Live Show 2 [18/10/08]- Discussion Thread

[Lewis.]

So with Just over an hour left until the show starts.. I volunteer to start the Discussion thread for The second live show of the x factor

With our contestants singing michael Jackson songs.. Anything could Happen!

Scott Bruton She's Out Of my Life
Alexandra Burke I'll Be There
Austin Drage Billie Jean
Daniel Evans One Day In Your life
Girlband Heal The World
Rachel Hylton Dirty Diana
JLS The Way You Make Me Feel
Ruth Lorenzo I Just Can't Stop Loving You
Eoghan Quigg Ben
Diana Vickers Man In The Mirror
Laura White You Are Not Alone

[Annie]

What time it on?

[Sam!]

Dunno why the thread needs to be up so early but there you go.

[Lewis.]

The show starts at 7:25pm

[Lewis.]

1 hour left!

[Wildcat!]

thanx for the thread!
Looking forward to this week!
I think Diana And Alex are gonna be top 2 again, but I am looking forward to JLS. They werent great last week!

[Lewis.]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
thanks for the thread!
Looking forward to this week!
I think Diana And Alex are going to be top 2 again, but I am looking forward to JLS. They werent great last week!

That is okay.. I am looking forward to Diana and Rachel.. Want to know how they style their songs?

50 minutes left!

[MarkWaldorf]

Thanks for the time confirmation!

[Lewis.]

30 minutes left!

[Wildcat!]

I reckon Diana will do it a bit like this one

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=wU0drPOIlqU

[Lewis.]

10 more minutes..

[Annie]

11 mins :hello:

[Lewis.]

10 now.! Did you see dermot on Harry Hill?

[Lewis.]

4 minutes!

[ss00]

5 mins to go. gawd. I cant wait.

[Locke.]

Harry Hill is sooo boring.

[Lewis.]

3 minutes!

[Wildcat!]

Is everyone on this forum Diana fans!???
Its gonna be a bit biased I anticipate:roleyes:

[Lewis.]

After the Break! Huhhhhhh.. I am a Diana Fan but a Bigger Alexandra :wink:

[LemonJam]

eeeeeeee.

[Spike]

Really looking forward to it, great theme for the show

[ss00]

not really everyone. just majority, i suppose.

[Lewis.]

It is on!

[LemonJam]

I like Diana very much, but I know that I'll end up disliking her because of people constantly saying how good she is. =\

[Wildcat!]

Originally posted by LemonJam
I like Diana very much, but I know that I'll end up disliking her because of people constantly saying how good she is. =\

DITTO!!

[Indierock&roll]

woo beat it!

[Lewis.]

Nice intro.. Dermot is a true classic presenter

[Lewis.]

Danni Looks Stunning

[Indierock&roll]

omg i get so nervous every week ! ah

[Wildcat!]

Danny Minogue is hot!!!

[Spike]

Dannii looks amazing

[Lewis.]

Michael JAcksonn.. Oww,. :colour:

[Indierock&roll]

woo the girls

[LemonJam]

Michael Jackson <3

[Spike]

Alex up first, I think there is a possibility she will be in the bottom 2.

[LemonJam]

Uh-oh! :conf2:

[Lewis.]

She will be good..

[Lewis.]

Good start. :whistle:

[Wildcat!]

oopppss!!! she screwed up the LYRICS

[hannah.]

her dress is beautiful

[Spike]

She is great, strong performance
I am starting to really like her

[Lewis.]

She reminds me of Leona Lewis when she sang this.. But more beautifully sung..

[Lewis.]

Wow.. Brilliant.. :cheer2:

[LemonJam]

Very, very good. Impressed, was flat a couple of times but generally very good.

[Indierock&roll]

uh no way did louis just say that ee haha

[Lewis.]

It is Michael Jackson week for God Sake simon

[MarkWaldorf]

lol I'd agree it sounded like Mariah at parts

[Spike]

What Simon said could also apply to Leona

[Indierock&roll]

louis is sort of being a suck up to alexandra... haha

[LemonJam]

IMO, Simon hit the nail on the head.

[Lewis.]

Simon is being a hypocrite

[hannah.]

she reminds me of leona.. we dont neeed another leona though

[Indierock&roll]

Originally posted by hannahhhh
she reminds me of leona.. we dont neeed another leona though
yeah true i love her shes one of my favurates but she is similar to leona

[Lewis.]

I think she could win this thing!

[Lewis.]

Blooming adverts..

[Locke.]

Didn't like Alexandra's song but her voice was superb. Not looking forward to after the break, Ruth & Scott, my worst two acts, please send one of them home tonight!!

