Originally Posted by RileyH (Post 10523400)

Geoff

I've nommed Geoff during both of my rounds, yet he's been saved for some reason -glares @ Morgan/Epic- and I don't know why. I didn't dislike him in TDI, he was just so basic and the ~PARTY BOY~ character just isn't my type of character. And then he got with Bridgette. I actually really like them together, and there's no denying that they are the IT couple of Total Drama, having been together since TDI. I actually think sending them out early in TDA was a great idea, and they excelled hosting Aftermath. That's why I think it was a silly idea sending Bridgette into TDWT but then I guess they needed some story. Bridgette's shtick of 'I have a boyfriend!' became tiring quick, despite kissing Alejandro and then profusely apologizing to Geoff about it and idk it was just so BORING. And then he came back for RR for some reason, not even with Bridgette so idk what the thought was behind that and I always forget he was even there even though he won made it to the finals. Idk he should've been cut ages ago so bye.

Originally Posted by Epic. (Post 10523321)

44. