Diana should dance, says Friedman

[Red Moon]

Diana should dance, says FriedmanThe X Factor choreographer Brian Friedman is frustrated that Diana Vickers hasn't danced yet in the show, and thinks it could lose her votes.

Brian worked out a big dance number for Diana but her mentor Cheryl Cole switched the song at the last minute.

"When Diana did Yellow she was actually supposed to be doing the All Saints song Never Ever but it was switched.
Source: Metro (http://www.metro.co.uk/fame/article.html?Diana_should_dance,_says_Friedman&in_article_id=417644&in_page_id=7&in_a_source=)

[GiRTh]

It seems the little miss knows her weaknesses and is playing to them. She is the only contestant to not put on any kind of show so far yet she’s still getting the praise of the judges. I'd like to see her diversify more and show she's not a limited as I think.

Intriguing to see she was supposed to do Never Ever. She'd have murdered that.

[bigbrocks]

As far as I am concerned, she couldnt have murdered it worst than yellow.
But dancing wise, I really dont see the problem. It is a singing competition after all. Leona Lewis wasnt exactly the dancing type. She hardly done it when she won! She can sing without dancing if she is comfortable with that! I am more concern about her singing without making my ears bleed!

[Tom]

If anything not dancing will add votes. The choreography is awful and Brian must go ASAP

[Annie]

I absolutely LOVE Brian. Being an artist is not just about singing. Its about performing

[30stone]

Alex hasnt really danced ? or ruth?...

why diana...

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by 30stone
Alex hasnt really danced ? or ruth?...

why diana... Alex has.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by 30stone
Alex hasnt really danced ? or ruth?...

why diana...

Dont come out and say something completely untrue like that. Alex, forst song was I want to dance with somebody, she danced throughout the song. Candyman she danced throughout the song, and last week was a huge dance routine even with extras. I dont really think anyone should have to dance, but give credit where credit is due for god sakes!

[30stone]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by 30stone
Alex hasnt really danced ? or ruth?...

why diana... Alex has.

hardly.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by 30stone
Alex hasnt really danced ? or ruth?...

why diana... Alex has.

hardly.

You obviously have amnesia, so lets remind you!

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=AJpr_5nI4es

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=DbVh2_O-DD4

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=Si2CbmiIXEI

[xERFx]

I agree in the fact that Alex has danced but not alot in candyman she was just bobbing a bit

[30stone]

Still... thats not much...

but not even the point the point is they are singling out even though ruth doesnt and others who have left havent.

[XxShortyxX]

She dance a bit on Call Me, thing dancing doesn't sell records, Ruth hasn't danced yet either, me think they are excepting way too much from Diana. Leona Lewis doesn't dance, and look at her, TT don't really dance either.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by 30stone
Still... thats not much...

but not even the point the point is they are singling out even though ruth doesnt and others who have left havent.

Errrrm, we all know what the point was, we speak english. HOwever, thats not what you said. You said Alex Hasnt really danced. She has danced on most her songs, so you are talking rubbish! ANd, you say "still that not much"??:rolleyes::rolleyes:

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
She dance a bit on Call Me, thing dancing doesn't sell records, Ruth hasn't danced yet either, me think they are excepting way too much from Diana. Leona Lewis doesn't dance, and look at her, TT don't really dance either. t

She didnt dance anything. SHe sat down stood up for 10 seconds and sat down again! Fair enough, I dont care if she doesnt want to dance as long as she sings well, but dont go making stuff up: She didnt dance at all, we all have eyes!

[30stone]

Originally posted by bigbrocks
Originally posted by 30stone
Still... thats not much...

but not even the point the point is they are singling out even though ruth doesnt and others who have left havent.

Errrrm, we all know what the point was, we speak english. HOwever, thats not what you said. You said Alex Hasnt really danced. She has danced on most her songs, so you are talking rubbish! ANd, still that not much??:rolleyes::rolleyes:

well the first video you put was her walking around and turning side ways and candyman was bobbing up n down n that.

so im not really talking rubbish she has hasnt done a lot. nothing special at least..

