So apparently Diana Is getting a free pass to next Week!

[Wildcat!]

Should we just stop the competition now, and give her the crown. I mean, whats the point?

http://www.mirror.co.uk/celebs/latest/2008/11/08/x-factor-finalist-diana-vickers-told-not-to-sing-115875-20878204/

Not 100% yet, but it seems almost like she isnt gonna sing!

[M X]

Aww..poor Diana, GWS!

[Red Moon]

She shouldn't get a free pass, it just seems on unfair on all the others who have to sing for there place, but she will.

There is no way they could have two go this week, unless they had planned to lose two people at some point in the show, which I'm sure they haven't.

[XxShortyxX]

Diana will sing tonight, and yes we should just give her the crown now because she is going to win anyway :bigsmile:

[*mazedsalv**]

I hope she does sing, because if she doesnt and gets a free pass, then loads of people would be moaning on forums and stuff. But they cant get her out of the show because all the people that were voting for her in the last 4 weeks would be proper pissed.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Red Moon
She shouldn't get a free pass, it just seems on unfair on all the others who have to sing for there place, but she will.

There is no way they could have two go this week, unless they had planned to lose two people at some point in the show, which I'm sure they haven't.

They had a double elimination in week 3 in 2006, and one was planned for week 3 in 2007 but Emily was kicked off. I'm sure Simon would not mind a double - seeing as it would be a sure fire way of getting Daniel off he show.

I think if Diana is ill, then she should be given a pas to next weeks show. It's only fair, seeing as we all know she would be safe anyway.

[Wildcat!]

So this is aparently true then!

What a farce it really is! It just confirms that the winner is already known and chosen. I guarantee you if Daniel had the same think, there is no way he was getting a pass!
Ah well, its a soap opera as expected! NOt worth watching really!

[Annie]

If she cant sing - she should have to leave :whistle:

[LemonJam]

Unfair.

[XxShortyxX]

If she can't sing, or even talk then it must be really bad, you can't ask her to sing because she could damage her voice and then she would never be able to sing, so what is she to do? is it her fault she is ill then? Ruth had a sore throat, but obvs it wasn't as bad as Diana's.

[NettoSuperstar!]

I bet she'll sing its nonsense

[Wildcat!]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
If she can't sing, or even talk then it must be really bad, you can't ask her to sing because she could damage her voice and then she would never be able to sing, so what is she to do? is it her fault she is ill then? Ruth had a sore throat, but obvs it wasn't as bad as Diana's.

Ermm people in competition, who are hurt, pull out! regardless if they are the favorites or not, weather its their fault or not. Its part of life. If the 100m dash world record holder pulls his harmstring before the olympics qualifiers, they pull out! And have to wait another 4 years to get a chance!
This is definitely unfair, and it shows just what I thought, they have their script and they dont want it to be spoiled! The show is a joke!

[NettoSuperstar!]

Its just a story to reel us all in it wont happen

[XxShortyxX]

But she can sing next week, this is the X Factor, not what you were just saying.

[KKBL]

Alexandra,Ruth and many x-XF contestants(such as Leona) where in a similar situation to Diana yet they still had to sing so why shouldnt Dianna?

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by KKBL
Alexandra,Ruth and many x-XF contestants(such as Leona) where in a similar situation to Diana yet they still had to sing so why shouldnt Dianna?

As I said, she may have it really bad.

[Tom4784]

As a fan of Diana I'm glad but I can see why people are mad. To be fair though Diana's got Laryngitis which is a lot more serious then the throat infections other contestants have had. I hope this is all just a publicity stunt though.

[XxShortyxX]

Also Ruth had a sore throat, not laryngitis. Apparently they will comfirm it at 4 if she will sing or not.

[Wildcat!]

I dont really care if she has whatever! If she cant sing, she should be out of the competition. Anything else, is just favoritism,no matter how you put it!
Like I said, it just flushes this show's already dodgy credibility, down the toilet!
And I tell you what, I guarantee you, to soften the blow of this Bullshhit, all the acts are gonna be praised tonight, mark my words, so the fans of other acts arent gonna be angry about this!