[Princess]

Loved Alexandra. That reminded me of Leona because she sang the same song,I think it was in Week 2 as well.

[Lewis.]

Originally posted by Princess
Loved Alexandra. That reminded me of Leona because she sang the same song,I think it was in Week 2 as well.

She sang it on week 1. :thumbs:

[Wildcat!]

Ruth gonna do Gloria Estefan's version isnt she?
I wish she stopped trying to do Spanish on all the songs!

[Sam!]

Oo its back.

[Lewis.]

Back to the x factor.

[hannah.]

ahh dermot is so hot

[hannah.]

ahh scott
lovely lovely boyyy

[Wildcat!]

CRY baby is up!

[Spike]

Scott will be interesting, he must do a brilliant performance.

[LemonJam]

Mmm... Scott. :blush2:

[Indierock&roll]

aw scott was a cute little kid :)

[Loukas]

Alex was amazing as usual!

Scott is just :love: Best of luck for him..

[hannah.]

he has a really small head

[Wildcat!]

This guy SUCKSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Indierock&roll]

hes got an okay voice..

[hannah.]

okay?! he has a great voice!

[Arneldo]

Scott so much better this week

[Indierock&roll]

Originally posted by hannahhhh
okay?! he has a great voice!

not great but okay

[Wildcat!]

PLEASE This is horrendous!!!!!!!!!!
O course girlies are gonna think its so cute

[LemonJam]

Damn, he's goooooooood.

[Loukas]

When i told my dad Scott got this song he said 'Worst song he could of got' but when he started singing he was so shocked and he thought he pulled it off very, very well!!!!

[Lewis.]

So much Better!

[Arneldo]

And he's back in the game!!!

[Spike]

Scott looks yummy
He was really good and is back in the race

[MarkWaldorf]

He's good but it's not blow you away good. Its as if he's gonna buildup to some big vocals but he isn't.

[hannah.]

ohh i lovee himmm

[Indierock&roll]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
PLEASE This is horrendous!!!!!!!!!!
O course girlies are going to think its so cute
i dont like him but he sang it well .. nothing special though

[ss00]

nothing special there, yeah.

[Indierock&roll]

haha moonwalk over to danni

[Wildcat!]

Another spanish version!

[LemonJam]

Dang Ruth is hot. :lovedup:

[Loukas]

Ruth Ruth Ruth!!!! :love:

Woooo!

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
Another spanish version!
Posted too soon! :tongue:

[Loukas]

Originally posted by Markus
Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
Another spanish version!
Posted too soon! :tongue:

:tongue:

[Arneldo]

Awful song choice. Ruth is so much better than this.

[MarkWaldorf]

Better than last week I think!

[hannah.]

i don't get it

[Wildcat!]

I knew I was gonna hate everyone tonight!!!!!!!!!

[Spike]

Shes good but its not memorable. She will be safe tonight though

[hannah.]

lmao louis clapping. what a penis

[hannah.]

and i dont mean when the song finished, i mean like just before. like clapping in time with the music

[ss00]

aww. i love cheryl. haha

[LemonJam]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Awful song choice. Ruth is so much better than this.

I agree, she needs a bit better diction too IMO.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by hannahhhh
lmao louis clapping. what a penis

:laugh2:

[Indierock&roll]

ruth was so good

[MarkWaldorf]

She definitely is going to be in the bottom tonight. I've noticed when ever Simon says something like that - it happens.

[Loukas]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Awful song choice. Ruth is so much better than this.

I agree.. But i also disagree.. Find me another Michael Jackson that she can sing. For a Michael Jackson song she done pretty well!!!
Good Luck to her!! :lovedup:

[hannah.]

she's not dressed up enough!

[Wildcat!]

Alex 6.5
Scott 6
Ruth 5

[Indierock&roll]

lmao dermot makes me laugh

[LemonJam]

Originally posted by Markus
She definitely is going to be in the bottom tonight. I've noticed when ever Simon says something like that - it happens.

Holy hell, you have so many awards!!! [/off topic]

I hope Ruth doesn't go, I think she's still got amazing potential to show.

[Spike]

Surprisingly Scott has been the best so far

[Locke.]

Scott- Better than last week but dull.
Ruth- Terrible, SEND HER HOME TONIGHT PLEASE!

[Princess]

Scott did so much better than last week. Ruth was brill,although argee with Cheryl on the clothes.

[hannah.]

so far

alexandra 7/10
scott 8/10
ruth 6/10

[Spike]

Originally posted by Markus
She definitely is going to be in the bottom tonight. I've noticed when ever Simon says something like that - it happens.