[XxShortyxX]

I am not making anything up, I said she danced a bit! I wouldn't mind seeing her dance, she probably ca ndance anyway.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by bigbrocks
Originally posted by 30stone
Still... thats not much...

but not even the point the point is they are singling out even though ruth doesnt and others who have left havent.

Errrrm, we all know what the point was, we speak english. HOwever, thats not what you said. You said Alex Hasnt really danced. She has danced on most her songs, so you are talking rubbish! ANd, still that not much??:rolleyes::rolleyes:

well the first video you put was her walking around and turning side ways and candyman was bobbing up n down n that.

so Im not really talking rubbish she has hasnt done a lot. nothing special at least..

Yeah you are talking rubbish, you can close your eyes and make daft statements all you like, the fact is, she danced, she had a dance choreography on candyman, its called dancing. Again, youre the one who brought her name up. One of the rare acts who always have a dance routine, so yes, you were talking craap!!!

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
I am not making anything up, I said she danced a bit! I wouldn't mind seeing her dance, she probably ca ndance anyway.


Yes you are! Because she didnt dance a bit, she didnt dance at all whatsoever. meaning zero!!!!! Like I said, I dont mind if she doesnt know how to dance, not everyone does, and its not required, but the fact is, she didnt!

[XxShortyxX]

She moved, watch it again, she was moving her hips, that is classed as dancing! I know what I saw, she even moived with the dancers at one point.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
She moved, watch it again, she was moving her hips, that is classed as dancing! I know what I saw, she even moived with the dancers at one point.

I dont need to watch it again, I have a good enough memory. She strolled on stage, sat down, she stood up for 10 seconds waved her hand to her face, and sat down again. Never danced!!!! 0 dancing.
She moves her hips on both her last 2 performances, thats not dancing! Even Louis criticized her for not dancing on call me, and no one denied it!

[xERFx]

Well anyway its brians job to get diana to dance by organising the chereography and he hasnt done a very good job so i dont see why he's complaining

[Annie]

Alex has danced.

30stone you are delusional saying otherwise.

[XxShortyxX]

Yeah Alex has danced, more than once, she actually danced a bit last Saturday.

[30stone]

Originally posted by bigbrocks
Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by bigbrocks
Originally posted by 30stone
Still... thats not much...

but not even the point the point is they are singling out even though ruth doesnt and others who have left havent.

Errrrm, we all know what the point was, we speak english. HOwever, thats not what you said. You said Alex Hasnt really danced. She has danced on most her songs, so you are talking rubbish! ANd, still that not much??:rolleyes::rolleyes:

well the first video you put was her walking around and turning side ways and candyman was bobbing up n down n that.

so Im not really talking rubbish she has hasnt done a lot. nothing special at least..

Yeah you are talking rubbish, you can close your eyes and make daft statements all you like, the fact is, she danced, she had a dance choreography on candyman, its called dancing. Again, youre the one who brought her name up. One of the rare acts who always have a dance routine, so yes, you were talking craap!!!

yet dianas wasnt dancing and candyman is..


but yeh alex has danced every week now that i have seen the videos i dont pay much atention to her usually because she bores me.

but anyway ****ing hell. the point is im trying to say diana get singled out constantly at the moment ..

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by 30stone
but anyway ****ing hell. the point is Im trying to say diana get singled out constantly at the moment .. Of course she is. Its cuz firstly she missed a week and secondly cuz she's puts in average erformance but still gets praised.

She gets so much praise, I think the criticism redresses the balance.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by 30stone

yet dianas wasnt dancing and candyman is..


but yeh alex has danced every week now that i have seen the videos i dont pay much atention to her usually because she bores me.

but anyway ****ing hell. the point is Im trying to say diana get singled out constantly at the moment ..

