[Mrluvaluva]

I thought she was great last night after a slightly shaky start.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Mrluvaluva
I thought she was great last night after a slightly shaky start.

Yes the start was a bit wobbly but once she really got into it, it was great. She is one of my faves now.

[XxShortyxX]

IMO, they all started off wobby, but it was their first time singing live, so you can't really blame them.

[Ross]

I really dislike Diana, she's so annoying and imo has a really weak voice.

[Mrluvaluva]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX

IMO, they all started off wobby, but it was their first time singing live, so you can't really blame them.

Oh I wasn't blaming her. Far from it. I was just commenting on her performance. I thought they all did extremely well for their first live performance.

[Ross]

Also, she's putting on this whole 'weird' act - and whats with going on stage with no shoes, tramp.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Mrluvaluva
Originally posted by XxShortyxX

IMO, they all started off wobby, but it was their first time singing live, so you can't really blame them.

Oh I wasn't blaming her. Far from it. I was just commenting on her performance. I thought they all did extremely well for their first live performance.


lol sorry that wasn't amid at you, I was just saying about it lol.

[Mrluvaluva]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX

lol sorry that wasn't amid at you, I was just saying about it lol.

No problem. :thumbs:

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Ross
I really dislike Diana, she's so annoying and imo has a really weak voice.

I like her BECAUSE she isn't a powerhouse.
It's nice to see someone show you don't have to be like the typical Whitney/Mariah to do well in a show like this.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
I really dislike Diana, she's so annoying and imo has a really weak voice.

I like her BECAUSE she isn't a powerhouse.
It's nice to see someone show you don't have to be like the typical Whitney/Mariah to do well in a show like this.

I agree.

Also, Ross, she didn't wear shoes as she was afraid she would slip. :eureka:

[*mazedsalv**]

No, i think she is brilliant

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Ross
Also, she's putting on this whole 'weird' act - and whats with going on stage with no shoes, tramp.

She's not weird. That's horrible!
She went on stage without shoes because she was scared she'd trip over. She doesn't seem like a 'heels' girl anyway since most other times we've seen her, she hasn't worn heels.

She's not the first person to go on stage without shoes; Sandy Shaw? EVEN Leona Lewis has performed barefoot before.

[Ross]

Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
Also, she's putting on this whole 'weird' act - and whats with going on stage with no shoes, tramp.

She's not weird. That's horrible!
She went on stage without shoes because she was scared she'd trip over. She doesn't seem like a 'heels' girl anyway since most other times we've seen her, she hasn't worn heels.

She's not the first person to go on stage without shoes; Sandy Shaw? EVEN Leona Lewis has performed barefoot before.
I don't care about Leona and who the hell is Sandy Shaw?

I never said she was weird, I said she's putting the weird act on. Acting as if she doesn't have a clue what's going on, she could wear flats? I hope they cleaned the stage for whoever performed after her. Bare foot on a stage, disgrace.

[andybigbro]

Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
Also, she's putting on this whole 'weird' act - and whats with going on stage with no shoes, tramp.

She's not weird. That's horrible!
She went on stage without shoes because she was scared she'd trip over. She doesn't seem like a 'heels' girl anyway since most other times we've seen her, she hasn't worn heels.

She's not the first person to go on stage without shoes; Sandy Shaw? EVEN Leona Lewis has performed barefoot before.

I agree Darenn.
And the fact he called her a tramp is beyond me.
Explain why she is a tramp?

She is Unique, Atleast you can say that about her than Typical Alexandra etc.

Although i do like Alexandra, i think its wrong to Judge someone fro not wearing shoes!

LMFAO

[Tom]

Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
Also, she's putting on this whole 'weird' act - and whats with going on stage with no shoes, tramp.

She's not weird. That's horrible!
She went on stage without shoes because she was scared she'd trip over. She doesn't seem like a 'heels' girl anyway since most other times we've seen her, she hasn't worn heels.

