I think Macedonia's biggest problem is always the way they decide to present their entries live.

2010: The female dancers/stripers looked so tacky and they didn't fit well with the song whatsoever.
2011: This was already horrible and the live performance made it even worse.
2012: Finally a nice performance from them! The staging was nothing special though.
2013: They couldn't do anything innovative here...
2014: Probably the worst live presentation in Eurovision ever. What shall I comment on? The outfit? The haircut? The dancer? The staging with the black and white colors? The backing singers joining in? The "choreography"? A very good and catchy song ruined by the terrible live performance. With a much better one this would have easily qualified.
2015: What were Blackstreet doing there? Seriously now, who came up with this idea? Not to mention the bland staging...
2016: It's okay. Fortunately, the song itself was already great so it didn't need great staging too.

I agree but the song remains so emotional and moving to me.

Mine are 2012>2013>2016>2015>2010>2014>2011. I did really like 2015 but his live performance was so disappointing, it kinda ruined the song

In my opinion it is:

2012>2016>2014>2010>2015>2013>2011

I find Macedonia a quite good and underrated country. I love my top 4, like my 5th very much, as you already know, I find my 6th mediocre and hate my last.

I never expected them to go through, but in my opinion it's one if the better Macedonian songs with Kaliopi 2012 and '16

Macedonia's 2013 entry really confuses me. I like both parts of the song, especially Lozano's. But put them together and what do you get? A mediocre mess. Not to mention the sudden ending... This was doomed to flop from the very beginning.

I agree about Israel, San Marino and Switzerland deserving to qualify, but Macedonia is a big guilty pleasure of mine. Although I wouldn't put it as a qualifier, it was good. And without Esma, it would have been even better

Switzerland was not something special for me personally but still, miles ahead Romania. Even Albania and Macedonia were better.

I didn't want them to qualify. There were so much better entries in Semi-Final 2 that deserved to make it and unfortunately, they didn't. Israel and San Marino were amazing, Bulgaria was also very good and a breath of fresh air.

I was glad that they got to the final in 2013, but I didn't expect them to do so well