The Top 10 Greatest Bands of All Time According to TiBB [[The Results]]

[MrGaryy]

This was originally done in 2007 (http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/forum/viewthread.php?tid=56494), so I thought I would resurrect it, two years later for a laugh.

though my version will be a whole lot sexier, obv.

basically, you vote for your favourite all time bands like this:

1. - 10pts
2. - 8pts
3. - 4pts
4. - 2pts
5. - 1pts

then after the votes have been counted, I'll announce the winners. have fun, voting closes in 3 days time!:dance2:

[Shaun]

oof. just bands?

1. The Beatles
2. The Killers
3. The Cure
4. Placebo
5. Oasis

EDITED.twice.
want to include Queen, Scissor Sisters, Doves, Marilyn Manson, The Prodigy, Green Day, Rolling Stones, Pet Shop Boys and Radiohead badly too.

[MrGaryy]

yes just bands. maybe duos.

[xDramatick]

1. Green Day.
2. Evanescence.
3. Porcelain And The Tramps.
4. Muse.
5. Radiohead.

Special mentions to Radiohead, Jack Off Jill, Scarling, MGMT, Daughtry, Placebo, HIM, Arctic Monkeys, Snow Patrol and The Birthday Massacre<3

edited twice already lol :\

[Stu]

Hopeless, but...

1. Depeche Mode
2. Pink Floyd
3. HIM
4. The Wonderstuff
5. Black Sabbath

Honorable mentions : Cypress Hill, CKY, Turbonegro, The Prodigy, Tupac Shakur, Bob Marley, Tool.

[Gemmer-x]

1. Oasis
2. Queen
3. Coldplay
4. Beatles
5. Spice Girls :hugesmile:

[LemonJam]

1. Smashing Pumpkins
2. Avenged Sevenfold
3. Paramore
4. The Cure
5. Fightstar

That was hard. =\ Doubt many of them would get any more votes but oh well LOL

Special mentions to New Found Glory, Zebrahead and 36 Crazyfists.

[Captain.Remy]

1. - Daft Punk.
2. - Justice.
3. - Coldplay.
4. - Basement Jaxx.
5. - Depeche Mode.

[Noel]

1. Aqua
2. B*witched
3. Sister Sledge
4. Disney All Stars
5. Bananarama

[Stu]

Originally posted by Bradley!
1. Aqua
2. B*witched
3. Sister Sledge
4. Disney All Stars
5. Bananarama
.................................................. .:joker:

[MrGaryy]

mine are:

1.No Doubt
2.Oasis
3.Girls Aloud
4.Yeah Yeah Yeahs
5.Paramore

ugh, how utterly mainstream of me.

special mentions to Take That, Danity Kane, Basement Jaxx and Yeah Yeah Yeahs.

[Noel]

Originally posted by Stu
Originally posted by Bradley!
1. Aqua
2. B*witched
3. Sister Sledge
4. Disney All Stars
5. Bananarama
.................................................. .:joker:
WUT?
They've all had top 10 hits and are very popular amongst children and adults alike.

[Stu]

Originally posted by Bradley!
Originally posted by Stu
Originally posted by Bradley!
1. Aqua
2. B*witched
3. Sister Sledge
4. Disney All Stars
5. Bananarama
.................................................. .:joker:
WUT?
They've all had top 10 hits and are very popular amongst children and adults alike.
So? What has popularity got to do with worksmanship and quality of music? To be honest, the reason I made that post was because I thought you were joking.

Oh dear lord.

[Noel]

Originally posted by Stu
Originally posted by Bradley!
Originally posted by Stu
Originally posted by Bradley!
1. Aqua
2. B*witched
3. Sister Sledge
4. Disney All Stars
5. Bananarama
.................................................. .:joker:
WUT?
They've all had top 10 hits and are very popular amongst children and adults alike.
So? What has popularity got to do with worksmanship and quality of music? To be honest, the reason I made that post was because I thought you were joking.

Oh dear lord.

Stu, I was.
Oh dear lord.

[MrGaryy]

Stu, I have a feeling you were right the first time. :thumbs:

[Harry!]