She's not the first person to go on stage without shoes; Sandy Shaw? EVEN Leona Lewis has performed barefoot before.

I don't think he meant weird in that way, but she does act like shes just stepped out of a space ship

[MarkWaldorf]

I'm not reading through 2 pages of this thread because from what I've seen its just fans against fans.

But I agree. I don't see what's so special about her. She has a good voice, but the performance was just....meh. All she did was wave her hands and sing. I didn't get it.

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Ross
Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
Also, she's putting on this whole 'weird' act - and whats with going on stage with no shoes, tramp.

She's not weird. That's horrible!
She went on stage without shoes because she was scared she'd trip over. She doesn't seem like a 'heels' girl anyway since most other times we've seen her, she hasn't worn heels.

She's not the first person to go on stage without shoes; Sandy Shaw? EVEN Leona Lewis has performed barefoot before.
I don't care about Leona and who the hell is Sandy Shaw?

I never said she was weird, I said she's putting the weird act on. Acting as if she doesn't have a clue what's going on, she could wear flats? I hope they cleaned the stage for whoever performed after her. Bare foot on a stage, disgrace.

I didn't say you had to care about her, I'm just saying that Diana is far from the first person to go barefoot on stage, so I can't see why you're targetting that. It's a bit pathetic, and comes across as if you're LOOKING for reasons to insult her. Sandy Shaw - Puppet On A String, Eurovision. Joss Stone's gone barefoot too.

How do you know it's an act? It's a bit funny that someone who's acting has been the same in every piece of footage we've seen :rolleyes:

[Mrluvaluva]

Originally posted by Ross

who the hell is Sandy Shaw?



:shocked:

[Ross]

Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
Also, she's putting on this whole 'weird' act - and whats with going on stage with no shoes, tramp.

She's not weird. That's horrible!
She went on stage without shoes because she was scared she'd trip over. She doesn't seem like a 'heels' girl anyway since most other times we've seen her, she hasn't worn heels.

She's not the first person to go on stage without shoes; Sandy Shaw? EVEN Leona Lewis has performed barefoot before.
I don't care about Leona and who the hell is Sandy Shaw?

I never said she was weird, I said she's putting the weird act on. Acting as if she doesn't have a clue what's going on, she could wear flats? I hope they cleaned the stage for whoever performed after her. Bare foot on a stage, disgrace.

I didn't say you had to care about her, I'm just saying that Diana is far from the first person to go barefoot on stage, so I can't see why you're targetting that. It's a bit pathetic, and comes across as if you're LOOKING for reasons to insult her. Sandy Shaw - Puppet On A String, Eurovision. Joss Stone's gone barefoot too.

How do you know it's an act? It's a bit funny that someone who's acting has been the same in every piece of footage we've seen :rolleyes:
Never heard of Sandy Shaw.

Like Tom said, I'm not calling her weird. She just seems like she's come from space and acts all dopey.

I still think going barefoot is disgusting. So Joss Stone, Leona and that Sandy person are all tramps.

I mean tramps, not in the full literal sense like "omg they live on streets" I just think going barefoot in public, is trampy.

[andybigbro]

Originally posted by Ross
Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by Ross
Also, she's putting on this whole 'weird' act - and whats with going on stage with no shoes, tramp.

She's not weird. That's horrible!
She went on stage without shoes because she was scared she'd trip over. She doesn't seem like a 'heels' girl anyway since most other times we've seen her, she hasn't worn heels.

She's not the first person to go on stage without shoes; Sandy Shaw? EVEN Leona Lewis has performed barefoot before.
I don't care about Leona and who the hell is Sandy Shaw?

I never said she was weird, I said she's putting the weird act on. Acting as if she doesn't have a clue what's going on, she could wear flats? I hope they cleaned the stage for whoever performed after her. Bare foot on a stage, disgrace.