Yes thats right, Diana wasnt dancing. In fact she spent 90% of the time sitting! If you wanted make the point that Diana get singled out all the time, or its not a dancing competiton, you shouldve said so, and not mentioned Alex in the same group as an non dancing act. You brought her name up, I didnt! And ovbviously you were talking craap! And amyways this is his choreographer trying to improve her performances, not single her out!

[XxShortyxX]

Like I said, they are average to YOU.

[30stone]

Originally posted by bigbrocks
[quote]Originally posted by 30stone

yet dianas wasnt dancing and candyman is..


but yeh alex has danced every week now that i have seen the videos i dont pay much atention to her usually because she bores me.

but anyway ****ing hell. the point is Im trying to say diana get singled out constantly at the moment ..

Yes thats right, Diana wasnt dancing. In fact she spent 90% of the time sitting! If you wanted make the point that Diana get singled out all the time, or its not a dancing competiton, you shouldve said so, and not mentioned Alex in the same group as an non dancing act. You brought her name up, I didnt! And ovbviously you were talking craap! And amyways this is his choreographer trying to improve her performances, not single her out! [/quote

i wasnt talking crap so stop aying it you ****.

i said it without checking her performances a simple error not me talking crap.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Like I said, they are average to YOU. As I said before, when a singer is not hitting the right note then its pretty obvious to everone. Its not about opinions anymore. its about telling it as it is.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by 30stone

i wasnt talking c**p so stop aying it you ****.

i said it without checking her performances a simple error not me talking c**p.

Thats the exact definition of talking craap! Making statements without even knowing what youre talking about! Next time be sure before you make daft comments.

[30stone]

Originally posted by bigbrocks
Originally posted by 30stone

i wasnt talking c**p so stop aying it you ****.

i said it without checking her performances a simple error not me talking c**p.

Thats the exact definition of talking craap! Making statements without even knowing what youre talking about! Next time be sure before you make daft comments.

Ill do as i like -.-

and making an error doesnt mean talking crap. its called making a mistake.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by bigbrocks
Originally posted by 30stone

i wasnt talking c**p so stop aying it you ****.

i said it without checking her performances a simple error not me talking c**p.

Thats the exact definition of talking craap! Making statements without even knowing what youre talking about! Next time be sure before you make daft comments.

Ill do as i like -.-

and making an error doesnt mean talking c**p. its called making a mistake.

BUt you did not make a mistake! You commented on something you didnt know about, by your own admission. Its like making a book review on a book that you didnt read, or that you dont remember: AKA talking Craap!
And my apologies, you can do as you like of course. Just dont expect me to let it slide!

[XxShortyxX]

Anyway getting back to the Article, I wouldn't mind seeing Diana dance, but it is what she feels comfortable doing, not all singers dance, though I think she would be a good dancer.

[30stone]

Originally posted by bigbrocks
Originally posted by 30stone
Originally posted by bigbrocks
Originally posted by 30stone

i wasnt talking c**p so stop aying it you ****.

i said it without checking her performances a simple error not me talking c**p.

Thats the exact definition of talking craap! Making statements without even knowing what youre talking about! Next time be sure before you make daft comments.

Ill do as i like -.-

and making an error doesnt mean talking c**p. its called making a mistake.

BUt you did not make a mistake! You commented on something you didnt know about, by your own admission. Its like making a book review on a book that you didnt read, or that you dont remember: AKA talking Craap!
And my apologies, you can do as you like of course. Just dont expect me to let it slide!

lol im done.
i was just trying to give an example gave a bad ones and said she did dance after i had seen it so it doesnt matter now.

[bigbrocks]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Anyway getting back to the Article, I wouldn't mind seeing Diana dance, but it is what she feels comfortable doing, not all singers dance, though I think she would be a good dancer.

Thats fair enough! Thats what I said in my first post. She can dance if she feels it would make her performance better, but maybe she isnt comfortable dancing and singing at the same time. Not everyone is. BUt this is not star academy so she is not required to dance. I personally wouldnt try to force her to if its not in her nature.