1. Spice Girls
2. Dead or Alive
3. Girls Aloud
4. Aqua
5. McFly

[Stu]

Originally posted by Bradley!
Stu, I was.
Oh dear lord.
Thank god. I always had faith in you. But still, you have to be sure . . .

*Edit* Mind you someone actualy did mention Aqau 4 realz, so you can tell why I am skeptical :joker:.

[xDramatick]

I keep editing mine.
I really wanna put Jack Off Jill ++ Queen in thurr =[

[Noel]

Originally posted by Stu
Originally posted by Bradley!
Stu, I was.
Oh dear lord.
Thank god. I always had faith in you. But still, you have to be sure . . .

*Edit* Mind you someone actualy did mention Aqau 4 realz, so you can tell why I am skeptical :joker:.

LMAO.
Well I like Aqua, but they're obv not the best :L
At least I know I'll always have you, Stu, to defend the beauty of real music :)

[Stu]

Originally posted by Bradley!
Originally posted by Stu
Originally posted by Bradley!
Stu, I was.
Oh dear lord.
Thank god. I always had faith in you. But still, you have to be sure . . .

*Edit* Mind you someone actualy did mention Aqau 4 realz, so you can tell why I am skeptical :joker:.

LMAO.
Well I like Aqua, but they're obv not the best :L
At least I know I'll always have you, Stu, to defend the beauty of real music :)
And likewise, I know I will always have you to defend the beauty of practical jokes at the expense of Aqua :thumbs2:.

[MrGaryy]

Bradley do you want me to count those votes or do you want to edit your votes?
LOL

[Rob]

mine are

Chase and Status
Black Eyed Peas
Frankie goes to hollywood
Guns and Roses
Basement Jaxx

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Rob
mine are

Chase and Status
Black Eyed Peas
Frankie goes to hollywood
Guns and Roses
Basement Jaxx

in that order?

[Noel]

Originally posted by MrGaryy
Bradley do you want me to count those votes or do you want to edit your votes?
LOL

LOL. Hmmm..take them. What harm can they do? We'd have to be in a different universe for anyone else to vote for those 5. :)

And thanks Stu; any time! :D

[KKBL]

Whats the definition of a "band"?Do they have to play their own instruments etc.?

[Princess]

Right

1.Take That
2.Snow Patrol
3.Spice Girls
4.Keane
5.Coldplay

Special mentions to OneRepublic, Swicthfoot,The Killers,Backstreet Boys,Maroon 5,The Beatles,Athlete and Queen
edit:Argh forgot Bon Jovi!
edit2:I forgot Sugababes and GA,and I listen to them loads!
edit3:I also forgot Stereophonics.Prob loads of others too,gonna stop editing.
Argh hard!

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by KKBL
Whats the definition of a "band"?Do they have to play their own instruments etc.?

no just any group. E.G Pussycat Dolls would be excepted.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Bradley!
Originally posted by MrGaryy
Bradley do you want me to count those votes or do you want to edit your votes?
LOL

LOL. Hmmm..take them. What harm can they do? We'd have to be in a different universe for anyone else to vote for those 5. :)

And thanks Stu; any time! :D

you'll ****ing change them or else.

[Twilight]

1. Jonas Brothers
2. Forever The Sickest Kids
3. the veronicas
4. Girls Aloud
5. Take That

BTW I am ready to die because of who i put:whistle:

[Novo]

1. Bone thugs and harmony
2. Genesis
3. Outlawz
4. Switchfoot
5. The Ataris

[andyman]

1. Incognito
2. NWA
3. Rage Against The Machine
4. Men Without Hats
5. Guns N' Roses

[Stu]

Originally posted by MrGaryy
Originally posted by KKBL
Whats the definition of a "band"?Do they have to play their own instruments etc.?

no just any group. E.G Pussycat Dolls would be excepted.
What about a single DJ/Producer/Rapper?