I didn't say you had to care about her, I'm just saying that Diana is far from the first person to go barefoot on stage, so I can't see why you're targetting that. It's a bit pathetic, and comes across as if you're LOOKING for reasons to insult her. Sandy Shaw - Puppet On A String, Eurovision. Joss Stone's gone barefoot too.

How do you know it's an act? It's a bit funny that someone who's acting has been the same in every piece of footage we've seen :rolleyes:
Never heard of Sandy Shaw.

Like Tom said, I'm not calling her weird. She just seems like she's come from space and acts all dopey.

I still think going barefoot is disgusting. So Joss Stone, Leona and that Sandy person are all tramps.

I mean tramps, not in the full literal sense like "omg they live on streets" I just think going barefoot in public, is trampy.

Were humans born with shoes?

NO!

We dont have to wear clothes we are animals like everything else. Do yu see hippos wearing clothes no.

So we have just been used to it now.
SO if Dina doesnt want to wear shoes, She dont have to!
PEACE!

[Ross]

Originally posted by andybigbro

Were humans born with shoes?

NO!

We dont have to wear clothes we are animals like everything else. Do yu see hippos wearing clothes no.

So we have just been used to it now.
SO if Dina doesnt want to wear shoes, She dont have to!
PEACE!
Wth. What a stupid arguement LOL.

She isn't just being born though, and humans were shoes when they're out in public.

She isn't the Queen, so yes she does have to wear shoes otherwise she will be deemed as trampy (by me) but hey that's my opinion.

Comparing Diana to a Hippo :laugh3:

[Jen]

I love her and have done since her first audition...
and I will forever love her...

If another Leon wins I will have to Kill the Biritish Public... :D

[Annie]

Bianca Ryan didnt wear shoes on America's Got Talent and won.

I seriously think she is amazing - she is so different to the usual contenders and normally the public will get her and she will go far.

She is a breathe of fresh air to this kind of competition.

[Fom]

I like her look... its sexy. I liked her hair... and loads of performers go on bare foot.
Kelly Clarkson has always performed bare footed because she says she feels the beat better... its naturally not trampy.

[andybigbro]

Originally posted by Ross
Originally posted by andybigbro

Were humans born with shoes?

NO!

We dont have to wear clothes we are animals like everything else. Do yu see hippos wearing clothes no.

So we have just been used to it now.
SO if Dina doesnt want to wear shoes, She dont have to!
PEACE!
Wth. What a stupid arguement LOL.

She isn't just being born though, and humans were shoes when they're out in public.

She isn't the Queen, so yes she does have to wear shoes otherwise she will be deemed as trampy (by me) but hey that's my opinion.

Comparing Diana to a Hippo :laugh3:

I wasnt caomparing Diana to a Hippo, I was using a Hippo as an Example.Silly.

[Jen]

FOM

I found another Look'a'like for you.... Muahaha :D

[XxShortyxX]

I agree Annie, Diana is so cool as well.

[MarkWaldorf]

How did this argument turn into her not wearing shoes makes her brilliant?

[Locke.]

Where did shoes come into everything? Anyway, shes not the only person not to wear shoes on stage, an old singer (forgot her name) didn't either, and neither does Joss Stone, it's just a comfort thing like she said I guess.

[Jen]

She is a mesmerising singer...

Just because Rachel was crapo... (Sorry had to stick that in :P)

[Fom]

Originally posted by JDIZZEL
FOM

I found another Look'a'like for you.... Muahaha :D

Who?!

[Billy]

I thought she was amazing tonight :$ She started of shaky, but she grew into the song and she gave me goosebumps at the end of the song. About the way she was dressed, that's all down to personal taste I guess, but I thought she was amazing

[Jen]

Originally posted by Fom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
FOM

I found another Look'a'like for you.... Muahaha :D

Who?!

I was watching HairSpray (Because I'm sad...) and there was a dancer.. and I was like... :O FOM! *Pauses TV* FOM!