[XxShortyxX]

You are only saying that because you don't like her, if it was JLS, you wouldn't be saying that.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Yeh would you say the same if the it was the JLS boys eh eh?

[Wildcat!]

Are you joking? If it was anyone, I would want them gone! Anyone who cant see the injustice in this is just blind, or put the blinders on!
Anyways, I will just follow the script and watch it like a movie now!
Kinda like WWF wrestling! Just dont waste your money voting is what I say!

[NettoSuperstar!]

lol Im sure this wont happen anyway but we'll see

[XxShortyxX]

I am blind to nothing thank you, we don't even know yet if she will sing or not!

[Wildcat!]

Originally posted by NettoSuperstar!
Yeh would you say the same if the it was the JLS boys eh eh?

Have you ever seen me be biased towards JLS? I have favorites, but I am not that fussed if they win or not! They arent gonna win anyways we already know who is gonna win! But if they couldnt sing I would expect them to pull out!

[Billy]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
I dont really care if she has whatever! If she cant sing, she should be out of the competition. Anything else, is just favoritism,no matter how you put it!
Like I said, it just flushes this show's already dodgy credibility, down the toilet!
And I tell you what, I guarantee you, to soften the blow of this Bullshhit, all the acts are going to be praised tonight, mark my words, so the fans of other acts arent going to be angry about this!


Could you imagine the complaints the show would get if she kicked off?

[*mazedsalv**]

Originally posted by KKBL
Alexandra,Ruth and many x-XF contestants(such as Leona) where in a similar situation to Diana yet they still had to sing so why shouldnt Dianna?

Because all the other acts had coughs/croaky voices, but Diana has laryngitis, theres a massive diference. If Diana is in the worst case scenario, she probably cant speak at all.

[Wildcat!]

It doesnt matter if there are complains! I think they will get them either way! But at least if she is eliminated, it would be legitimate. Atfter all, the show have nothing to gain form eliminating the favorite! So what can they complain about? That they were fair?

[Billy]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
It doesnt matter if there are complains! I think they will get them either way! But at least if she is eliminated, it would be legitimate. Atfter all, the show have nothing to gain form eliminating the favorite! So what can they complain about? That they were fair?

Are you being serious? This happens with EVERY show, if someone is ill. So stop being so pathetic as to blame it on the fact that it is because she is the favourite.

Seriously, I wonder about you sometimes..

[Killian]

If she gets a free pass, I'm not watching this show anymore.

Absolutely ludicrous.

:mad:

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
It doesnt matter if there are complains! I think they will get them either way! But at least if she is eliminated, it would be legitimate. Atfter all, the show have nothing to gain form eliminating the favorite! So what can they complain about? That they were fair?

Are you being serious? This happens with EVERY show, if someone is ill. So stop being so pathetic as to blame it on the fact that it is because she is the favourite.

Seriously, I wonder about you sometimes..


Well said Billy :thumbs:

Also, I have just read over on DS that Diana still wants to go a head a sing tonight, but doctors have adivised her not to, so it's up to Diana.

[Kornetto]

I don't mind if she does , shes got a unique voice anyway. [: even if her name goes up on phoneline , bet alll her fans will keep her in. :thumbs:

[Christina]

Originally posted by KKBL
Alexandra,Ruth and many x-XF contestants(such as Leona) where in a similar situation to Diana yet they still had to sing so why shouldnt Dianna?

[Sam!]

Originally posted by Killian
If she gets a free pass, I'm not watching this show anymore.

Absolutely ludicrous.

:mad:

What else is she susposed to do? Just stand there not being able to sing and people vote or people vote when she hasn't sung. Its not her fault, higher people are saying she can't sing not Diana.

[Tom]

She'll perform. Its all being over hyped to get people to watch to see if she performs or not.

In the small chance that she doesn't perform, then its not fair on the other acts if shes given a free pass. Although she wouldn't be in the bottom two tonight anyway the public should still have to vote for her. What they vote on I have no idea.

If it was Daniel he would be forced to withdraw.

[Princess]

Either way she was gonna get through anyway. They can't kick out her if she is so ill that she can't talk.

