Log in

View Full Version : New X Factor Themes; What would you have?


LemonJam
09-11-2008, 02:53 PM
Lets face it, X Factor is just recycling themes from last year. If you could make any themes you want, what would they be?

I'd include:
- Acoustic Week
- Rock Week
- Self-written song week
- All time classics week
- Norweigan Viking Metal week (Just for the lols :hugesmile:)

What would you have?

Spike
09-11-2008, 02:54 PM
Scrap the themes completely, contestants pick their own songs each week

Damaris
09-11-2008, 02:59 PM
Originally posted by Spike
Scrap the themes completely, contestants pick their own songs each week

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:00 PM
for me, i think

week1 : best of british
week2 : big bands
week3 : acoustic
week4 : maria carey
week5 : disco
week6 : micheal jackson
week7 : rock *this will realy test them, and will show whos got the whole package*
week9 : all time classic
week10: self-written song

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:02 PM
Originally posted by mambosambo12
Originally posted by Spike
Scrap the themes completely, contestants pick their own songs each week

that would be pointless...because there is no challenge...and they would just look like copycats!

thats why they changed the sing off so that contestants can pick a song of their choice.

Annie
09-11-2008, 03:02 PM
I would defo have self written as i think its important in an artist

then:

love songs
movie soundtracks
a duet with another contestant
accoustic

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:04 PM
Originally posted by Annie

movie soundtracks


yerh i think that would be realy interesting!!!!


o.O?
*btw, i thought you left, or was that someone else*

Sam!
09-11-2008, 03:04 PM
I think Mariah Carey week sucked. DOn't they have a duet week near the end or sumin?

supernoodles!
09-11-2008, 03:04 PM
90`s week
rock
movie soundtracks

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:04 PM
Originally posted by Scampi
I think Mariah Carey week sucked. DOn't they have a duet week near the end or sumin?

i swear they had one last year

Annie
09-11-2008, 03:05 PM
Originally posted by rayheartbliss
Originally posted by Annie

movie soundtracks


yerh i think that would be realy interesting!!!!


o.O?
*btw, i thought you left, or was that someone else*

Yeah I left for a week. Came back. Haha

Spike
09-11-2008, 03:05 PM
Originally posted by rayheartbliss

that would be pontless...because there is no challenge...and they would just look like copycats!

thats why they changed the sing off so that contestants can pick a song of their choice.

So your saying it would be better for them to sing a style of song which they would never release? That meaning the public judging them on that is pointless
Whereas if they chose their own songs each week, we would know the kind of music they will be releasing if they win and we could judge them better

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:08 PM
Originally posted by Spike
Originally posted by rayheartbliss

that would be pontless...because there is no challenge...and they would just look like copycats!

thats why they changed the sing off so that contestants can pick a song of their choice.

So your saying it would be better for them to sing a style of song which they would never release? That meaning the public judging them on that is pointless
Whereas if they chose their own songs each week, we would know the kind of music they will be releasing if they win and we could judge them better

the whole point is to challenge them, if they sing in the same style, otherwise they'd just sound the same.

plus, the system that it has now wouldnt have been put for no reason.

Noel
09-11-2008, 03:09 PM
I think a current top 40 week would be interesting. If they could only sing songs that were in the charts that week, it would really show just how current each contestant is.

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:11 PM
:o

what about greece week

thats quite nice....

or they coould change next year's maria week to whitney week

Spike
09-11-2008, 03:12 PM
Originally posted by rayheartbliss
Originally posted by Spike
Originally posted by rayheartbliss

that would be pontless...because there is no challenge...and they would just look like copycats!

thats why they changed the sing off so that contestants can pick a song of their choice.

So your saying it would be better for them to sing a style of song which they would never release? That meaning the public judging them on that is pointless
Whereas if they chose their own songs each week, we would know the kind of music they will be releasing if they win and we could judge them better

the whole point is to challenge them, if they sing in the same style, otherwise they'd just sound the same.

plus, the system that it has now wouldnt have been put for no reason.
No. The whole point is to find an artist to release music and become successful. If that artist is good one genre of music, why make them sing others when they will never release music of that type?
Most artists sing the same style or close to it all the time and they are successful. You don't listen to Madonna for a big strong ballad like you don't listen to Leona for a huge, upbeat, catchy pop song.