[pinkmichk]

people must be forgetting the unmistakable diana hand dance she does every single week obviously getting that just right stops her being able to focus on dancing as well

[Tom]

Originally posted by 30stone
Still... thats not much...

but not even the point the point is they are singling out even though ruth doesnt and others who have left havent.

Alex has danced more than she hasn't! Don't forget disco week as well. Thats 4 out of 7, plus shes moved about the stage in all of her performances unlike Diana who seems to be super glued to the one spot apart from that week where she walked from the judges desk to the doors

[Lauren]

Dancing will take away from the vocals. It's a singing competition. However, it must be better than her usual...

http://www.jumperlumps.com/product_images/669/thumbnail_jazz_hands.gif

[Annie]

The only dancing diana has EVER done is move her hands around her face

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Annie
The only dancing diana has EVER done is move her hands around her face

The way the Yodelling Barbie Doll does that is really doing my heading in. According to some reports in the press there is a facebook group complaining about it.

http://www.tvscoop.tv/2008/11/diana_vickers_l.html

[XxShortyxX]

Barbie Doll? because she has Blonde hair?

Dance or not, I am not really bothered, I will enjoy her performance whatever. The hand thing can annoy me, but I think that's just her style and what she feels comfortable doing. She does move about on stage though (not dancing).

[GiRTh]

She hardly 'moves' around the stage. She walks every now and again but thats' all.

[ParentalAdvisory]

Originally posted by Red Moon
The way the Yodelling Barbie Doll does that is really doing my heading in. According to some reports in the press there is a facebook group complaining about it.

http://www.tvscoop.tv/2008/11/diana_vickers_l.html

The story in that linkage is highly amusing.

[GiRTh]

From the article:

"I just don't get what all the fuss is about. Firstly she doesn't annunciate when she is singing so it sounds like one big rambling sentence. Secondly the 'quirky and original' thing is just plain strange. If being quirky and original means looking like you haven't brushed your hair for 5 years and have been dragged through a bush backwards then I would rather be boring and ordinary. Thirdly, does the girl not own a pair of shoes?! I mean what the ****** statement is she trying to make by coming out barefoot every week? Beyond me! And of course, last but not least I am going to make it my mission to travel down to London and cut off her ****ing left hand if she does not stop touching her face with it. Yes, you have a hand, yes you have a face but you don't need to caress it every week."

LMAO

[pinkmichk]

Originally posted by GiRTh
From the article:

"I just don't get what all the fuss is about. Firstly she doesn't annunciate when she is singing so it sounds like one big rambling sentence. Secondly the 'quirky and original' thing is just plain strange. If being quirky and original means looking like you haven't brushed your hair for 5 years and have been dragged through a bush backwards then I would rather be boring and ordinary. Thirdly, does the girl not own a pair of shoes?! I mean what the ****** statement is she trying to make by coming out barefoot every week? Beyond me! And of course, last but not least I am going to make it my mission to travel down to London and cut off her ****ing left hand if she does not stop touching her face with it. Yes, you have a hand, yes you have a face but you don't need to caress it every week."

LMAO

:laugh3::laugh3:

[Billy]

Diana put on a show in Call Me, and she proved you dont need to dance to do that. Ruth hasn't danced, has she, and I dont see the point in dancing when it isn't your strength? She is doing fine as it is.

[Billy]

Funny how it's the oldies that are agreeingwith the stylee 8-)

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Billy21
Funny how it's the oldies that are agreeingwith the stylee 8-) Whats that got to do with anything?

[gavinh2008]

Dancing on the spot, which is what Alex did in Candyman, is having a hand routine and only using the hands and body to make "dancing on the spot" and Alex did a lot with her hands in Candyman so really she did dance in Candyman, just on the spot

[pinkmichk]

Originally posted by Billy21
Funny how it's the oldies that are agreeingwith the stylee 8-)


wth:rolleyes:

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21
Diana put on a show in Call Me, and she proved you dont need to dance to do that. Ruth hasn't danced, has she, and I dont see the point in dancing when it isn't your strength? She is doing fine as it is.