[Indierock&roll]

on the news it said shes not singing :/
i wish she was i love her performances

[M X]

:sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad: :sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad::sad:

[Wildcat!]

So any bets as to who is coming 2nd! Thats the only thing left isnt there!

[30stone]

so having a medical problem you should just leave because of the shedule of x factor?

she wasnt leaving this week any way.

[pinkmichk]

she shouldnt be allowed a free pass laringitus is really serious to the point she can do permanant damage to her voice the others just had sore throats but its no excuse plus is she gonna get suddenly better to sing next week i am pretty laringitus is a fairly long running throat illness so what happens if she cant sing again next week

[Wildcat!]

Dont even worry yourself! If she cant sing next week, we'll just give her another week!
I mean, we cant have the show without the winner in it!
Anyways, still taking bets for 2nd place! I am going for Laura, altough I am sure Simon's dream final is with Owen!

[M X]

I was devastated Diana didn't perform tonight. Get well soon gal'! xxx.

[hannah.]

Originally posted by pinkmichk
she shouldnt be allowed a free pass laringitus is really serious to the point she can do permanant damage to her voice the others just had sore throats but its no excuse plus is she going to get suddenly better to sing next week i am pretty laringitus is a fairly long running throat illness so what happens if she cant sing again next week

exactly.
it said on the video thingy that if she sung she could have permanent damage to her voice box which is a lie

[Deirdre]

I thought the show tonight felt lost without Diana, It was like it was missing something..

[NettoSuperstar!]

Well I have to eat ma hat they did it but who cares aslong as they do the same for everyone. I do agree that if shes ill next week she should have to pull out tho. I missed her last night the show was lacking summat!

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by patheticfool
I thought the show tonight felt lost without Diana, It was like it was missing something..

Yeh too rite man:thumbs:

[Lewis.]

I think Alexandra really sparkled last night and proved that she can be as good as Diana..

[Adamw92]

Even though i'm glad Alexandra was the best last night it just felt kinda empty without Diana there

[Billy]

Originally posted by Lewiis.Xx
I think Alexandra really sparkled last night and proved that she can be as good as Diana..

What difference does that make if Diana was there or nto?

[XxShortyxX]

IMO, it felt horrible Diana wasn't, last ngiht just wasn't the same. Alex was by far the best last ngiht though.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Tom
She'll perform. Its all being over hyped to get people to watch to see if she performs or not.

In the small chance that she doesn't perform, then its not fair on the other acts if shes given a free pass. Although she wouldn't be in the bottom two tonight anyway the public should still have to vote for her. What they vote on I have no idea.

If it was Daniel he would be forced to withdraw.

No he wouldnt.

Rik Waller
David Seamen
Naomi from FA

All got a pass to the following week. It'd be the same for Daniel as it is in their contracts.

[rayheartbliss]

you just dont like her, so what your saying isnt realy relevant!
^_^

they didnt let her sing because if she did, she could have a long term damage, so basicly she didnt sing so that she could sing next week!

the others didnt have severe damage, but she could have lost her voice if she sang that night.

[Sod_James]

Diana is a good singer.

but at the end of the day she couldnt sing. she should have left the competition in my opinion.

[Billy]

there would have been so many complaints if she did, considering they done it with every other ill contestant.

[Z]

I think they ought to have opened a phone line for Diana anyway, because there are people who think it's unfair she got into next week's show. By having a phone line for her, it would have been a sort of compromise between the two. She wasn't going to leave anyway, but it is a bit of a sham that they just let her through without any kind of viewer interaction.

[emmiemichelle]

To Be Honest..
I Think It Was Goood That She Got A Free Pass..
Because It Wouldn't Have Been Very Fair And Also I Don't Think It Would Have Made A Difference =S

[GiRTh]

Two passes? Fix. Why dont they just hand her the title now?

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Two passes? Fix. Why dont they just hand her the title now?

nah this is old. I agree if shes ill this week she will have to drop out

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by NettoSuperstar!
Originally posted by GiRTh
Two passes? Fix. Why dont they just hand her the title now?

nah this is old. I agree if shes ill this week she will have to drop out Sorry. I thought she was getting another free pass.