Did Freddie do anything wrong in the opera task?

[bluebelle21]

The way Karly and Rodrigo were looking at him made out that Freddie had done something wrong because he started singing at the same time as Rodrigo? But what Freddie was singing was in time with the music so surely he was right.

I'm confused???

[CarlyBunny]

I know I was confused too. He just started singing over them? But then he said to Rodders and Karly that they had been singing too slow.

[KillER]

wasnt big bro meant to have played the music wrong? it was different to what theyd been listening to or something... what freddo sang was in time with the music too.

[CarlyBunny]

Originally posted by KillER
wasnt big bro meant to have played the music wrong? it was different to what theyd been listening to or something... what freddo sang was in time with the music too.

Yeah they said that too! That it had been different. I don't know why Freddie sang over Rodders though, I thought that the best thing would have been just to sing how it had been taught and ignore the music. That's what I would have done...

[NettoSuperstar!]

He was singing in time to the music, Karly must have been out of time and she knew it!

[bluebelle21]

Karly does have a good singing voice, I'll admit though, but she mustve been singing too slow. Because Freddie sang in time with the music. I doubt BB would have given them the wrong music :S

[Appearance_Of_A_Junky]

Originally posted by bluebelle21
Karly does have a good singing voice, I'll admit though, but she mustve been singing too slow. Because Freddie sang in time with the music. I doubt BB would have given them the wrong music :S

which is why they needed to use the mp3 players more to get the timing, just singing/learning the words won't give you a concept of timing

[Gooner_mad]

It was Rodrigo who sang too slow.

[bluebelle21]

Exactly. I couldnt believe how much of a fuss Karly kicked up with her argument with Freddie. All he said was can we just listen for 5 more minutes because we have to give the mp3 players back. Which is a fair point. If anyone else had suggested it she would have agreed. It just shows how the HMs are turning against him and using anything as ammunition just to cause conflict!

[CarlyBunny]

Originally posted by Gooner_mad
It was Rodrigo who sang too slow.

I thought that too, because Karly sounded like she was singing in time.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by CarlyBunny
Originally posted by Gooner_mad
It was Rodrigo who sang too slow.

I thought that too, because Karly sounded like she was singing in time.

She must have been out of time because there wasnt enough time for Rodrigo to sing his bit in the first place and the look on her face showed she knew that

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by bluebelle21
Exactly. I couldnt believe how much of a fuss Karly kicked up with her argument with Freddie. All he said was can we just listen for 5 more minutes because we have to give the mp3 players back. Which is a fair point. If anyone else had suggested it she would have agreed. It just shows how the HMs are turning against him and using anything as ammunition just to cause conflict!

Yeh its silly they'll pick on anything cos its him! Totally playground!

[Tom4784]

Even as a Freddie Fan I did find him quite overbearing and full of himself on this task. I think it was more of his attitude that annoyed them really.

[NettoSuperstar!]

I didnt think he was full of himself or overbearing at all...just a tad ott and flamboyant (not bad things)

[30stone]

Rodrigo or karly come in to late i think.

Freddie was 100% in time.

[bluebelle21]

They were getting annoyed with him even when he was just singing and practising. I couldnt believe it when Karly shouted at him to shut up. He wasn't full of himself or overbearing and he didnt even nominate himself for this task the housemates picked him. I just think he cant do anything right for anyone. Whatever he does will be wrong in their eyes.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by bluebelle21
They were getting annoyed with him even when he was just singing and practising. I couldnt believe it when Karly shouted at him to shut up. He wasn't full of himself or overbearing and he didnt even nominate himself for this task the housemates picked him. I just think he cant do anything right for anyone. Whatever he does will be wrong in their eyes.

Exactly :thumbs: forgot about that poor bloke was just singin ffs

[KillER]

Originally posted by bluebelle21
They were getting annoyed with him even when he was just singing and practising. I couldnt believe it when Karly shouted at him to shut up. He wasn't full of himself or overbearing and he didnt even nominate himself for this task the housemates picked him. I just think he cant do anything right for anyone. Whatever he does will be wrong in their eyes.
trueee. they just seem to enjoy picking on him full stop. then boasting about the argument/disagreement theyve just had with him to eachother of course. poor freddoooo.