Yeah some of the things he says, especially on The Xtra Factor, gives away the results
He gave it away who was in the bottom 2 last week

[Locke.]

So far:

Best-
1. Alexandra
2. Scott
3. Ruth
Worst

[Loukas]

Alexandra - 8
Scott - 7.5/10
Ruth - 7

[Spike]

so far

Alexandra 7/10
Scott 9/10
Ruth 6/10

[LemonJam]

1. Scott
2. Alexandra
3. Ruth

IMO.

[Locke.]

Alexandra- 7.5
Scott- 5.5
Ruth- 3

[Lewis.]

Alex- 9/10
Scott- 7/10
Ruth- 8/10

[Indierock&roll]

alexandra - 8/10
scott - 6/10
ruth - 7/10

[LemonJam]

"Your names Austins Mum!" LMAO Dermot!

[Wildcat!]

CMON Girlband! I hate the song they are doing, but we'll see!

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by LemonJam
Originally posted by Markus
She definitely is going to be in the bottom tonight. I've noticed when ever Simon says something like that - it happens.

Holy hell, you have so many awards!!! [/off topic]

I hope Ruth doesn't go, I think she's still got amazing potential to show.
I'm sure Matt has more! :tongue:

[Arneldo]

I love the blonde one, her voice is sooo funny

[Christina]

My bloody Mum keeps turning over to watch SCD its really annoying me! :mad:

[Indierock&roll]

i feel sorry for girlband becuse louis seems to only care about jls..
but i hope girlband go tonight dont like them

[Arneldo]

CHEESE!

[Indierock&roll]

this is cheesy and just started off cr*p

[hannah.]

they just remind me of shows put on by the holiday park reps at the place i go every year?

[Lewis.]

Not perfect but okay.?

[hannah.]

HOW COME THEYVE GOT SPARKLES?!

[Indierock&roll]

them 3 women looked like they had straight jackets on... didnt like that too cheesy aha

[hannah.]

LMFAO simons face then summed it up for me

[hannah.]

4/5

[Loukas]

Ouch. There is something i really dislike. :puzzled:


Can't but my finger on it... Sorry girls but its borderline terrible!!

Alexandra - 8/10
Scott - 7.5/10
Ruth - 7/10
Girlband - 4/10

[LemonJam]

Brie or Cheddar anyone?

[Christina]

Still not too keen on them :conf2:

[Arneldo]

LOL Louis was so irish then "Awww no, now Dannii, be nice to them."

[Spike]

The vocals were painfull in places but I liked the performance for some reason
I don't know why but I just can't like these girls

[Indierock&roll]

hahahahah polar bears and dolphins and children

[Christina]

Alexandra - 9/10
Scott - 7/10
Ruth - 7/10
Girlband - 4/10

[MarkWaldorf]

Why do Louis' comebacks never have any meaning?

[Indierock&roll]

yes true!!! he is obsessed with jls

[hannah.]

1 scott 8/10
2 alexandra 7/10
3 ruth 6/10
4 girlband 4/10

[Spike]

Alexandra 7/10
Scott 9/10
Ruth 6/10
Girlband 3/10

[Lewis.]

Polar bears.. Haha..

[Jack]

LOL! Gimmicky? Didn't Simon mentor Same Difference Last Year?

[Arneldo]

Best
Alexnadra
Scott
Ruth
Girl Band
Worst

[Spike]

Simon was right
Louis know Girband wont do well, JLS are the only ones he cares about

[hannah.]

hahaha they could be the powerpuff girls
reminds me of the pantene magazine ads with all different hair colours

[Indierock&roll]

woo laura

[Sam!]

Laura!!!!

[LemonJam]

Its Laura time!

[Loukas]

I cannot wait to listen to Laura's Performance!!! :hello:

[ss00]

yay laura!

[hannah.]

SHE'S TOO WINEHOUSE!
NOBODY CAN BE WINEHOUSE

[LemonJam]

Wrong song. I'm ******** myself now.

[hannah.]

i just don't like her
and this was a bad song choice

[Lewis.]

Not too good.? :puzzled:

[MarkWaldorf]

THAT GOT SO MUCH BETTER

[Wildcat!]

The song is tough for her!

But she is OK!

[Spike]

Wrong song
Not as good as last week and was flat towards the start

Alexandra 7/10
Scott 9/10
Ruth 6/10
Girlband /10
Laura 6/10

[Arneldo]

Horrible start.
Fantastic finish.

[Indierock&roll]

the second bit was much better than the first! dress is better this week

[Sam!]

I was worried at the start and she soo improved. GO LAURA!

