Ruthie HAS to go!

[Adamw92]

Do you think Ruthie is a good judge?

I used to think so until last night where she really annoyed me, she was being pathetic with the scores, giving Jessica a 3.5 and Zoe 4.0 when she was clearly better than Zoe, then she critised nicky for giving coleen 4.5 but he liked her performance even tho she wasnt the steadiest then Zoe nearly falls and ruthie gives her a 4.0 and says it doesnt matter because she liked the performance

I can't stand her anymore, she needs to go!

[beanny]

Completly agree. She was so pathetic last night. Bye Ruthie :xyxwave:

[Spike]

I like her, definatly one of the better judges.
She has an opinion and she isn't frightened to say it even if its completly different to the other judges.

[Tom4784]

I think she should stay, she's a harsh judge like Jason and it helps balance things out I think.

[SammyAyee]

She's okay sometimes but last night. What was she on :conf2:.

[Brad*]

I have said this since she arrived! She cannot comment on anything even slightly techncical and always goes on about the 'performance'. People are talking about her insulting Nicky's marking last night and I thought it was pathetic too. She shouldn't compare her scores to the other judges or compare one contestant with another. I hope this is her last series because I can't stand her!

[Tom]

I don't mind her but she always copies Jason's scores and she isn't consistent with her marking at all. Shes lost the plot a bit. Bring back the one who couldn't speak English :tongue:

If they wanted a West End person to judge the performance then they should have got Bonnie Langford- she was in series 1 so would be able to tell us everything Ruthie does and more!

[GiRTh]

She was out of order last night but I think Nicky didnt handle the situation too well either. If she had some issue with the way Nicky marks then it should have been dealt with off camera. She an inconsistent judge as some posters have pointed out and she does not have the technical background to give constructive crtiticism on the quality of the skating.

Theres a similar discusion to this on DS and many people think she's should go too.

[Annie]

It should be Jason that goes! I hate him!

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Annie
It should be Jason that goes! I hate him! Me too. The man is just rude. He rarely says anything constructive.

[Annie]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Originally posted by Annie
It should be Jason that goes! I hate him! Me too. The man is just rude. He rarely says anything constructive.

OMG! I know like the first week with the boys and Philip was talking to the camera after the break and he was just huffing and puffing and making faces! That is just completely rude and unprofessional! I was like whoo when Philip slapped him across the head!

[amby]

She was terrible tonight again!!!

[Princess]

She has to go! She is as bad as Jason but never gets any stick for it.