Silent Hill vs. Resident Evil (Movies)

[Scarlett.]

Which is better?
Silent Hill the movie
or
The Resident Evil movie series?


IMO Resi has the best films out of them, Silent Hill's plot is altered too much, replacing an actual weird and scary cult (The Order) with some weird Catholic witch burners

[Tom4784]

Silent Hill I thought. It stuck closer to the actual style and look of the game, the plot was altered in points but it was closer to the story of SH1 then the Resi films were to the game. I like the Resident Evil films but if I watched them without knowing what it was i could never guess it was a Resident Evil Film.

[rayheartbliss]

ive never seen the silent hill movie, cuz i thought it was just games

isit any good?

[Tom4784]

I thought it was one of the best Hollywood game adaptions. The story is a bit confusing to anyone who hasn't played the games and elements have been changed but I'd reccomend it.

[Scarlett.]

I love the Silent Hill movie though

They took so many things from the game, and secretly hid them, its so much fun trying to spot em all


damn....I wanna change my vote to Silent Hill now :sad:

[001steven]

Resident Evil silnet hill movies are rubbish :bored:

[Rory]

I haven't played either games, but both movies are terrible.

The first Resident Evil was alright, the second one was ridiculous, and the third just showed they were trying to milk the franchise for all its worth.

The Silent Hill movie was just hilarious at how awful it was.

If I had to vote, it'd be Resident Evil, but only the first one.