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:13 PM
Originally posted by Bradley!
I think a current top 40 week would be interesting. If they could only sing songs that were in the charts that week, it would really show just how current each contestant is.

i like

NettoSuperstar!
09-11-2008, 03:13 PM
Originally posted by Spike
Originally posted by rayheartbliss
Originally posted by Spike
Originally posted by rayheartbliss

that would be pontless...because there is no challenge...and they would just look like copycats!

thats why they changed the sing off so that contestants can pick a song of their choice.

So your saying it would be better for them to sing a style of song which they would never release? That meaning the public judging them on that is pointless
Whereas if they chose their own songs each week, we would know the kind of music they will be releasing if they win and we could judge them better

the whole point is to challenge them, if they sing in the same style, otherwise they'd just sound the same.

plus, the system that it has now wouldnt have been put for no reason.
No. The whole point is to find an artist to release music and become successful. If that artist is good one genre of music, why make them sing others when they will never release music of that type?
Most artists sing the same style or close to it all the time and they are successful. You don't listen to Madonna for a big strong ballad like you don't listen to Leona for a huge, upbeat, catchy pop song.

no the whole point is to make a TV show

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:15 PM
Originally posted by Spike
Originally posted by rayheartbliss
Originally posted by Spike
Originally posted by rayheartbliss

that would be pontless...because there is no challenge...and they would just look like copycats!

thats why they changed the sing off so that contestants can pick a song of their choice.

So your saying it would be better for them to sing a style of song which they would never release? That meaning the public judging them on that is pointless
Whereas if they chose their own songs each week, we would know the kind of music they will be releasing if they win and we could judge them better

the whole point is to challenge them, if they sing in the same style, otherwise they'd just sound the same.

plus, the system that it has now wouldnt have been put for no reason.
No. The whole point is to find an artist to release music and become successful. If that artist is good one genre of music, why make them sing others when they will never release music of that type?
Most artists sing the same style or close to it all the time and they are successful. You don't listen to Madonna for a big strong ballad like you don't listen to Leona for a huge, upbeat, catchy pop song.

well, tell them that...because they are the once trying to find someone with the "X-FACTOR"
so they have to see different side of them.

like i said, they wouldnt just make the system like that for no reason

jkp44
09-11-2008, 03:21 PM
But wouldn't self-written week take too long like take a long time 2 write the songs and then produce a melody for them and then rehearse wouldn't it be abit I don't know like rushed.b and really pressurised.

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 03:33 PM
Originally posted by jkp44
But wouldn't self-written week take too long like take a long time 2 write the songs and then produce a melody for them and then rehearse wouldn't it be abit I don't know like rushed.b and really pressurised.
yerh i guess,
maybe they could just do that for their first song on the last week! ^_^

dupin
09-11-2008, 03:46 PM
Motown Week! That's the best week, I wish they'd have it again...

Adamw92
09-11-2008, 05:36 PM
I'd love a completely christmas theme for the final, all christmas songs except the winners song obviously

Indierock&roll
09-11-2008, 05:49 PM
tv programme themes hahah
love someone to sing home and away or something

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 05:56 PM
Originally posted by Indierock&roll
home and away or something

lol

haha

Tom4784
09-11-2008, 05:56 PM
Christian Death Metal week FTW!!!!!

rayheartbliss
09-11-2008, 06:00 PM
XD

a death metal week......hmmmmm
XD lol

Jen
09-11-2008, 06:05 PM
week1 : Bob Dylan
week2 : Acoustic
week3 : The Beatles
week4 : 70's
week5 : Rock Anthems
week6 : Niel Diamond :lovedup:
week7 : 80's
week9 : TV Theme songs
week10: Classic Christmas songs