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Twilight
1. Jonas Brothers
2. Forever The Sickest Kids
3. the veronicas
4. Girls Aloud
5. Take That

BTW I am ready to die because of who i put:whistle:

FTSK/TV/GA/TT <3

[Noel]

Originally posted by Shaun
Originally posted by Bradley!
Originally posted by MrGaryy
Bradley do you want me to count those votes or do you want to edit your votes?
LOL

LOL. Hmmm..take them. What harm can they do? We'd have to be in a different universe for anyone else to vote for those 5. :)

And thanks Stu; any time! :D

you'll ****ing change them or else.

****, you MSN Plus sounds *****.

[M X]

1. Queen
2. The Beatles
3. Spice Girls (:blush:)
4. Fangs
5. Jack Off Jill

probably edit it lol.

Note 2 the V's aswell. &Paramore.

[lily.]

1. Green Day
2. R.E.M.
3. Metallica
4. Guns N Roses
5. Queen

[Ross]

1. Sugababes / 10 points
2. Pussycat Dolls / 8 points
3. Manic Street Preachers / 5 points
4. Queen / 3 points
5. Spice Girls / 1 point

[Lewis.]

1. The Saturdays
2. Girls Aloud
3. Take That
4. The Pussycat Dolls
5. Mcfly



How Modern :/




:love:

[Stu]

Rage Against The Machine, Jack Off Jill, Metallica and the Manics, respect. I got a good laugh off The Saturdays being the best band of all time too, so this is a neat little comedy thread.

[lily.]

My list was respectable.. ;)

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Stu
Rage Against The Machine, Jack Off Jill, Metallica and the Manics, respect. I got a good laugh off The Saturdays being the best band of all time too, so this is a neat little comedy thread.

people are allowed to have a favourite artist. i'm personally not going to write down some 1970's rockband just to make my list seem respectable or valid.

if you don't like who people list then that's your problem. you can't tell people which artists they should like. music snobs are the worst things about lists like these.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Stu
Originally posted by MrGaryy
Originally posted by KKBL
Whats the definition of a "band"?Do they have to play their own instruments etc.?

no just any group. E.G Pussycat Dolls would be excepted.
What about a single DJ/Producer/Rapper?

obviously not.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Stu
Rage Against The Machine, Jack Off Jill, Metallica and the Manics, respect. I got a good laugh off The Saturdays being the best band of all time too, so this is a neat little comedy thread.

some one has a bad case of music snobbery.

[Stu]

Originally posted by MarkWaldorf
Originally posted by Stu
Rage Against The Machine, Jack Off Jill, Metallica and the Manics, respect. I got a good laugh off The Saturdays being the best band of all time too, so this is a neat little comedy thread.

people are allowed to have a favourite artist. i'm personally not going to write down some 1970's rockband just to make my list seem respectable or valid.

if you don't like who people list then that's your problem. you can't tell people which artists they should like. music snobs are the worst things about lists like these.
Your right. It is my problem. I am not offended, just voicing my lolability about the subject. So what point are you trying to make exactly? I think finding The Saturdays, a fairly new pop act, to be the best band ever is a bit of a stretch. I love classic rock, of which I named a mere two bands. One being metal the other being prog. rock. I hardly put them down just to make a more valid list. Besides that, I listen to electronic more than I do rock. But I cant put down many DJ's or solo electronic producers thanks to the nature of this thread.

If finding that the Saturdays are the greatest band ever is hillarious, and if that makes you a music snob, then I would wager that the majority of the population are music snobs. Which, because we are talking about a majority, instantly nullifies the 'snob' aspect.

I love people like you, who think I am somehow trying to deny someone from liking an artist just because I think their choice is hillarious. Shoot me dead.

[GhettoSuperstar]

01. Girls Aloud
02. Jonas Brothers
03. Good Charlotte
04. The Pigeon Detectives
05. The Cribs

[Annie]

1. Take That
2. Girls Aloud
3. The Saturdays
4. The White Stripes
5. 5ive

[Iceman]

1. System Of A Down
2. Nirvana
3. Rage Against The Machine
4. Oasis
5. Arctic Monkeys

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Stu
Rage Against The Machine, Jack Off Jill, Metallica and the Manics, respect. I got a good laugh off The Saturdays being the best band of all time too, so this is a neat little comedy thread.