During Call Me she just sat there and moved her legs a bit. Ruth hasn't danced, but shes moved around the stage a lot.

[XxShortyxX]

Diana has moved aroubnd the stage before as well, also Call Me she has stakes on, she could hardly start spinning around and dance.

[Tom4784]

Oh I see this show's turned into Strictly X Factor while we wasn't looking... So much for it being a singing contest.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Dezzy
Oh I see this show's turned into Strictly X Factor while we wasn't looking... So much for it being a singing contest. It hasnt been a singing contest for a few years now. The mentors seem to put on a show inorder to hide the weaknesses of the acts.

[XxShortyxX]

Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:

I agree, I don't care if Diana dances or not! dancing doesn't sell records.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:
dancing doesn't sell records. And neither will she.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:
dancing doesn't sell records. And neither will she.


You don't know that, she has a massive fanbase that would buy her Albums!

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:
dancing doesn't sell records. And neither will she.


You don't know that, she has a massive fanbase that would buy her Albums! But when each song sounds the same coupled with her shaky vocals I dont think too many people will buy another album of hers. She'll probably become a bit of a novelty act.

[Tom4784]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:
dancing doesn't sell records. And neither will she.

I beg to differ, Songstresses are very popular now in the music industry I can see her doing very well especially if she sticks to the same style of her auditions.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Dezzy
Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:
dancing doesn't sell records. And neither will she.

I beg to differ, Songstresses are very popular now in the music industry I can see her doing very well especially if she sticks to the same style of her auditions. LMAO:laugh:

She aint no songstress. Songtresses are singers like Anoita Baker and Eva Cassidy. She aint one of those.

[XxShortyxX]

Again you don't know that, they will work on her Album (if she wins or not) and if Gary does sign her up she should do fine, he knows his stuff.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Again you don't know that, they will work on her Album (if she wins or not) and if Gary does sign her up she should do fine, he knows his stuff. Dont know what?

I know she aint no Anita Baker or Eva Cassidy.

[XxShortyxX]

Of course she isn't, she doesn't want to be, she is Diana.

Everytime I go down town people are listeing to her songs on their MP3 Players. I think she will sell records.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Everytime I go down town people are listeing to her songs on their MP3 Players. I think she will sell records. Do you try on their headphones in order to check?

[pinkmichk]

Originally posted by Dezzy
Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:
dancing doesn't sell records. And neither will she.

I beg to differ, Songstresses are very popular now in the music industry I can see her doing very well especially if she sticks to the same style of her auditions.

but she has gone miles away from how she was in auditions there wasnt no yodelling or jazz hands then

[XxShortyxX]

Nope I can hear them, I also her people talking about her.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Nope I can hear them, I also her people talking about her.

What, all talking about how if she wins it will show what a Fix-Factor the show has become and how little it has to do with talent?

She is fast becoming the John Sergeant of the X-Factor.

[XxShortyxX]

Nope, that they want her to win and really like her.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Nope I can hear them, I also her people talking about her.

What, all talking about how if she wins it will show what a Fix-Factor the show has become and how little it has to do with talent?

She is fast becoming the John Sergeant of the X-Factor.

no that was Daniel

[xERFx]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Nope I can hear them, I also her people talking about her.

What, all talking about how if she wins it will show what a Fix-Factor the show has become and how little it has to do with talent?

She is fast becoming the John Sergeant of the X-Factor.

Fix Factor- you obviously listen to anything in the press about her being favoured and believe it.

and just because you dont like her dosnt mean she dosnt have talent :bored:

[Tom4784]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Nope I can hear them, I also her people talking about her.

What, all talking about how if she wins it will show what a Fix-Factor the show has become and how little it has to do with talent?

She is fast becoming the John Sergeant of the X-Factor.

How is it fixed? Yeah she got the free pass but so would of alexandra IF she had Laryngitis. The winner's song is NOT Hallejualah so how is it fixed? If your going to take newspapers words seriously please read the broadsheets and not the tabloids.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Nope I can hear them, I also her people talking about her.