[Christina]

Great performance, yet again!

[Wildcat!]

When all fails, just SHOUT!
the 2nd half was just shouting!!

[Loukas]

Made That Song Her Own!!!! WOW!!! :lovedup:

[hannah.]

1 scott 8/10
2 alexandra 7/10
3 laura 7/10
3 ruth 6/10
4 girlband 4/10

[Lewis.]

Alexandra- 9/10
Ruth- 8/10
Scott- 6/10
Laura- 6/10
Girlband- 4/10

[Billy]

nowhere near as good as before.

[Loukas]

Laura - 8.5/10 (Overall song!! Begining was a 6)
Alexandra - 8/10
Scott - 7.5/10
Ruth - 7/10
Girlband - 4/10

[Arneldo]

Best
Alexnadra
Scott
Ruth
Laura
Girl Band
Worst

[LemonJam]

Originally posted by Indierock&roll
the second bit was much better than the first! dress is better this week

I preffered her showing off the home town :laugh:

[Indierock&roll]

all the songs have been slow :/ its boring me

[Indierock&roll]

eoghan is the last boy again (N)

[hannah.]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
When all fails, just SHOUT!
the 2nd half was just shouting!!

lmao i agree with you for once

[Locke.]

Girlband- 2/10
Laura- 8/10

[Wildcat!]

So far Ive got

Alexandra 6.5/10
Scott 6/10
Ruth 5/10
Girlband 5/10
Laura 5/10

Basically, they all kind of blow tbh!

[Princess]

Liked Girlband(it was really gimmicky though-which was really funny). Laura was amazing,although the start was a bit bad.

[Indierock&roll]

up to now: best to worst
laura
alexandra
ruth
scott
girlband

[Sam!]

Alexandra 8/10
Scott 6/10
Ruth 6.5/10
Girlband 5.5/10
Laura 8/10

[Christina]

Alexandra - 9/10
Scott - 7/10
Ruth - 7/10
Girlband - 4/10
Laura - 8/10

[Lewis.]

Alex has been the best so far

[LemonJam]

Atm....

1. Scott
2. Alexandra
3. Laura (Bad Song choice)
4. Ruth
5. Girlband (Bad song choice)

Only liked one so far. :sad:

[Locke.]

1. Laura
2. Alexandra
3. Scott
4. Ruth
5. Girlband

[hannah.]

Originally posted by LemonJam
Atm....

1. Scott
2. Alexandra
3. Laura (Bad Song choice)
4. Ruth
5. Girlband (Bad song choice)

Only liked one so far. :sad:

snappidy snap ;)

[Billy]

1.Scott
2.Ruth
3.Alexandra
4.Girlband
5.Laura

[Benjamin]

I don't understand why everyone likes Laura, I thought she was terrible tonight, her voice really annoyed me during that song.

Loved Ruth's and Alex's.

Girlband suck!

[hannah.]

Originally posted by ukturtle
I don't understand why everyone likes Laura, I thought she was terrible tonight, her voice really annoyed me during that song.

Loved Ruth's and Alex's.

Girlband suck!

:kiss::kiss:benny

[Lewis.]

Laura was not very good tonight.

[Lewis.]

Back on again!

[Indierock&roll]

i think the acts will be in this order now

austin
daniel
diana
eoghan
rachel
jls

[Loukas]

Bille Jean for Austin.. Will he sing it well?.. Only time will tell!

[Indierock&roll]

is there no fast songs AT ALL tonight?! :|

[hannah.]

blimey
austin looks hot! and i thought he was ugly :conf:

[Arneldo]

YAY hot Austin is back <3

[hannah.]

omg only just realised what this was! I LOVE IT. AND I DONT EVEN LIKE AUSTIN

[Wildcat!]

HERE we go! Simon copying American Idol Again, and no credit given to the originator of the song!

[Indierock&roll]

it sounds so wierd.. haha

[Greg.!]

Well Its......Different........

[~Kizwiz~]

Austin..... is doing the version of Billy Jean that David Cook did on American idol...... pffffff!!!

Not impressed!!!!!! Its been done before and its not as good as David Cook's!!!!

[Lewis.]

He is good. . . But not as good as Alexandra

[LemonJam]

****ing brilliant, I must admit.

[hannah.]

i freaking love it!

[Loukas]

His vocals are amazing.

But the version is like :bored:


Take that back accually its ok..

[Spike]

Austin just got hotter!
That was amazing!

Alexandra 7/10
Scott 9/10
Ruth 6/10
Girlband /10
Laura 6/10
Austin 10/10

[Wildcat!]