Another JOJ fan? :O

[Stu]

Originally posted by Satisfaction
Originally posted by Stu
Rage Against The Machine, Jack Off Jill, Metallica and the Manics, respect. I got a good laugh off The Saturdays being the best band of all time too, so this is a neat little comedy thread.

Another JOJ fan? :O
:lovedup:

Aye, heard of them through Scott Putesky, who co-founded and played guitar for Marilyn Manson on Portrait Of An American Family until he left through the Marilyn Manson revolving door of guitarists. Their awesome lol.

I keep forgetting bands. Cant believe I did not mention Tool & Bob Marley.

[Shaun]

:love: music snobs.

The Saturdays as no#1 is, I'm sorry, ridiculous. I don't care how many differently coloured tights they own.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Shaun
:love: music snobs.

The Saturdays as no#1 is, I'm sorry, ridiculous. I don't care how many differently coloured tights they own.

LOL.
just so it's clear I obviously see the ridiculousness of the sats being number one, I was more referring to a lot of your posts in general.

[Princess]

I argee with the whole The Sats being number 1 thing,but if they're your fav band you can't exactly choose anyone else can you?

[Stu]

Originally posted by Shaun
:love: music snobs.

The Saturdays as no#1 is, I'm sorry, ridiculous. I don't care how many differently coloured tights they own.
http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y237/kingofthering/05.jpg

[Tom4784]

1. - Muse
2. - Yeah Yeah Yeahs
3. - Placebo
4. - Arctic Monkeys
5. - Kings of Leon

[Twilight]

Originally posted by Satisfaction
Originally posted by Twilight
1. Jonas Brothers
2. Forever The Sickest Kids
3. the veronicas
4. Girls Aloud
5. Take That

BTW I am ready to die because of who i put:whistle:

FTSK/TV/GA/TT <3 :lovedup:

[andyman]

All the following need top points..

Incognito. (Jazz funk/acid jazz)
Guns N' Roses.
Rage Against the Machine.
The Stone Roses.
Happy Mondays.
NWA.
James Brown.
808 State.
The Prodigy.
Eric B. & Rakim.
Cypress Hill.
Inner City.
Kiss.
Soul 2 Soul.
SWV.
Men Without Hats.
Mobb Deep.
Foreigner.
Queen...
Pet Shot Boys.
UB40.
Nirvana

....

[MrGaryy]

bump, more votes please.

[MarkWaldorf]

1. Girls Aloud
2. Paramore
3. Shiny Toy Guns
4. The Pussycat Dolls
5. The Saturdays

I don't listen to many bands, which is why I've named them^

[Shaun]

Mark. ****.

[ange7]

Originally posted by andyman
All the following need top points..

Incognito. (Jazz funk/acid jazz)
Guns N' Roses.
Rage Against the Machine.
The Stone Roses.
Happy Mondays.
NWA.
James Brown.
808 State.
The Prodigy.
Eric B. & Rakim.
Cypress Hill.
Inner City.
Kiss.
Soul 2 Soul.
SWV.
Men Without Hats.
Mobb Deep.
Foreigner.
Queen...
Pet Shot Boys.
UB40.
Nirvana

....
oooo...points for 808 State and Eric B&Rakim,
points deducted for Men without Hats lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lj-x9ygQEGA&feature=player_embedded

[Damaris]

1.Blondie
2.The Strokes
3.The Stone RosesThe
4.Yeah Yeah Yeahs
5.Blur

Shout out to CSS,Dapeche Mode,Rage Against the machine and Slipknot

[MrGaryy]

I'm going to close the voting tonight, so get your votes in guys!

[Jerusilam]

1- Rod Stewart and The Small Faces
2- The Beatles
3- U2
4- Oasis
5- D12

[Tom4784]

Originally posted by ange7
Originally posted by andyman
All the following need top points..

