Get Diana Out!!

[Saph]

i dnt see what every1 sees in her. i think shes really boring and her voice isent that good. all she does it sit on chairs or stand still moving her hands around
:conf2:
Love - Ruth
Like -
Hate - Diana, Twatboy, JLS, Alexandra

[Indierock&roll]

her voice is amazing..
and different
she should win ..

[*mazedsalv**]

I love Diana

[Matt08]

No, as I said with Alexandra earlier, it would be a travesty for her not to get to the finals. She's unique and has a fantastic voice. Whether she wins the show or not, she will definitely be signed with Sony BMG.

Simon Cowell made that clear last night when he responded to Gary Barlow's proposal for her.

[ParentalAdvisory]

She is different. She's different from someone who can sing.

[Mrluvaluva]

I think she has a great voice.

[Saph]

ok i quess i am the only 1 who hates diana and her hands of bordem

[Matt08]

Originally posted by SaphLiike
ok i quess i am the only 1 who hates diana and her hands of bordem

Nah, you're not. There's a few other members on here who dislike her.

[Z]

Different yes, but she's got no idea how to use her voice in terms of conforming to a theme. She was crap singing Yellow, and she was crap singing Patience. She's been the worst for two weeks running in my opinion, but I agree, she ought to make the final, but if she wins I will be furious.

[ParentalAdvisory]

Saph - I think you'll find I share your view. Scroll up.

[Matt08]

Originally posted by Z
Different yes, but she's got no idea how to use her voice in terms of conforming to a theme. She was c**p singing Yellow, and she was c**p singing Patience. She's been the worst for two weeks running in my opinion, but I agree, she ought to make the final, but if she wins I will be furious.

Whether she wins or not, Simon will sign her. You're not going to get away from her that easily. Maybe you'll change your mind on her once she releases some of her own material.

[Mrluvaluva]

Originally posted by Z

She's been the worst for two weeks running in my opinion, but I agree, she ought to make the final, but if she wins I will be furious.


I wouldn't say she was the worst. I picked Rachel and DFS as the worst 2 last night.

[ParentalAdvisory]

DFS? lol

I saw no evidence of sofas.

[Mrluvaluva]

They are about as entertaining as one.

[ParentalAdvisory]

I wouldn't say that. I think their mentor is the problem though. They could use someone like P.Diddy to mentor them in my view. He might be able to come up with something remotely relevant to their style.

[Matt08]

Originally posted by ParentalAdvisory
I wouldn't say that. I think their mentor is the problem though. They could use someone like P.Diddy to mentor them in my view. He might be able to come up with something remotely relevant to their style.

P Diddy! :laugh2:

I suppose anyone is better than Louis though.

[Mrluvaluva]

You might have something there. He is a million miles away from Louis, but could he pull the same faces? I would miss that.

[Z]

Originally posted by Matt08
Originally posted by Z
Different yes, but she's got no idea how to use her voice in terms of conforming to a theme. She was c**p singing Yellow, and she was c**p singing Patience. She's been the worst for two weeks running in my opinion, but I agree, she ought to make the final, but if she wins I will be furious.

Whether she wins or not, Simon will sign her. You're not going to get away from her that easily. Maybe you'll change your mind on her once she releases some of her own material.


The thing is, I liked her until the whole laryngitis debacle. Both her performances since her week off have been rubbish, and I find her voice really irritating now. She was the worst last night, followed closely by Rachel and JLS.

[Matt08]

I think JLS' best mentor would be Cheryl. I think she'd modernize their song choices and give them a much better chance. Simon would be better with the girls and Dannii with the boys. Not sure who'd be good with the over 25's.

[ParentalAdvisory]

Z, I used to like her also. But now I find her phlegm-gargling irritating as ****.

[Z]

Originally posted by ParentalAdvisory
Z, I used to like her also. But now I find her phlegm-gargling irritating as ****.

Yep. I can't believe people can point blank deny that she's not been bad in the past two weeks. Yellow was rubbish, she was evidently ill, to be fair, but it was rubbish, yet I still see people defending her and refusing to admit it was bad. Then this week with Patience - she was off key so many times in that performance it actually hurt.

[ParentalAdvisory]

I find Diana fans to be like this on other forums as well though. She can't put a foot wrong. At least I have the balls to admit when my favourite act makes an arse of it one week. I hate this blind [or should that be 'deaf'] loyalty a lot of the Diana fans seem to have.

[Mrluvaluva]

I didn't rate her performance last night but I don't think it was the worst. Maybe I am biased. I just don't like Rachel's voice.

[ParentalAdvisory]

Rachel is a poor-man's Amy Winehouse.

[Matt08]

Originally posted by ParentalAdvisory
Rachel is a poor-man's Amy Winehouse.

Some weeks she sang that loud that it could be classed as shouting. Her mentor didn't help because they found it difficult to work together. Thus, she got awful song choices moreless every week.

[ParentalAdvisory]

Yeah, they were a useless pairing. She might have got on better with Simon because he wouldn't take any of her shite. Danni let her away with acting like a twat.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Z She was c**p singing Yellow, and she was c**p singing Patience. She's been the worst for two weeks running in my opinion, [/quote]Finally ,someone who saw the same show as me. She failed to hit the high note every time she tried and the backing singers were also drowning her out. I still dont see what it is that everyone see in her. Her voice is different but as a singer she's not in anywhere near the same league as Alex or Ruth or even Austin or Laura.

If she wins this contest simply because of that squeaky yodel she puts on her voice then it will be an even bigger travesty than Leon's ridiculous win last year.

[NettoSuperstar!]

She wasnt the worse, JlS and Egg were worse. Ruth was the only one on the night worthy of any praise. I admit she was a bit ropey at the start but then pulled it back towards the end. Overall, over the whole competition I still think shes been the most exiciting performer. I dont see anyone else who should win more

[Annie]

I agree. GET DIANA OUT!!!

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by NettoSuperstar!
She wasnt the worse, JlS and Egg were worse. Ruth was the only one on the night worthy of any praise. I admit she was a bit ropey at the start but then pulled it back towards the end. Overall, over the whole competition I still think shes been the most exiciting performer. I dont see anyone else who should win more What about Alex? She has yet to give a poor performance.

Diana failed to hit the high note in the chorus every time she tried it and I noticed the backing singers drowned her out every time. She again showed a lack of power and range. How many weeks have I been saying she has no power and range? And she's yet to prove me wrong.

[Annie]

Originally posted by SaphLiike
i dont see what every1 sees in her. i think shes really boring and her voice isent that good. all she does it sit on chairs or stand still moving her hands around
:conf2:
Love - Ruth
Like -
Hate - Diana, Twatboy, JLS, Alexandra

Also,

This made me LOL

[JOSHUAH!]

I'd love to see Diana out, shes a good singer but everything else is rubbish, and if you want a singer you need to like EVERYTHING, and I don't.

Also hating JLS who were TERRIBLE on the sing-off, compared to Rachel.

[30stone]

Originally posted by ParentalAdvisory
Rachel is a poor-man's Amy Winehouse.

off key poor and **** version.

and i hate amy

[ParentalAdvisory]

I also hate Amy. Glad to see I'm not the only one. People always go on about her talent. I can't stand to listen to her.

[Loukas]

as long as ruth or alexandra wins im happy :P

[ParentalAdvisory]

I'd say they both have a good chance. For pure singing talent, they are a cut above the rest.

[rayheartbliss]

no.
:)