[Bombardier]

I can't figure this out. Seems like a stitch-up.

[gemz25]

Please, just him being there is enough to iritate them

[Rozartytype]

I think Freddie spoiled the Three Tenors task on purpose,just to annoy the others.I think he said something earlier along the lines that he was going to pay them back for nominating him again.

[flemin]

We'll never really know but I suspect it was freddie's mistake.

[ILoveFreddie]

You could hear Freddie's singing went with the music. It was "200% not his fault" :thumbs2:

[Lee.]

I think Freddie was the only one who got it right but now, because of Karly, the whole house blames Freddie (as usual)

I didn't mind Karly but I'm rapidly going off her. Her downfall is goiing to be getting involved with team nasty

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by Rozartytype
I think Freddie spoiled the Three Tenors task on purpose,just to annoy the others.I think he said something earlier along the lines that he was going to pay them back for nominating him again.

No he said "haha that will shake things up a bit" after noms and he didnt sabotage the task he practised well and was in time to the music

[Cybele]

I think Carly and Rodrigo were both not singing in time with the music because they learned more with the printed words than with the recording. I'm a dancer and I know when in the music I am supposed to do something regardless of what others are doing. That is exactly what Freddy did. He knew when he was supposed to start singing and he did.

Not that it will matter. Freddie could grow angels wings and cure cancer and someone would still find a reason to complain about him.

[Rozartytype]

Originally posted by NettoSuperstar!
Originally posted by Rozartytype
I think Freddie spoiled the Three Tenors task on purpose,just to annoy the others.I think he said something earlier along the lines that he was going to pay them back for nominating him again.

No he said "haha that will shake things up a bit" after noms and he didnt sabotage the task he practised well and was in time to the music

Considering Freddie was supposed to have trained as a chorister in his younger days,he was pretty poor.And he was deliberatley messing around during their rehearsals.
But I hope Freddie survives on Friday just to annoy the hell out of the others for another week.

[28thapril]

Karly had it in for him at the start telling sophie and noirin in the bedroom she was going to go at him (freddie) if he starts what's her big deal they all know he bursts into song all the time she's a hag

she sang ok but too slow and so was rodrigo but it's obvious she would point the finger at freddie because everyone else does--- little miss perfect---NOT!!:devil:

[cleaner67]

No Freddie done nothing wrong it was BB who mucked up with the music. Karly said they had missed Rodrigos piece of music out so Freddie sang to the piece of music that he was supposed to. When Rodrigo had a go at Freddie saying that he had sang his bit Karly changed her tune and blamed Freddie as well.

[muchadoaboutnothing]

Originally posted by Rozartytype
Originally posted by NettoSuperstar!
Originally posted by Rozartytype
I think Freddie spoiled the Three Tenors task on purpose,just to annoy the others.I think he said something earlier along the lines that he was going to pay them back for nominating him again.

No he said "haha that will shake things up a bit" after noms and he didnt sabotage the task he practised well and was in time to the music

Considering Freddie was supposed to have trained as a chorister in his younger days,he was pretty poor.And he was deliberatley messing around during their rehearsals.
But I hope Freddie survives on Friday just to annoy the hell out of the others for another week.

Don't agree with you at all. Freddie was the only one who took the singing task seriously. Karly wanted to mess it up so that Freddie could be blamed. Freddie wanted Karly and Rod to listen to the MP3 one more time but Karly sulked and went to the other HMs, swearing like a trooper (considering she nominated Marcus because of his swearing - two-faced) and said "what Freddie wants." It was basically because Karly didn't get "what Karly wants" that she blew a fuse and did her best to have others blame Freddie.

[yousoboo!]

Karly is no lady

[Chels]

Originally posted by Rozartytype
Considering Freddie was supposed to have trained as a chorister in his younger days,he was pretty poor.And he was deliberatley messing around during their rehearsals.
But I hope Freddie survives on Friday just to annoy the hell out of the others for another week.

you do realize his voice has broken since then?

[Ketman]

The HMs cannot be blamed for the disaster.

This is the version BB should have played over the sound system, sung here by Pavarotti, Carreras and Domingo:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDtcidMR_6I

That was the one they'd practised for. But the version played over the sound system was this one, sung by Pavarotti alone:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VATmgtmR5o4

In that version what should have been Rodrigo's part has been cut out altogether. The music skips straight to Freddie's solo.

