The difference with Cheryl and Louis

[Princess]

Cheryl has 3 amazing acts,she doesn't need to get rid of other acts because of 'competetion'.

[30stone]

I agree.

100%

[rayheartbliss]

;)

[Loukas]

Originally posted by 30stone
I agree.

100%

[LemonJam]

Austin was a threat to the girls definatley.

[30stone]

Originally posted by LemonJam
Austin was a threat to the girls definatley.

imo the biggest threat.

[Tom4784]

I agree, Austin was 4th or 5th favourite to win but he was far behind the girls. There'd be no reason to vote him out, Louis on the other hand voted him out because they posed a threat to his over-hyped (By far NOT the best group) last act.

[Tom]

If Austin or Rachel were that big a threat, they wouldn't be in the bottom 2. Simple as.

[Z]

Originally posted by Tom
If Austin or Rachel were that big a threat, they wouldn't be in the bottom 2. Simple as.

Yeah, which leaves Eoghan and JLS. Somehow, I think any one of the three girls have it in the bag.

[XxShortyxX]

If Austin was such a threat to the girls, why was he in the bottom two? he couldn't of been that much of a threat, the girls obvs have way more fans then him.

[Emzy-!!]

I agree.
Louis only care about JLS to begin with, so he gave the other groups rubbish songs and spent no time with them!!!!

[robb]

Devil's advocate..............cheryl obviously was given the stongest SIX acts to choose from, any 5 of them would have made it this far......why did cheryl get the girls anyway? It would have been far more interesting if she'd had to take on the groups, or maybe even the over 25's........ther 'cheryl factor' was always going to help the girls.

[xERFx]

Originally posted by robb
Devil's advocate..............cheryl obviously was given the stongest SIX acts to choose from, any 5 of them would have made it this far......why did cheryl get the girls anyway? It would have been far more interesting if she'd had to take on the groups, or maybe even the over 25's........ther 'cheryl factor' was always going to help the girls. ther 'cheryl factor' was always going to help the girls

Yer but if you think about it who would be better to work with young girls than a young women popstar

[Tom]

Originally posted by ERF-Saratowinbb9
Originally posted by robb
Devil's advocate..............cheryl obviously was given the stongest SIX acts to choose from, any 5 of them would have made it this far......why did cheryl get the girls anyway? It would have been far more interesting if she'd had to take on the groups, or maybe even the over 25's........ther 'cheryl factor' was always going to help the girls. ther 'cheryl factor' was always going to help the girls

Yer but if you think about it who would be better to work with young girls than a young women popstar

Apply Cheryl to last years category. Would she still be the winning judge? Probably not.