Who has peaked already?

[Tom]

All in the title

[Benjamin]

Laura, she is very over-rated and nothing special, she won't get much better.

i think Diana ha also, which is a shame.

[Adamw92]

Eoghan

[Spike]

Diana

[Annie]

Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

[Jen]

Originally posted by Annie
Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

She could be another Rydian.
Brilliant from start to finish. Nothing new to her and eventually the public will pick a hot guy to win. Instead of the talent.
Its a shame as I really like her.

[Adamw92]

i wish we could vote twice tho because i think Daniel and Laura couldnt do much more

[Tom]

Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Annie
Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

She could be another Rydian.
Brilliant from start to finish. Nothing new to her and eventually the public will pick a hot guy to win. Instead of the talent.
Its a shame as I really like her.

Rhydian did something different every week. I hated him but he was a good contestant :joker:

[Jen]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Annie
Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

She could be another Rydian.
Brilliant from start to finish. Nothing new to her and eventually the public will pick a hot guy to win. Instead of the talent.
Its a shame as I really like her.

Rhydian did something different every week. I hated him but he was a good contestant :joker:

Yeah different song genres/styles.
But his music was virtually the same.
He was consistant but leon went and won because he was Alright on the last night. I'm still annoyed about that.. LOL

[Adamw92]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Annie
Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

She could be another Rydian.
Brilliant from start to finish. Nothing new to her and eventually the public will pick a hot guy to win. Instead of the talent.
Its a shame as I really like her.

Rhydian did something different every week. I hated him but he was a good contestant :joker:

and what did he do different, wear different clothes, thats all i can think of

[Locke.]

Laura (and Ruth and Diana)

[Tom]

Originally posted by Adamw92
Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Annie
Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

She could be another Rydian.
Brilliant from start to finish. Nothing new to her and eventually the public will pick a hot guy to win. Instead of the talent.
Its a shame as I really like her.

Rhydian did something different every week. I hated him but he was a good contestant :joker:

and what did he do different, wear different clothes, thats all i can think of

Perform different genres. What other contestant would be able to do Phantom of the Opera one week and Go West a few weeks later?

He took risk after risk, I can't see Diana doing that

[Adamw92]

Originally posted by Tom
Perform different genres. What other contestant would be able to do Phantom of the Opera one week and Go West a few weeks later?

He took risk after risk, I can't see Diana doing that

right yeah big change, sounded the same every week, we'll see if Diana can do that this week, going from big band to disco

[Jen]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Adamw92
Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Annie
Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

She could be another Rydian.
Brilliant from start to finish. Nothing new to her and eventually the public will pick a hot guy to win. Instead of the talent.
Its a shame as I really like her.

Rhydian did something different every week. I hated him but he was a good contestant :joker:

and what did he do different, wear different clothes, thats all i can think of

Perform different genres. What other contestant would be able to do Phantom of the Opera one week and Go West a few weeks later?

He took risk after risk, I can't see Diana doing that

Thats why its a shame.
Rhydian was brilliant every single week.
Leon was average on a good day.
Diana is not as good as Rydian but if they as you said take risks then maybe she will become more interesting. I don't think they are using her talent enough.

[hannah.]

Diana. To be honest I can't see how she's gonna shock me at any point. She's done the same kind of song even in different genres and I think it's gonna stay that way

[Bells]

Originally posted by hannahhhh
Diana. To be honest I can't see how she's going to shock me at any point. She's done the same kind of song even in different genres and I think it's going to stay that way

^^ Completely agree. I think she has a big enough fanbase that will support her no matter what now though.

She seems to be a bit of a one trick pony, as unique as her voice may be. It's not as commercial enough so she needs to step away from TXF and make a mark of her own now that she has the publicity. She may have the X factor, but it's still not what the show wants.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Adamw92
Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Annie
Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

She could be another Rydian.
Brilliant from start to finish. Nothing new to her and eventually the public will pick a hot guy to win. Instead of the talent.
Its a shame as I really like her.

Rhydian did something different every week. I hated him but he was a good contestant :joker:

and what did he do different, wear different clothes, thats all i can think of

Perform different genres. What other contestant would be able to do Phantom of the Opera one week and Go West a few weeks later?

He took risk after risk, I can't see Diana doing that

Diana done a U2 classic one week and took one of Michael Jacksons hits the next? They ALL take risks, they hvae to.

[hannah.]

Originally posted by Ash
Originally posted by hannahhhh
Diana. To be honest I can't see how she's going to shock me at any point. She's done the same kind of song even in different genres and I think it's going to stay that way

^^ Completely agree. I think she has a big enough fanbase that will support her no matter what now though.