I'm going to find the screenshot and make a thread.. :D

Just you wait.. LOL

[Fom]

Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Fom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
FOM

I found another Look'a'like for you.... Muahaha :D

Who?!

I was watching HairSpray (Because I'm sad...) and there was a dancer.. and I was like... :O FOM! *Pauses TV* FOM!

I'm going to find the screenshot and make a thread.. :D

Just you wait.. LOL

*Gives weird look*


Which scene? I have it on DVD ;)

[Tom]

Without meaning to sound like a mod, its not a chat thread you know, why just come into this thread and say that? :whistle:

Anyway I'm interested to know whether people would still think she is mesmerising/captivating of Cheryl never said anything

[Billy]

Originally posted by Tom
Without meaning to sound like a mod, its not a chat thread you know, why just come into this thread and say that? :whistle:

Anyway I'm interested to know whether people would still think she is mesmerising/captivating of Cheryl never said anything
Yes, I said it straight after her first audition :P I was like "damn I want to hear more"

[Fom]

Her version of Hallelujah during bootcamp is breath taking...

[Jen]

Originally posted by Fom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Fom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
FOM

I found another Look'a'like for you.... Muahaha :D

Who?!

I was watching HairSpray (Because I'm sad...) and there was a dancer.. and I was like... :O FOM! *Pauses TV* FOM!

I'm going to find the screenshot and make a thread.. :D

Just you wait.. LOL

*Gives weird look*


Which scene? I have it on DVD ;)

The first time you see the T.V Show and it introduces all of the kids, he makes a weird face.. LOL

Hes called Brad... and I just found the video.. LOL

[chachaslide4567]

sorry but Diana has a beautiful voice. Alexandra is strnger i agree - but laura sounds like Amy Winehouse when drunk.

[CassetteFinger]

Rename the thread "Laura is completely overrated!"

[Tom4784]

Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Fom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Fom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
FOM

I found another Look'a'like for you.... Muahaha :D

Who?!

I was watching HairSpray (Because I'm sad...) and there was a dancer.. and I was like... :O FOM! *Pauses TV* FOM!

I'm going to find the screenshot and make a thread.. :D

Just you wait.. LOL

*Gives weird look*


Which scene? I have it on DVD ;)

The first time you see the T.V Show and it introduces all of the kids, he makes a weird face.. LOL

Hes called Brad... and I just found the video.. LOL

I just watched the scene in question on Youtube! There's a little resemblance!

[Benjamin]

I hated Diana, but last nights performance was second best to Ruths. It was amazing. I just hope the public don't get bored of her, as they so often do very quickly with unsual voiced singers (Macy Gray, Anastacia etc.)

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by ukturtle
I hated Diana, but last nights performance was second best to Ruths. It was amazing. I just hope the public don't get bored of her, as they so often do very quickly with unsual voiced singers (Macy Gray, Anastacia etc.)

Yeah, look Alisha, Phillip, Ashley, Maria etc.
They all had quite unique voices [compared to other contestants], and had an early exit.

[NettoSuperstar!]

I think she could win, her voice is distinctive and very contemporary! Me and my old man said we would buy that song she sang Saturday and we never say that!

[karezza]

Diana is too annoying to win.

Laura, Alexandra & Rachel have the strongest voices.:whistle:

[Billy]

Originally posted by Darenn
Originally posted by ukturtle
I hated Diana, but last nights performance was second best to Ruths. It was amazing. I just hope the public don't get bored of her, as they so often do very quickly with unsual voiced singers (Macy Gray, Anastacia etc.)

Yeah, look Alisha, Phillip, Ashley, Maria etc.
They all had quite unique voices [compared to other contestants], and had an early exit.

To be fair though, Alisha,Phillip and Ashley were awful when they were eliminated, it had nothing to do with an unusual voice.

[GhettoSuperstar]

Did anyone actually hear the first minute of her performance? - Oh wait no-one could because she was having an orgasm whilst trying to sing.