What, all talking about how if she wins it will show what a Fix-Factor the show has become and how little it has to do with talent?

She is fast becoming the John Sergeant of the X-Factor.

Oh, was John Sergeant topping popularity polls and the bookies fave aswell?

[Billy]

Originally posted by pinkmichk
Originally posted by Dezzy
Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:
dancing doesn't sell records. And neither will she.

I beg to differ, Songstresses are very popular now in the music industry I can see her doing very well especially if she sticks to the same style of her auditions.

but she has gone miles away from how she was in auditions there wasnt no yodelling or jazz hands then

But there was. Sure, she didnt have the squeak in her voice, but if you listen to her bootcamp stuff, you it sounds the same, oh and the hands are still there.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by ERF-Saratowinbb9
and just because you dont like her dosnt mean she dosnt have talent :bored:

Lets look at this talent:

The Negatives:

She can't she hold a pure note.
She is not always she always in tune.
She one dimensional and can only sing in one style.
She has limited career potential because she isn't adaptable.
She is like marmite people either love her or hate her giving her limited market share.
She won't (can't) Dance.
She waves her left hand in front of her face annoyingly.
She doesn't own a pair of shoes she not ashamed of that she could use on the stage.
She is too young to have experienced life and write meaningful music at the moment.

The Positives:

She is liked by the judges who big her up.
She looks cute, cuddly and innocent with her big eyes.
She sounds different from any thing else on the X-Factor this year.
She has fans that will vote for even when she is rubbish and the worse act of the night.

[Billy]

Lmao Red tbf it's kinda hard to take you seriously after last year and the whole "rhydian shouldnt be there" argument.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Billy21
Lmao Red tbf it's kinda hard to take you seriously after last year and the whole "rhydian shouldnt be there" argument.

Well he didn't win in the end :wink:

So who knows I just might be right again. There are similarities between the two of them in terms of them being one dimensional and only being able to sing in one style.

But there is one big difference Rhydian could sing a pure note!

I wish him luck. now he is doing Opera I'm happy. He is good at that. He just wasn't the X-Factor material.

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21
Originally posted by pinkmichk
Originally posted by Dezzy
Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Lmao Dezzy :laugh3:
dancing doesn't sell records. And neither will she.

I beg to differ, Songstresses are very popular now in the music industry I can see her doing very well especially if she sticks to the same style of her auditions.

but she has gone miles away from how she was in auditions there wasnt no yodelling or jazz hands then

But there was. Sure, she didnt have the squeak in her voice, but if you listen to her bootcamp stuff, you it sounds the same, oh and the hands are still there.

Diana doesn't top every poll on the internet

her style is completely different now to what it was. i liked her in the auditions but i can't stand her now because shes become a parody of herself

[XxShortyxX]

How the fudge do know she can't dance? and so what if she can't, does Leona dance, no, does Duffy does, no!.

And why is it some people on here can't understand that her fans luv her and vote for her, just because you dislikers say she is the worse act and rubbish on the night doesn't make it true, it's called your opinon! IMO Yellow was her only poor performances, I luv Diana I want her to win I will be voting for her end of!

[Kornetto]

Be quite interesting seeing that girl dance ;)

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
And why is it some people on here can't understand that her fans luv her and vote for her, just because you dislikers say she is the worse act and rubbish on the night doesn't make it true, it's called your opinon! IMO Yellow was her only poor performances, I luv Diana I want her to win I will be voting for her end of!

And there lies the problem with the X-Factor, it's not a talent show but a popularity contest.

It doesn't matter how bad you are on a particular show, your fans will always vote for you.

It's the "John Sergeant virus" and it will infect everything and kill off the format.

[XxShortyxX]

IMO, She had ONE bad performances, just because you think she has had more doesn't mean we all have to agree with you, X Factor stop being about talent years ago, I don't knwo why some people keep saying that, it's boring now. Diana has been my fav from day same as Alex, I am voting for them, and them only I don't like JLS, Eoghan or Ruth, so therefore I will not vote for them, why is that so hard to understand for some people. Why do all us Diana fans have to agree with all you Diana dislikers, we get it, you don't like her! doesn't mean we have to as well.