She seems to be a bit of a one trick pony, as unique as her voice may be. It's not as commercial enough so she needs to step away from TXF and make a mark of her own now that she has the publicity. She may have the X factor, but it's still not what the show wants.

Yeah, her fanbase is big enough to keep her in and for her to get a career out of it, but I just don't think she'll win, right now I can't see any way that she can earn it in the majority of voters' eyes, although I may be wrong

[Wildcat!]

I think Diana is gonna be in the final for sure. She is terrible, but it seems, thats what the voters like this year:tongue:
BUt If she gets to the final, she could lose, because I know she irritates a lot of people, so with a 2 way vote she can lose in the final!

I hope she dont, cause Ive got money on her!:blush:

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by Adamw92
Originally posted by Tom
Originally posted by JDIZZEL
Originally posted by Annie
Diana has peaked too soon and a lot of people will not see a journey with her and people will get bored. She is a one trick pony

She could be another Rydian.
Brilliant from start to finish. Nothing new to her and eventually the public will pick a hot guy to win. Instead of the talent.
Its a shame as I really like her.

Rhydian did something different every week. I hated him but he was a good contestant :joker:

and what did he do different, wear different clothes, thats all i can think of

Perform different genres. What other contestant would be able to do Phantom of the Opera one week and Go West a few weeks later?

He took risk after risk, I can't see Diana doing that

Diana done a U2 classic one week and took one of Michael Jacksons hits the next? They ALL take risks, they hvae to.

Its not a massive risk though, she performs in the same style every week. And she had to do Michael Jackson.

[Lewis.]

i think Ruth's Purple rain was her peak.

[robb]

JLS may have more to offer..............wouldn't be that suprised to see them in the final with diana, who appears to have a bye to the final however well or badly she sings................

[GiRTh]

Diana and unfortunately, Laura. Diana sings in the same style each week. At first everybody loved her. Her fans would use words like 'eerie' and 'haunting' to describe her vocal style. Im glad that many now see she's just a one trick pony.

Also, Laura has peaked. She's a great singer when she gets going but Rachel's performance on Saturday showed up laura's technical deficiencies.

[robb]

I saw Alison Goldfrapp (Goldfrapp) live over the weekend......now there is a brilliant, quirky singer............

[LemonJam]

Sadly, Laura peaked SO early that I fear her leaving soon.

[rayheartbliss]

alexandra

and eoghan!

[Dan_]

It could well be Diana.I liked her through the auditions and thought With Or Without You was great but the last couple of weeks haven't been anything to write home about in my view.If she's just going to carry on singing in the same style week after week then it's going to become tedious and all merge into one big yodel.

[rayheartbliss]

if these "good ones" as you might call them.....are peaking!

then the least good ones maybe would have stood a chance!

because through their x-factor journey they are improving!

bit like leon!

[missposh]

diana

[*mazedsalv**]

Daniel peaked at bootcamp and then went downwards.

[Jake!]

Diana peaked, and I think for all the wrong reasons...

[womanizer]

diana, i don't see any improvement, just the same trash every week with her flat vocals.

[Loukas]

Diana.

She's really begining to bore me. After her first live performance i thought she was AMAZING, DIFFERENT AND NEW but now im begining to change my mind. 1) She is still young! Her whole life a head of her, she seems a bright girl. Uni material. 2) She hasn't improved much, she is SO overated its starting to hit the level of crazy.

Disco week this week. The week that Diana begins to crack?

[Z]

Diana, for all of the reasons given in the thread.

I disagree with people saying Laura though. I'd also add Daniel, but I don't think he was ever at a level you could describe as a peak.. :bigsmile:

[Princess]

Rachel,I think her audition was her best,downhill after then.

[rayheartbliss]

Originally posted by Princess
Rachel,I think her audition was her best,downhill after then.

i thought her best was during bootcamp!
when she sang chasing cars!
i didnt even recognise it, she made her own.

[bigknowse]

Diana. One trick pony.

[xERFx]

Originally posted by ukturtle
Laura, she is very over-rated and nothing special, she won't get much better.

i think Diana ha also, which is a shame.


I completely disagree

[Annie]

Originally posted by ukturtle
Laura, she is very over-rated and nothing special, she won't get much better.



Agree. I do like her but she isnt as amazing as everyone is making out. Big whoop she can sing. So can Alexandra and Rachel and many others.

Saying she is world class at week three is a complete joke.

[sexy_leigh]

diana and that makes me happy as she does not deserve to win as she has not got the best voice in the competition like alex or laura, she is wayyyyyyyyyy over rated!