[Annie]

^^^ Harsh Doug

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by GhettoSuperstar
Did anyone actually hear the first minute of her performance? - Oh wait no-one could because she was having an orgasm whilst trying to sing.

yeh and...

[Billy]

Originally posted by GhettoSuperstar
Did anyone actually hear the first minute of her performance? - Oh wait no-one could because she was having an orgasm whilst trying to sing.

I did :S ?

[NettoSuperstar!]

yer and me lol

[GhettoSuperstar]

She was on mute! For me thats not good. Well, because there is nothing to hear! :shrug:

[NettoSuperstar!]

she has a beautiful voice...more about her than girls a freakin loud

[Tom4784]

Diana was doing something called singing an act of which some members are unfamiliar with on this forum since all the singers they know need some sort of machine to perform. Harsh but true.

[Annie]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T6Ixvsp-RU4

She sang at the beginning as well. Not on mute at all.

[NettoSuperstar!]

like a freakin angel

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Dezzy
Diana was doing something called singing an act of which some members are unfamiliar with on this forum since all the singers they know need some sort of machine to perform. Harsh but true.


Funnily enough, most of the people who seem to 'hate' Diana are the ones who seem to listen to the artists whose voices get edited the most.

[GhettoSuperstar]

Originally posted by bbE
she has a beautiful voice...more about her than girls a freakin loud

Nuh uh galfriend!
We'll compare her success in years to come yeahs.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by GhettoSuperstar
Originally posted by bbE
she has a beautiful voice...more about her than girls a freakin loud

Nuh uh galfriend!
We'll compare her success in years to come yeahs.

yes my lovely we shall

[GiRTh]

I think she's overrrated too. In fact, I think Hannah should have gone thru to the live finals at Diana's expense. I also dont see too many commercial opportunities for her; she doesnt have the purity of tone of say a Nora Jones of a Katie Melua. I think she's taking up space in the final twelve

[Billy]

Originally posted by GiRTh
I think she's overrrated too. In fact, I think Hannah should have gone thru to the live finals at Diana's expense. I also dont see too many commercial opportunities for her; she doesnt have the purity of tone of say a Nora Jones of a Katie Melua. I think she's taking up space in the final twelve

Hannah wouldn't have brung in votes though. If anything she'd have taken away from Laura.

Obviously not wasting space if she is the bookies 3rd fave to win :rolleyes:

[~Kizwiz~]

I think she has a very unique sound but i dont see her winning at all. She is going to struggle when it come to certain genre's each week

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Billy21
Hannah wouldn't have brung in votes though. If anything she'd have taken away from Laura.

Obviously not wasting space if she is the bookies 3rd fave to win :rolleyes: I wouldnt mind if Hannah had split Laura's fans. I dont think we should have a final 12 to fit all styles and genres I think the best 12 should go through.

I'm surprised Diana's third fave so I think you and I should have a friendly wager that she finshes much lower than that. Are you up for that?

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by GiRTh
I think she's overrrated too. In fact, I think Hannah should have gone thru to the live finals at Diana's expense. I also dont see too many commercial opportunities for her; she doesnt have the purity of tone of say a Nora Jones of a Katie Melua. I think she's taking up space in the final twelve

Hannah wouldn't have brung in votes though. If anything she'd have taken away from Laura.

Obviously not wasting space if she is the bookies 3rd fave to win :rolleyes:

Why would Hannah not bring in the votes? I didn't like her (because of her personality, or lack of) but she was extremely talented, but she was quite mysterious and secretive. I think she definitely had "it" even though I didn't particularly like her.

Hannah & Laura were also nothing like each other, I don't get how one would take votes away from the other.

[Wildcat!]

She is god. But she will be out like week 4 or 5. Same as Ashley from 2 years ago. Unique, weird, will be interesting for 3 weeks, then.......
Make way for the real singers!