BB is to blame, not the HMs.

[Miss-red]

i thought they played the wrong music lol so did karly at first but when the other hms jumped to blame freddie she jumped on the bandwagon. she had said it wasn't freddies fault but then when freddie himself said it wasn't his fault she said it wouldn't be would it freddie, in a sarcastic way. she's a two faced so and so yes i'm being polite lol

[ILoveFreddie]

Originally posted by cleaner67
No Freddie done nothing wrong it was BB who mucked up with the music. Karly said they had missed Rodrigos piece of music out so Freddie sang to the piece of music that he was supposed to. When Rodrigo had a go at Freddie saying that he had sang his bit Karly changed her tune and blamed Freddie as well.
Exactly. She knew that it wasn't his fault but still had to make that nasty sarcastic comment at the end.


Also I think Freddie sounded lovely singing, except in the long notes he had to hold. I think they were too high for his voice.

[AhmedFan2004]

Originally posted by bluebelle21
The way Karly and Rodrigo were looking at him made out that Freddie had done something wrong because he started singing at the same time as Rodrigo? But what Freddie was singing was in time with the music so surely he was right.

I'm confused???
= Refused to listen to fellow housemates upon multiple kind requests

= Ruined the Italian Opera task by singing out of sync with the music

= Patronised and annoyed fellow housemates endlessly

= Smugly said that he 'Is 200 % sure he has done nothing wrong whatsoever' with a smug grin, again bringing down the moral of the group.

EVEN nice people like Rodrigo hate him.

EVICT Halfwit, save BB10 and that means ... save Sree. We need Sree to keep carrying the show and making it blossom into a top series.

DON'T kill BB10, we need Sree, evict Halfwit. Serious guys. :bored:

[Twilight]

Originally posted by AhmedFan2004
Originally posted by bluebelle21
The way Karly and Rodrigo were looking at him made out that Freddie had done something wrong because he started singing at the same time as Rodrigo? But what Freddie was singing was in time with the music so surely he was right.

I'm confused???
= Refused to listen to fellow housemates upon multiple kind requests

= Ruined the Italian Opera task by singing out of sync with the music

= Patronised and annoyed fellow housemates endlessly

= Smugly said that he 'Is 200 % sure he has done nothing wrong whatsoever' with a smug grin, again bringing down the moral of the group.

EVEN nice people like Rodrigo hate him.

EVICT Halfwit, save BB10 and that means ... save Sree. We need Sree to keep carrying the show and making it blossom into a top series.

DON'T kill BB10, we need Sree, evict Halfwit. Serious guys. :bored: Get over it Sree's a goner

[Stephanie]

i think karly was singing abit too slow, but she was good.
then rodderz mucked it up by singing the wrong part when it was freddies and he was going with the music, but singing badly.
big brother most likely, as said played around with the music to cause more hate.

[supergirthuk]

BB's record skipped. Rodrigo's bit was missing. They will pass this.

[NettoSuperstar!]

Originally posted by AhmedFan2004
Originally posted by bluebelle21
The way Karly and Rodrigo were looking at him made out that Freddie had done something wrong because he started singing at the same time as Rodrigo? But what Freddie was singing was in time with the music so surely he was right.

I'm confused???
= Refused to listen to fellow housemates upon multiple kind requests

= Ruined the Italian Opera task by singing out of sync with the music

= Patronised and annoyed fellow housemates endlessly

= Smugly said that he 'Is 200 % sure he has done nothing wrong whatsoever' with a smug grin, again bringing down the moral of the group.

EVEN nice people like Rodrigo hate him.

EVICT Halfwit, save BB10 and that means ... save Sree. We need Sree to keep carrying the show and making it blossom into a top series.

DON'T kill BB10, we need Sree, evict Halfwit. Serious guys. :bored:

- Wanted to listen to the MP3 player for 5 mins (Ooh how dare he)

- Doesnt do anything patronising unless thick idiots arent listening to him...the HMs annoyance is to do with scapegoating and projecting their own anxieties and insecurities onto the weakest target

- Sang in time to the music and so 200% wasnt his fault

- Lisa and the nasty crew are bringing down the morale of the group by acting like chimps

- Rodrigo has been heavily influenced and isnt that intelligent

[AhmedFan2004]

Originally posted by supergirthuk
BB's record skipped. Rodrigo's bit was missing. They will pass this.
Freddie still refused to listen, still messed up his part and still was smug and rude about it, annoying THE ENTIRE GROUP.