[ParentalAdvisory]

One of the big problems with the "popularity" aspect of it is the fickle nature of the viewers. While they'll happily vote each week for a certain contestant, they won't actually follow that up once they get signed, effectively making the winner unsuccessful.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by ParentalAdvisory
One of the big problems with the "popularity" aspect of it is the fickle nature of the viewers. While they'll happily vote each week for a certain contestant, they won't actually follow that up once they get signed, effectively making the winner unsuccessful.


So Leona, who I wanted to win, am a fan of is unsuccessful is she?

[Billy]

Umm, Diana CAN dance, considering she is a trained ballet and tap dancer, but whatever, don't let good old fashioned facts get in the way of hate.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
So Leona, who I wanted to win, am a fan of is unsuccessful is she?

She could be more successful people didn't download her stuff, but that aside, she was consistent week in and week out.

[XxShortyxX]

The girl couldn't be more successful if she tried, she has has had more success then any other X Factor winner/constentant.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
So Leona, who I wanted to win, am a fan of is unsuccessful is she?

She could be more successful people didn't download her stuff, but that aside, she was consistent week in and week out.

Someone didn't listen to her first 2 performances then.

We are never going to agree if Diana is good or not, because some people like the quirks of her voice, others don't.

[ParentalAdvisory]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Originally posted by ParentalAdvisory
One of the big problems with the "popularity" aspect of it is the fickle nature of the viewers. While they'll happily vote each week for a certain contestant, they won't actually follow that up once they get signed, effectively making the winner unsuccessful.


So Leona, who I wanted to win, am a fan of is unsuccessful is she?

Leona was the exception to the rule. Have any of the other winners of these type of shows been as successful? Leona is the only one.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Billy21
Someone didn't listen to her first 2 performances then.

We are never going to agree if Diana is good or not, because some people like the quirks of her voice, others don't.

There were okay for the start of the show, Leona lacked confidence, still does sometimes you see it interviews, but her voice was as good. And nearly anyone is bound to improve as the show goes on, just from the voice coaching alone.

Back to Diana, at the start of the show I really liked her, it was like a breath of fresh air had been injected into the X-Factor, but as the show went on I have grown tired of her squeaky voice and her stupid left hand. The air freshness has turned in the smell of the swear, it's unpleasant and leaves a nasty taste in the mouth.

[Z]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Originally posted by Billy21
Someone didn't listen to her first 2 performances then.

We are never going to agree if Diana is good or not, because some people like the quirks of her voice, others don't.

There were okay for the start of the show, Leona lacked confidence, still does sometimes you see it interviews, but her voice was as good. And nearly anyone is bound to improve as the show goes on, just from the voice coaching alone.

Back to Diana, at the start of the show I really liked her, it was like a breath of fresh air had been injected into the X-Factor, but as the show went on I have grown tired of her squeaky voice and her stupid left hand. The air freshness has turned in the smell of the swear, it's unpleasant and leaves a nasty taste in the mouth.

Leona got better in time (what a pun) meanwhile Diana started off strongly but has gotten progressively worse. Yellow was the low point, Patience was a slight improvement but she was back to full health (miraculous recovery from laryngitis...) so there is absolutely no excuse to be singing that poorly so late in the competition.

[30stone]

Originally posted by ParentalAdvisory
Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Originally posted by ParentalAdvisory
One of the big problems with the "popularity" aspect of it is the fickle nature of the viewers. While they'll happily vote each week for a certain contestant, they won't actually follow that up once they get signed, effectively making the winner unsuccessful.


So Leona, who I wanted to win, am a fan of is unsuccessful is she?

Leona was the exception to the rule. Have any of the other winners of these type of shows been as successful? Leona is the only one.

will young has done pretty well..