[NettoSuperstar!]

she'll be there long after JLS and she is a real singer

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by bbE
she'll be there long after JLS and she is a real singer Kiz made a good point in that she'll struggle during the genre specific weeks. I'm already chucking at the thought of Diana doing Disco week.:whistle:

[NettoSuperstar!]

ok come back to me disco week...in fact come back to me after Jacko week

[xDramatick]

^ Simon said last year he'd never do Disco week again

[Tom]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by bbE
she'll be there long after JLS and she is a real singer Kiz made a good point in that she'll struggle during the genre specific weeks. I'm already chucking at the thought of Diana doing Disco week.:whistle:

Michael Jackson week first, I bet she murders whatever she gets with her nails down a blackboard voice.

[Wildcat!]

Diana can do Michael Jackson1

I dont think she will struggle this week! There are a lot of songs from her to choose from that will suit her!

But like I said, I dont see her as a contender, just a pretty good singer.
She will do better than most outside of Xfactor though! For sure!

[Emzy-!!]

I think she is good, but I do agree that she is overrated.
Her voice only suits those hippy songs, and I think she will struggle with alot of songs especially next week with Michael Jackson's songs.

I don't think any of his songs would suit her voice.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by bbE
she'll be there long after JLS and she is a real singer Kiz made a good point in that she'll struggle during the genre specific weeks. I'm already chucking at the thought of Diana doing Disco week.:whistle:

Michael Jackson week first, I bet she murders whatever she gets with her nails down a blackboard voice. She'll probably pick something really slow like 'One day in your life' or 'Ben'. I want to see her do something up tempo - she'll murder it.

[~Kizwiz~]

She certainly has talent but can she really contend with the big voices?

[GiRTh]

Strange thing is - I'm sitting here taking the p*ss but I think she's going to do quite well. I dont think she'll make the final but I can see her being around during the last few weeks. I also dont think she'll deserve it but, judging by the response on here, its clear she has loyal fans who will vote for her every week. Once the show is done I dont see much of a future for her. She's too specific in style and her style doesn't sell the millions that other styles do.

[Tom4784]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Strange thing is - I'm sitting here taking the p*ss but I think she's going to do quite well. I dont think she'll make the final but I can see her being around during the last few weeks. I also dont think she'll deserve it but, judging by the response on here, its clear she has loyal fans who will vote for her every week. Once the show is done I dont see much of a future for her. She's too specific in style and her style doesn't sell the millions that other styles do.

I reckon she'll do well outside of X Factor. She's got a good relaxing sound. She could be a singer song writer like Katie Melua or Sarah Maclauchan (sp?).

[~Kizwiz~]

Originally posted by Dezzy

I reckon she'll do well outside of X Factor. She's got a good relaxing sound. She could be a singer song writer like Katie Melua or Sarah Maclauchan (sp?).

I was thinking the same thing, she has a very edgy voice but I still feel she will struggle and its when the singer dont feel comfortable with the songs that faults and cracks start to appear

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Dezzy
Originally posted by GiRTh
Strange thing is - I'm sitting here taking the p*ss but I think she's going to do quite well. I dont think she'll make the final but I can see her being around during the last few weeks. I also dont think she'll deserve it but, judging by the response on here, its clear she has loyal fans who will vote for her every week. Once the show is done I dont see much of a future for her. She's too specific in style and her style doesn't sell the millions that other styles do.

I reckon she'll do well outside of X Factor. She's got a good relaxing sound. She could be a singer song writer like Katie Melua or Sarah Maclauchan (sp?). Can she write he own songs? My little summing up was based on the fact that she doesn't write her own songs. The way I see it, if she write her own songs she'll be OK she's slip into the genre you specified but if she doesn't then I see no future for her. I cant see professional songwriters writing songs for her as opposed to say Girls Aloud or Kylie.

[XxShortyxX]

I think Diana may struggle too, but I think most of the girls will, because MJ songs are more suited to boys.