Even Rodrigo the nice cute innocent dude hates him.

Just get rid of him. We need BB10 to stay alive.

DO NOT KILL OFF THE SHOW. THE SHOW NEEDS SREE. THE FORUM DOES.

[Twilight]

Originally posted by AhmedFan2004
Originally posted by supergirthuk
BB's record skipped. Rodrigo's bit was missing. They will pass this.
Freddie still refused to listen, still messed up his part and still was smug and rude about it, annoying THE ENTIRE GROUP.

Even Rodrigo the nice cute innocent dude hates him.

Just get rid of him. We need BB10 to stay alive.

DO NOT KILL OFF THE SHOW. THE SHOW NEEDS SREE. THE FORUM DOES. GIVE IT UP:rolleyes:

[Stephanie]

god, ahmed.
your making people hate sree fans even more.

[Twilight]

Originally posted by stefani
god, ahmed.
your making people hate sree fans even more. Yeah Everytime he posts i hate Sree a little more.

[ILoveFreddie]

The reason Freddie said it 200% was not his fault was because he KNEW he'd get the blame for it.

[30stone]

Originally posted by AhmedFan2004
Originally posted by supergirthuk
BB's record skipped. Rodrigo's bit was missing. They will pass this.
Freddie still refused to listen, still messed up his part and still was smug and rude about it, annoying THE ENTIRE GROUP.

Even Rodrigo the nice cute innocent dude hates him.

Just get rid of him. We need BB10 to stay alive.

DO NOT KILL OFF THE SHOW. THE SHOW NEEDS SREE. THE FORUM DOES.

Freddie never messed up his part, he came in when he was meant to..

Lol, i kinda agree with these people, this much positive sree talk will make people dislike him more.

[blackadder]

Originally posted by Ketman
The HMs cannot be blamed for the disaster.

This is the version BB should have played over the sound system, sung here by Pavarotti, Carreras and Domingo:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDtcidMR_6I

That was the one they'd practised for. But the version played over the sound system was this one, sung by Pavarotti alone:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VATmgtmR5o4

In that version what should have been Rodrigo's part has been cut out altogether. The music skips straight to Freddie's solo.

BB is to blame, not the HMs.

I wonder if BB is going to own up to his/her error.
Giving the housemate a different backing track to the song
on their mp3 players, on a major task
is embarrassing. They should pass the task by default and
admit their error to the housemates.
Was it Karly or Halfwit who initially thought their
was a something missing in the part Rodrigo was suppose to play in the backing track?
That was before the blame game began.
though I cannot stand her,Karly had a suprisingly good singing voice ,not just the way she sang but
the way she pronounced the words.

[BGT-FAN!]

I dont think so,
Lisa :mad: when she said 'oh wow karly and rodrigo well done for learning it off the sheet' what a b*tch, she should get a job and grow up

[kisywisy]

Originally posted by Twilight
Originally posted by stefani
god, ahmed.
your making people hate sree fans even more. Yeah Everytime he posts i hate Sree a little more.

i know. it's making me pick up the phone and vote to evict sree more and more

[Beyoncé]

I think Halfwit was to blame, personally. It can't have been Rodrigo as he didn't even have chance to sing and mess it up before Halfwit began! Also, as far as I'm aware, and I am not an expert I admit, Karly also seemed to be in time with the music. I think Halfwit came in too early.

[blackadder]

Originally posted by Beyoncé
I think Halfwit was to blame, personally. It can't have been Rodrigo as he didn't even have chance to sing and mess it up before Halfwit began! Also, as far as I'm aware, and I am not an expert I admit, Karly also seemed to be in time with the music. I think Halfwit came in too early.

Why don't you read the rest of the thread.
I think it's been established that BB cocked up.
They used a different backing track to
the song on the mp3 player.
The backing track did not have rodrgio's
singing part.That's why, i think,
Rodrigo sounded so flat.
I think BB should admit their mistake
and pass the task as default.

