Best performance in X factor History...

[Lewis.]

For series 1-2-3-4... Which performance do you think was the best?

Do NOT include series 5 performances..

Only put ONE performance and i will count all of the performances and add the scores up

For me.. Leona Lewis- Summertime

[Loukas]

Ruth - Purple Rain

[Lewis.]

Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
Ruth - Purple Rain

Series 5.. Not included

[xDramatick]

Shayne Ward - Somewhere Over The Rainbow

[Ninastar]

Has to be a leona song. Any of her songs in the final. They were all amazing
x

[Lewis.]

Originally posted by ninostar
Has to be a leona song. Any of her songs in the final. They were all amazing
x

Which in particular

[LemonJam]

Shayne Ward - If you're not the one

[Fom]

If I could choose season 5... i would also choose Ruth - Purple Rain.
But... I will choose:

Leona - Summertime.

[Loukas]

Originally posted by Lewiis.Xx
Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
Ruth - Purple Rain

Series 5.. Not included

Leona Lewis - Somewhere Over The Rainbow

[Princess]

I loved all of Leona's from Summertime onwards but if I had to choose it would be 'Without You'.

I also loved her performance with Take That but only because it was with Take That.

[Lewis.]

Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
Originally posted by Lewiis.Xx
Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
Ruth - Purple Rain

Series 5.. Not included

Leona Lewis - Somewhere Over The Rainbow

Ohh yeah.. that was good... Especially the note at the end.!

[x_mel_x]

Leona Lewis-I Have Nothing or Somewhere Over The Rainbow.

[Matt]

Originally posted by Lewiis.Xx

Do NOT include series 5 performances..


...and what if you think the best performance in X Factor history is from Series 5?

Surely if the poll is to choose the best performance in X Factor history, then you should be able to choose from all the performances in X Factor history?

[Lewis.]

Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Lewiis.Xx

Do NOT include series 5 performances..


...and what if you think the best performance in X Factor history is from Series 5?

Surely if the poll is to choose the best performance in X Factor history, then you should be able to choose from all the performances in X Factor history?

But not this series

[Billy]

Nikitta; Bring It On Home

[Matt]

Originally posted by Lewiis.Xx

But not this series

So surely, if you're asking people to choose the best performance in X Factor history, then excluding any performances makes the poll pointless?

:rolleyes:

[Lewis.]

Originally posted by Matt
Originally posted by Lewiis.Xx

But not this series

So surely, if you're asking people to choose the best performance in X Factor history, then excluding any performances makes the poll pointless?

:rolleyes:

History before this series!

[Z]

Hope - Back to Black.

[Conzors]

Same Difference - Never Had A Dream Come True.

x

[Indierock&roll]

leona - i will always love you
it did literelly sound as good as whitney maybe even better i just remember getting goosebumps
i did love summertime too!

[shanelle]

leona- i have nothing

[Callum]

Originally posted by Z
Hope - Back to Black.

[Hugo]

Originally posted by Callum
Originally posted by Z
Hope - Back to Black.

Gimme a break! Hope were awful but it was the first proper Girls Aloud style girlband in the live stages so Simon obsessed over them and gave them more credit than they deserved.

anyway;;

Leona Lewis - Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word

[Callum]

Originally posted by tooperfect
Originally posted by Callum
Originally posted by Z
Hope - Back to Black.

Gimme a break! Hope were awful but it was the first proper Girls Aloud style girlband in the live stages so Simon obsessed over them and gave them more credit than they deserved.

anyway;;

Leona Lewis - Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word

Well sorry but it's my favorite performance. :|

[Z]

Originally posted by tooperfect
Originally posted by Callum
Originally posted by Z
Hope - Back to Black.

Gimme a break! Hope were awful but it was the first proper Girls Aloud style girlband in the live stages so Simon obsessed over them and gave them more credit than they deserved.

anyway;;

Leona Lewis - Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word


I don't see why my opinion should be any less valid than yours. I thought the vocal arrangement was great.

[Locke.]

Chico - It's Chico Time

[LemonJam]

Originally posted by Callum
Originally posted by Z
Hope - Back to Black.

I loved that performance. :lovedup:

[KKBL]

Originally posted by tooperfect
Originally posted by Callum
Originally posted by Z
Hope - Back to Black.

Gimme a break! Hope were awful but it was the first proper Girls Aloud style girlband in the live stages so Simon obsessed over them and gave them more credit than they deserved.



agreed.i love Hope and their BTB performance n all..and if thats your favourite XF performance ever..then fair enough..but best performance..no!

[Hugo]

LOL Sorry if I came across like I was belittling your opinions Z and Callum. I was just sharing mine. It didn't mean to come across like that lol.

[Locke.]

Originally posted by David_Purdy
Chico - It's Chico Time

Chico's performance of Hero is also a very close second.

[Z]

Originally posted by tooperfect
LOL Sorry if I came across like I was belittling your opinions Z and Callum. I was just sharing mine. It didn't mean to come across like that lol.

Haha it's OK :)



I thought it was one of the only examples of an X Factor act truly taking matters into their own hands (i.e. taking a song and molding it to their own standards)

That, and I didn't want to be another "Leona..." poster, all of her performances were good, but everyone else has already praised her to high heaven :laugh:

[Tom]

Brenda-Respect

One of the best vocals but as well as that she really performs it and doesnt just stand and sing

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=JtDG5ebpdXw

[MarkWaldorf]

God I loved Brenda. I couldn't believe she didn't win.

[Tom]

Originally posted by Markus
God I loved Brenda. I couldn't believe she didn't win.

Shes my favourite ever contestant but I'm glad she didn't win- she wouldn't have lasted in the charts and would have been branded as a reality TV flop. Instead shes been really successful in the West End and she does LK Today's X Factor thing. Arguably shes ended up more successful than Shayne.

[Magic]

Originally posted by Conzors
Same Difference - Never Had A Dream Come True.

x

:laugh3::laugh3::laugh3::laugh3::laugh3::laugh3:
But it was kinda good in a shamefull way.

[Dan_]

Shayne Ward - Somewhere Over The Rainbow
Andy Abraham-Me And Mrs Jones
Leona Lewis-I Have Nothing

[Tom]

Originally posted by Dan_
Shayne Ward - Somewhere Over The Rainbow

A few have said that, I always preferred Leona's version though, I'll add that to my fave actually :tongue:

Oh and Shayne's Cry Me A River.

[Magic]

Will Young - Evergreen.


I know.

[XxShortyxX]

Every song Leona did, she never once had a bad song or went out of tune.

JLS-The Way you make me feel.
Diana-Man in the mirror
All the songs Laura has done.
Nikki-Nothing compares to you.
Brenda-I will always love you.
All the songs Rowetta did.

[M X]

Leona Lewis - Summertime

But I also loved Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word, I Will Always Love you and all her performances.

And also,

Chico - It's Chico Time (i loved hope with hurt)

[GiRTh]

Leona doing summertime was good. Brenda Edwards doing Without you. Niki Evans doing Nothing compares to you.

[SammyAyee]

[b]Shayne Ward - Somewhere Over The Rainbow Or Leona - i Will Always Love You