Incognito. (Jazz funk/acid jazz)
Guns N' Roses.
Rage Against the Machine.
The Stone Roses.
Happy Mondays.
NWA.
James Brown.
808 State.
The Prodigy.
Eric B. & Rakim.
Cypress Hill.
Inner City.
Kiss.
Soul 2 Soul.
SWV.
Men Without Hats.
Mobb Deep.
Foreigner.
Queen...
Pet Shot Boys.
UB40.
Nirvana

....
oooo...points for 808 State and Eric B&Rakim,
points deducted for Men without Hats lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lj-x9ygQEGA&feature=player_embedded

That Video is HILARIOUS!!!! I'm so linking it on Facebook. :laugh:

Mullet with Headlights!

[andyman]

Originally posted by ange7
Originally posted by andyman
All the following need top points..

Incognito. (Jazz funk/acid jazz)
Guns N' Roses.
Rage Against the Machine.
The Stone Roses.
Happy Mondays.
NWA.
James Brown.
808 State.
The Prodigy.
Eric B. & Rakim.
Cypress Hill.
Inner City.
Kiss.
Soul 2 Soul.
SWV.
Men Without Hats.
Mobb Deep.
Foreigner.
Queen...
Pet Shot Boys.
UB40.
Nirvana

....
oooo...points for 808 State and Eric B&Rakim,
points deducted for Men without Hats lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lj-x9ygQEGA&feature=player_embedded ^Pukka tune
:tongue:


Nothing wrong with Men without Hats, pure 80s magic!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xfhpp-4I60E

[Shaun]

I so posted that literal Bonnie Tyler video first. Just a few days ago in fact. :bored:

[KKBL]

1.Linkin Park
2.Coldplay
3.The Killers
4.U2
5.Girls Aloud

Obviously this is based on the music they've released and not talent.

[Jen]

1. The Killers
2. Dire Straites
3. The Kinks
4. Nirvana
5. Pulp


Special mention to: Blur, The Beatles, U2, Metallica, Guns and Roses, Snow Patrol and Poison.

[Emilee]

1. Girls Aloud
2. Spice Girls
3. Take That
4. The Beetles
5. The Saturdays

[Tom]

It depends what your concept of a band is, and for me a "band" isn't a manufactured bunch of girls "singing" along to a song which would sound exactly the same as the same amount of other girls singing it, whilst every single one is replaceable. Girls Aloud, OK I can see that one at a push because they've been around for what feels like ever but The Saturdays?! That to me is a pop group, not a band. For me a band is a group who write their own material and play their own instruments etc. And I'm as far from a music snob as you can get. So:

1- Oasis
2- Queen
3- The Beatles
4- The Killers
5- Kings of Leon

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Tom
It depends what your concept of a band is, and for me a "band" isn't a manufactured bunch of girls "singing" along to a song which would sound exactly the same as the same amount of other girls singing it, whilst every single one is replaceable. Girls Aloud, OK I can see that one at a push because they've been around for what feels like ever but The Saturdays?! That to me is a pop group, not a band. For me a band is a group who write their own material and play their own instruments etc. And I'm as far from a music snob as you can get. So:

1- Oasis
2- Queen
3- The Beatles
4- The Killers
5- Kings of Leon

That's how I interpret band from pop group or vocal group too :tongue:

[Siouxsie]

in no paticular order
T, rex
deep purple
def leppard
pink floyd
take that westlife and many many more

[Nicky.]

Aww! I missed this!
I will vote anyway! - incase you want to count them!

1. McFly
2. Take That
3. The Beatles
4. Busted
5. The Saturdays

Xx

[ange7]

Originally posted by andyman
Originally posted by ange7
Originally posted by andyman
All the following need top points..

Incognito. (Jazz funk/acid jazz)
Guns N' Roses.
Rage Against the Machine.
The Stone Roses.
Happy Mondays.
NWA.
James Brown.
808 State.
The Prodigy.
Eric B. & Rakim.
Cypress Hill.
Inner City.
Kiss.
Soul 2 Soul.
SWV.
Men Without Hats.
Mobb Deep.
Foreigner.
Queen...
Pet Shot Boys.
UB40.
Nirvana

....
oooo...points for 808 State and Eric B&Rakim,
points deducted for Men without Hats lol

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lj-x9ygQEGA&feature=player_embedded ^Pukka tune
:tongue:


Nothing wrong with Men without Hats, pure 80s magic!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xfhpp-4I60E
What evil oppressor is stopping him from dancing anyway? Any revolutions with their foundations in dance WILL FAIL!!. Kilts or no kilts!