[Beyoncé]

Originally posted by blackadder
Originally posted by Beyoncé
I think Halfwit was to blame, personally. It can't have been Rodrigo as he didn't even have chance to sing and mess it up before Halfwit began! Also, as far as I'm aware, and I am not an expert I admit, Karly also seemed to be in time with the music. I think Halfwit came in too early.

Why don't you read the rest of the thread.
I think it's been established that BB cocked up.
They used a different backing track to
the song on the mp3 player.
The backing track did not have rodrgio's
singing part.That's why, i think,
Rodrigo sounded so flat.
I think BB should admit their mistake
and pass the task as default.
Why don't I read the rest of the thread? Uhm, because I don't have to? Unless Big Brother admits they messed up the track it is nothing but mere speculation. You choose to believe BB messed it up, I choose to believe Halfwit messed it up. Unless there is evidence to the contrary, then that is what I will continue to believe - and reading the rest of this thread will not change that.

[blackadder]

Originally posted by Beyoncé
Originally posted by blackadder
Originally posted by Beyoncé
I think Halfwit was to blame, personally. It can't have been Rodrigo as he didn't even have chance to sing and mess it up before Halfwit began! Also, as far as I'm aware, and I am not an expert I admit, Karly also seemed to be in time with the music. I think Halfwit came in too early.

Why don't you read the rest of the thread.
I think it's been established that BB cocked up.
They used a different backing track to
the song on the mp3 player.
The backing track did not have rodrgio's
singing part.That's why, i think,
Rodrigo sounded so flat.
I think BB should admit their mistake
and pass the task as default.
Why don't I read the rest of the thread? Uhm, because I don't have to? Unless Big Brother admits they messed up the track it is nothing but mere speculation. You choose to believe BB messed it up, I choose to believe Halfwit messed it up. Unless there is evidence to the contrary, then that is what I will continue to believe - and reading the rest of this thread will not change that.
The evidence is in the rest of the thread.


Practised version:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MDtcidMR_6I

Backing track version

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VATmgtmR5o4

Hm version
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eZL1T0FP4Z0

[EzzaB]

I was confused
But it was Karly and Rodrigo who sang too slow :yuk:
Karly and Freddie r good singers :thumbs:

[Stephanie]

on bblb they said there were technical faults, causing them to not hear the first bit of music, that why it wasn't right.
and they have passed the task because of this and their effort.

[blackadder]

Originally posted by stefani
on bblb they said there were technical faults, causing them to not hear the first bit of music, that why it wasn't right.
and they have passed the task because of this and their effort.

I think that's a load of crap.
They played the wrong backing track.
At least they have still passed the task.
despite BB's cock up.

[Beastie]

yeah they did practise a lot! im glad they passed! i think rodrigo made some errors! but on a whole as an effort and the performance alltogether they did themselves proud!

[Stephanie]

Originally posted by blackadder
Originally posted by stefani
on bblb they said there were technical faults, causing them to not hear the first bit of music, that why it wasn't right.
and they have passed the task because of this and their effort.

I think that's a load of c**p.
They played the wrong backing track.
At least they have still passed the task.
despite BB's cock up.
i agree, they so played it on purpose to try and cause arguements.

[blackadder]

Originally posted by stefani
Originally posted by blackadder
Originally posted by stefani
on bblb they said there were technical faults, causing them to not hear the first bit of music, that why it wasn't right.
and they have passed the task because of this and their effort.

I think that's a load of c**p.
They played the wrong backing track.
At least they have still passed the task.
despite BB's cock up.
i agree, they so played it on purpose to try and cause arguements.

I think it's a genuine cock up
I've just had another listen
and Karly(great singing voice) is near bang on in her timing
in the intro. They had no problems hearing it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eZL1T0FP4Z0

[ILoveFreddie]

BBLB said it was a technical difficulty. So there.

[KillER]

on bblb george lamb said that "there was a slight technical error so the housemates were unable to hear the first part of the music"... but bb thought they tried their best so they passed that part of the task :)

[vgh50]

Did they pass or fail the singing part of the task?

BB seemed to skip over that...or did I miss something? :conf:

Did BB even say which parts of the task they passed and which they failed?