He did a great job with that

9/10

[Lewis.]

Naa.. Not as good as David Cook... I didn't like the song choice/version/arrangement

[Christina]

Personally.. i didnt like it. But my Mum thinks he was the best tonight and how his voice is 'absoulotley incrediable'.

[~Kizwiz~]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
HERE we go! Simon copying American Idol Again, and no credit given to the originator of the song!

I hear you...... copy cat Austin!!!!

[Tom8592]

Best performance of the night so far tbh

[Wildcat!]

He did a great job with that

9/10

[Arneldo]

Loved it. Not as good as David Cook but still very very good.

Best
Alexandra
Austin
Scott
Ruth
Laura
Girl Band
Worst

[Wildcat!]

YES, LOUIS exposed Simon!!!!!!!!!!!

[Christina]

Alexandra - 9/10
Scott - 7/10
Ruth - 6.5/10
Girlband - 4/10
Laura - 8/10
Austin - 6.5/10

[MarkWaldorf]

Is it weird that the only thing I'm looking forward to now is Girls Aloud? :/

[LemonJam]

1. Austin
2. Scott
3. Alexandra
4. Laura
5. Ruth
6. Girlband

Austin is so short. =\

[Tom8592]

Best
Austin
Alexandra
Laura
Ruth
Scott
Girlband
Worst

[Loukas]

Laura - 8.5/10 (Overall song!! Begining was a 6)
Alexandra - 8/10
Scott - 7.5/10
Austin - 7/10
Ruth - 7/10
Girlband - 4/10

[Indierock&roll]

omg he looks exactly the same as a kid haha

[Lewis.]

Lets see what this goes like...

[Wildcat!]

Alexandra 6.5/10
Scott 6/10
Ruth 5/10
Girlband 5/10
Laura 5/10
Austin 9/10

[hannah.]

bleugh. don't like him at all

[Wildcat!]

Granny votes in full force!

[Indierock&roll]

this is quite cringey .. he will probably be in the bottom 2 i think

[Loukas]

I am falling alsleep TOO MANY SLOW SONGS! :bored:

Enough Ballads already!

Good voice but not 21st centery star.

[LemonJam]

He's much better when singing louder.

[Wildcat!]

Better than I thought!

8/10

[Spike]

I don't know why but I just love Daniel
I really liked that, he will be safe tonight

Alexandra 7/10
Scott 9/10
Ruth 6/10
Girlband 3/10
Laura 6/10
Austin 10/10
Daniel 6/10

[Indierock&roll]

hahahah he actually called him ricky being dead serious aswell haha

[Lewis.]

Better when Loud....

[Indierock&roll]

aww daniel is cute

[Arneldo]

Good but just ugh.

[Lewis.]

I think he can survive another week...

[LemonJam]

1. Austin
2. Scott
3. Daniel
4. Alexandra
5. Laura
6. Ruth
7. Girlband

[Indierock&roll]

rachel will be last

[Tom8592]

He's an okay singer but nothing special

[Wildcat!]

Alexandra 6.5/10
Scott 6/10
Ruth 5/10
Girlband 5/10
Laura 5/10
Austin 9/10
Daniel 8/10

I think the boys have been better than the girls tonight!

[Princess]

Absolutely loved Austin. Daniel was dreadful.

[Locke.]

Austin was amazing!!!
Daniel was average :sad:

[hannah.]

1 austin 9/10
2 scott 8/10
3 alexandra 7/10
4 laura 7/10
5 ruth 6/10
6 daniel 5/10
7 girlband 4/10

[Lewis.]

Alex - 9/10
Austin- 8/10
Ruth- 8/10
Laura- 6/10
Daniel- 6/10
scott- 6/10
Girlband- 4/10

[Arneldo]

Best
Alexnadra
Austin
Scott
Ruth
Laura
Girl Band
Daniel
Worst

[Locke.]

1. Austin
2. Laura
3. Alexandra
4. Daniel
5. Scott
6. Ruth
7. Girlband

[Spike]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha

I think the boys have been better than the girls tonight!

[Lewis.]

Counting on Diana to bring back the brilliancy of last week..?

[Sam!]

1. Laura
2. Austin
3. Alexandra
4. Ruth
5. Scott
6. Girlband
7. Daniel

so far.

[Indierock&roll]

louis loves jls far too much
i just dont like them

[LemonJam]

Originally posted by Spike
Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha

I think the boys have been better than the girls tonight!

Austin was a brilliant vocal performance
Scott gave me goosebumps.

Lets hope Eoghan can keep it up. :thumbs:

[Indierock&roll]

haha J.... L ...... S