[Damaris]

OMGZ **** SAKE I FORGOT THE CURE!!!!!!!

[MrGaryy]

counting the votes now.

[Princess]

Hope TT do well! They seemed to get a good few votes.

[Tom4784]

Muse should win just because they are god. They won't though. Damn Saturdays.

[Shaun]

Saturdays win and I'm calling everyone ***** for the next 24hrs.

[MrGaryy]

THE RESULTS:

01|Girls Aloud [57pts]
02|The Beatles [38pts]
03|Take That [37pts]
04|Oasis [33pts]
05|Queen [29pts]
06|Spice Girls [28pts]
07|The Killers [22pts]
08|Green Day [20pts]
09|Jonas Brothers [18pts]
10|Coldplay [17pts]

Notable mentions to; The Saturdays [16pts], Paramore [13pts] and the Pussycat Dolls [12pts].

thanks to everyone who voted. :angel:
exohexoh.

[Shaun]

pmsl @ GA and the Jonas Brothers.

oh lordy.

Happy with the others though.

[Princess]

Girls Aloud won,wow! Guess Doug will be estactic!

Very pleased my boys are 3rd!!!!

[Tom4784]

Originally posted by MrGaryy
THE RESULTS:

01|Girls Aloud [57pts]
02|The Beatles [38pts]
03|Take That [37pts]
04|Oasis [33pts]
05|Queen [29pts]
06|Spice Girls [28pts]
07|The Killers [22pts]
08|Green Day [20pts]
09|Jonas Brothers [18pts]
10|Coldplay [17pts]

Notable mentions to; The Saturdays [16pts], Paramore [13pts] and the Pussycat Dolls [12pts].

thanks to everyone who voted. :angel:
exohexoh.

Compared to the sh*tfest i was expecting it ain't a bad list!

['Conor]

are you serious !!!!!!!!!! GA r **** !!!

[MrGaryy]

forgot to bump this.

[Ross]

GA, ew

[Jen]

GA.
****.

[Harry!]

Jonas Brothers are you kidding me!!!!

[Shaun]

It's not often I'll say this to you Harry but IFKR!

[M X]

Girls Aloud? You have seriously got to be joking me.. :shocked:

[Tom]

Girls Aloud ARE NOT a band ... they're a manufactured pop group

I do like them though but they shouldn't have even made it into that chart :blush2::blush2::blush2:

[Lewis.]

Girls aloud

:love:

Guess it's just me


:hugesmile:

[Harry!]

Originally posted by Shaun
It's not often I'll say this to you Harry but IFKR!

What is IFKR?

[Twilight]

Girls Aloud
:love:
Jonas Brothers
:love:
Take That
:love:
Green Day
:love:

[Twilight]

Originally posted by Harry.
Originally posted by Shaun
It's not often I'll say this to you Harry but IFKR!

What is IFKR? I ****ing know right

[GhettoSuperstar]

Originally posted by Princess
Girls Aloud won,wow! Guess Doug will be estactic!

Very pleased my boys are 3rd!!!!

:bigsmile:

My girls always win. That's because they are the best. So they won, uh huh.

[GhettoSuperstar]

Originally posted by Jen
GA.
****.

No.

[Harry!]

Originally posted by Twilight
Originally posted by Harry.
Originally posted by Shaun
It's not often I'll say this to you Harry but IFKR!

What is IFKR? I ****ing know right

Thanks for clering that up!

[Damaris]

Sketty Sketty list.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by GhettoSuperstar
Originally posted by Princess
Girls Aloud won,wow! Guess Doug will be estactic!

Very pleased my boys are 3rd!!!!

:bigsmile:

My girls always win. That's because they are the best. So they won, uh huh.

They're lush, but really, no.

Not in the slightest. There is no limit to how very very endlessly WRONG that is.

[Jen]

Originally posted by GhettoSuperstar
Originally posted by Jen
GA.
****.

No.

I love you though... :P