I think David Archuleta will win. The producers are desperate for a successful male winner. As Red Moon has said Archuleta has the dollar factor written all over him. He appeals to tweenage/teenage girls, the so-called 'Archies Angels', who vote in their millions for him. He ticks all the boxes, he's young, good looking and has a clean cut 'boy next door' image that Americans love.

I personally find him quite bland and boring.

I hatee him :(

Besides, Carly'smindblowers and Kristy's Krushers are better =D

Jason, Carly & David C are the best.

I think David A gets a hard time from some people. I think he is good. Not great but he has that extra spark that others are missing.

Brooke and Kristy are just awful. Kristy more so. Awful, awful voice.

LOL Do you watch the show?

Obviously. :rolleyes:
He said Carly+David C were the best :P

Emmm..yes. Why do you ask?

He also said Jason was too.

And that Brooke and Kristy had awful voices :S

And? It's called an opinion.

Jason has a great voice and is one of the more all round talented contestants, along with David A and David C (Although David A's voice puts drags him down in my books.).

Brooks voice is one of the worst, and nothing special. Kristy's is just awful. She shouldnt have made the Top 24 IMO.

I don't think any of the top 7 have awful voices, it's a pretty strong line-up imo.

David cook and Carly shout way to much.

Never heard the judges saying that to anyone this year. It's something Simon is normally keen to pick up on.

1. Kristy Lee Cook - Think last week was good? Wait till you hear this one, got kinda blasted, but she was REALLY AMAZING. HONESTLY.

2. Syesha - She was good too, really powerful.

3. David Cook - His made me sad cos his brother.

4.Carly - OK WTF. She got blasted by this when she was MAAZING.

5. Jason - Oh DULLLLL.

6. David Archhrehrhd - That was crap. Once again OVERRATED by the judges. Leons was better, and thats saying something.

7. Brooke - No Brooke, just no. Sounded like all her other perofrmances.

B3 - Brooke,Kristy,Syesha.
HOME; Syesha

should be Brooke.

Carly Smithson - 10/10. Performance of the night in my opinion. Would rather have seen David C sing this, but Carly's reminded me a lot of when Kelly Clarkson sang it, and I think it was beautiful.

David Cook - 9/10. Amazing. I was expecting it to be so bad but it was in fact really good. Best male of the night by far.

Kristy Lee Cook - 9/10. Surprising eh? She's growing on me because she's the underdog, but I think she was actually incredible. Her best performance by far, even if you could hear the country in her voice.

Syesha Mercado - 8/10. Good, a lot of power, and although I think the song choice was good for her, I think it'll let her down.

Brooke White - 5/10. Okay. It was good, and up until near the end I was going to give her a seven, but it started to sound like all her other performances. Also, she messed up on the piano at the end.

David Archuleta - 4/10. It got dull and repetitive. His voice is annoying, the song choice was bad (Leon was better) and he sounded like Kermit from the Muppets.

Jason Castro - 3/10. Again, I found it boring. I can't believe he's still there, and should've gone way before Ramiele or Michael.

Bottom 3;; Jason, Brooke, Syesha.

Did they all have to sing Mariah Carey songs? Harsh.

1.David Cook-Although I know how good he is at adapting songs to fit his own style even I was worried by this song choice,there was no need to be.I thought he was brilliant, the arrangement and his voice just everything worked. 9/10

2.David Archuleta-I thought he sung most of the song really well but he came a bit unstuck with the ending where he tried to shift things around too much.I'd like him to try something a bit different next week as he's done ballads for quite a lot of the competition.8/10

3.Carly Smithson-I was really hoping that she would nail it but she didn't quite do that for me.Don't get me wrong, I thought she did a very good job but I wasn't really wowed.8/10

4.Kristy Lee Cook-It started out kinda rough for me as Kristy's not got a very good lower range but once she got into higher parts of the song I though she sung it really well.7/10

5.Jason Castro-This turned out better than I expected, I had this down as week Jason would really struggle but he put his own slant on the song and I thought he did a decent job.6.5/10

6.Syesha Mercado-Here's the deal, Syesha's got one of the most powerful voices in the competition but I think she really overdid things this week.At times I couldn't really understand what she was singing and it just turned a bit screechy.6/10

7.Brooke White-She's obviously not got the vocal skills to really belt out the song like Mariah but she did convey the emotion of the song, just a shame that she sounded so out of tune.5/10

Kristy Lee Cook is favourite to be the Top Female

=O

It's a difficult one to predict with the girls, all of them have been in the bottom two at least once and most likely the bottom 3 will be all girls again this week.

We thought that last week htough.

I reckon it COULD be a Brooke,Syesha,Jason, but more likely Brooke Syesha and Kristy.

I wouldn't be surprised to see Carly in the bottom 3 again despite a good performance.

Yeah I agree, although Id put money on Brooke or Syesha leaving.

I think those two will be the bottom 2, hopefully with Brooke going.

OMGOMGOMG


[spoil]KRISTY LEE COOK WENT[/spoil]

SORRY BILLY :(

Can i ust say that based on last night that was definitely the wrong choice

Ah well.
No big loss (:

She was growing on me.
It'd been nice to see her stay.
&it was the wrong decision.
But I don't think she deserved to stay any longer than. a couple of a weeks ago =S

Just typical that when she started to give better performances that she goes.