Should Karly & Lisa Be Punished?

[Benjamin]

I know they can be bitchey, but in all fairness they didn't actually discuss nominations, especially Karly. She just sat there listening.

[Shasown]

must have been my imagination then when she chimed into the conversation about the girls outside being bitches etc, she was there at the start of the discussion sat nodding while lisa was mouthing names or whatever with her mouth hidden and there at the end.

In my opinion that means she was involved in the discussion.

[Benjamin]

Originally posted by Shasown
must have been my imagination then when she chimed into the conversation about the girls outside being bitches etc, she was there at the start of the discussion sat nodding while lisa was mouthing names or whatever with her mouth hidden and there at the end.

In my opinion that means she was involved in the discussion.


what because she listened. Ha, well glad to see BB have some common sense.

[Shasown]

Well if she was as sweet and innocent as you obviously seem to think she is, why didnt she just say we shouldnt be talking nominations or simply got up and walked away. She was invilved in the discussion pure and simple

Same as being there with someone commtiing a crime, you dont distance yourself from the person and the crime, you get knicked as well

[Alf]

lisa should be made to dress up as karly for the day and vice versa

[Benjamin]

Originally posted by Shasown
Well if she was as sweet and innocent as you obviously seem to think she is, why didnt she just say we shouldnt be talking nominations or simply got up and walked away. She was invilved in the discussion pure and simple

Same as being there with someone commtiing a crime, you dont distance yourself from the person and the crime, you get knicked as well


Lol. a crime and noms are different.

Because maybe she didn't realise that they were directly talking about noms. If any of them had realised, they wouldn't ahve done it because they know BB will punish them.

[Shasown]

Oh do be serious, Lisa knew what she was doing thats why she hid her nouth in cupped hands, carly moved towards her to ensure she could see what lisa was mouthing

[Insane_Spirit]

Originally posted by Shasown
Oh do be serious, Lisa knew what she was doing thats why she hid her nouth in cupped hands, carly moved towards her to ensure she could see what lisa was mouthing


Sure, she can do no wrong with BB, or so it seems! I nearly choked laughing when she said, in all seriousness, that "she has never done anything to influence nominations"! :shrug:

[Shasown]

here turtle do me a favour mate go here and listen very carefully to what BB tells charlie, listen to the bit where he recites the discussion and what Karly actually said and then what charlie said.

http://www.channel4.com/bigbrother/video/ee9c7ef0c1a750affab211f1c8afb5c8/play.c4?anchor=comment

[Benjamin]

Yep I watched it. Charlie is being punished because he hinted at who he was nominating. Karly said that she had two now, but didn't hint at who, whereas Charlie was hinting about Rodrigo because of the petty row they had.

[Patrick]

Originally posted by Shasown
simply got up and walked away.


Yes, so when your mates are talking to you do you randomly get up and walk away on them??:rolleyes:

[Shasown]

Originally posted by pmccaff2009
Yes, so when your mates are talking to you do you randomly get up and walk away on them??:rolleyes:

Two answers:

a) What mates?

b) No thats why i have spent many a weekend in the company of Grampions finest, to have a chat with a wee man on the bench on the monday morning. Lifes like that!

Take the one that tickles you most

[28thapril]

They should be up instead of freddie and marcus:shrug:

[freesias]

Originally posted by Shasown
must have been my imagination then when she chimed into the conversation about the girls outside being bitches etc, she was there at the start of the discussion sat nodding while lisa was mouthing names or whatever with her mouth hidden and there at the end.

In my opinion that means she was involved in the discussion.

here here..
but lets get rid of kris this week and hopefully lisa will be up next week.:banana:

[mtt]

Yes, hopefully next week

[Sabrewulf238]

To be honest I've never seen them talking about nominations recently but I'd still punish them anyway. :devil:

[Peek]

They should be punished but next week. Don't want anyone up this week who might draw votes away from Kris.

[*teddybear*]

The public will punish them on Friday when they vote their mate Kris out. Shame we can't have a double eviction this week, weaken the Team Nasty well and good.:dance:

[Shasown]

Yeah hopefully BB gives them a pass or be nominated task after friday, or maybe they will think they are relatively safe and do the same again

[boomoo]

Lisa and Karly discuss noms evry week after an eviction.

When they say to each other there three obvious, Yes. and after that it will be harder because we will have to nom people we like.

They should have been up last week.
Get rid of Kris because there will be plenty of chances to get rid of Marcus.

[muchadoaboutnothing]

Originally posted by ukturtle
I know they can be bitchey, but in all fairness they didn't actually discuss nominations, especially Karly. She just sat there listening.

Karly is guilty by association, she could have told Lisa to be quite or better still she could have walked away. By remaining where she was she offered Lisa an audience and the opportunity to hold court at the bust stop. So both should have gone up for eviction.

[BigBummer]

Yes, so when your mates are talking to you do you randomly get up and walk away on them??:rolleyes:
Wow, I actually wasted 2 minutes registering to comment on this!

Of course you don't walk away from your friends when they are talking to you but in the BB house there are certain conversations which are obviously 'dangerous' and it is totally reasonable to explain yourself and walk away. Karly should ahve behaved like an adult.

[Striptease]

Lisa did discuss about the noms but im not quite sure if Karly did but I voted for both of them coz im a mofo hater