Lisa and Charlie not up for eviction even though both got most nominations.

[muchadoaboutnothing]

I apologise in advance if this is a repeat topic already posted. I have not seen one.

Apparently some of those HMs who said that they were not going to nominate actually did nominate and the reason they are up for eviction (all apart from Lisa and Rodrigo) is because they discussed nominations. And, as it turns out, Lisa and Charlie received the most nominations.

What another lucky escape for Lisa, she must be holding on to that horseshoe very tightly.

[june]

get lisa out next week i want kenneth out now :dance2:

[HuxleyPig]

Aren't Lisa and Rodrigo the only two to have nominated... so assuming Rodrigo nominated Lisa and Charlie and Lisa nominated Charlie... there should still be someone esle with a nomination. Lisa couldn't have nominated herself.

[WAYNEEBRUM]

Originally posted by HuxleyPig
Aren't Lisa and Rodrigo the only two to have nominated... so assuming Rodrigo nominated Lisa and Charlie and Lisa nominated Charlie... there should still be someone esle with a nomination. Lisa couldn't have nominated herself.
Wtf are u on about?

[amy-jayne]

Originally posted by HuxleyPig
Aren't Lisa and Rodrigo the only two to have nominated... so assuming Rodrigo nominated Lisa and Charlie and Lisa nominated Charlie... there should still be someone esle with a nomination. Lisa couldn't have nominated herself.
Plus I dont see why Lisa would have nominated Charlie!
Im guessing your right about who Rodrigo nominated, this is so confusing

[Benjamin]

They all nominated (not the newbies), but then BB voided their nominations because most of the house had discussed noms.

[mkdfan]

This is all very confusing, im sure we will find out tonight.

[AhmedFan2004]

So in the end they did nominate? Interesting.

[stickydatepudding]

The task meant that either the five new housemates or the nominated housemates would be up. As the five newbies failed their task, they went up instead of the nominated housemates. That's why Lisa and Charlie weren't put up. Then in addition to those five, the people who discussed nominations (including Charlie) went up as well as a punishment.

No one had their nominations voided as a punishment. The punishment was simply being put up. The reason the people who got the most nominations weren't put up was because of the task - it was either the five newbies *or* the nominees.

[mtt]

Originally posted by june
get lisa out next week i want kenneth out now :dance2:

agree

[davidalbert]

....bodes well for next weeks noms........

[IndigoJo]

So is discussing whether or not to Nominate considered "Discussing Nominations?"

I mean, they can say things like "Today is Nomination Day," and that's not a problem.

Or did some of them talk about who would be up or who would go???
:puzzled:

[Tulip]

Originally posted by muchadoaboutnothing
What another lucky escape for Lisa, she must be holding on to that horseshoe very tightly.

I think the old Mare is wearing them ....

:devil:

[TheOfficialAdam]

Charlie is up???

[HuxleyPig]

Originally posted by WAYNEEBRUM
Originally posted by HuxleyPig
Aren't Lisa and Rodrigo the only two to have nominated... so assuming Rodrigo nominated Lisa and Charlie and Lisa nominated Charlie... there should still be someone esle with a nomination. Lisa couldn't have nominated herself.
Wtf are u on about?

Well... its been stated that Charlie and Lisa got the most nominations and would have been up for the chop had there not been the twist or the housemates refusing to nominate.

But we know that only Rodrigo and Lisa nominated. So that leaves four nominations between the two of them. Assuming Charlie got a nomination from both Rodrigo and Lisa, and Rodrigo used his other nomination to nominate Lisa.. that leaves Lisa's second nomination unclarified.

Surely it can't be just Lisa and Charlie who got the most nominations. There has to be a third person involved. The numbers dont add up right.

[fitz2k2]

does lisa have 9 lives?

[AhmedFan2004]

Originally posted by stickydatepudding
The task meant that either the five new housemates or the nominated housemates would be up. As the five newbies failed their task, they went up instead of the nominated housemates. That's why Lisa and Charlie weren't put up. Then in addition to those five, the people who discussed nominations (including Charlie) went up as well as a punishment.

No one had their nominations voided as a punishment. The punishment was simply being put up. The reason the people who got the most nominations weren't put up was because of the task - it was either the five newbies *or* the nominees.
Correct.

It was Newbies vs Halfwit/Noirin in terms of being put up.
The punished HMs are a side issue to the above.

[AhmedFan2004]

Originally posted by HuxleyPig
Well... its been stated that Charlie and Lisa got the most nominations and would have been up for the chop had there not been the twist or the housemates refusing to nominate.

But we know that only Rodrigo and Lisa nominated. So that leaves four nominations between the two of them. Assuming Charlie got a nomination from both Rodrigo and Lisa, and Rodrigo used his other nomination to nominate Lisa.. that leaves Lisa's second nomination unclarified.

Surely it can't be just Lisa and Charlie who got the most nominations. There has to be a third person involved. The numbers dont add up right.
LOL you've got this all wrong.

The originals did end up nominating, see the other thread.

Lisa and Charlie were NEVER going to be up for eviction this week.

Because it was newbies vs Halfwit/Noirin.

The extra 6 people up for eviction is due to breaking rules.

[Saywhat]

What a fix!

[AhmedFan2004]

Originally posted by TheOfficialAdam
Charlie is up???
For rule breaking.

The only way to be put up this week was:

As a mission failing newb
Halfwit/Noirin
Rule breaking

Therefore Lisa would only be up via rule breaking. But she didn't brake rules.

[the_watcher87]

Originally posted by fitz2k2
does lisa have 9 lives?

she must, next week is the 9th eviction isn't it?

bye bye Lisa :D:D:D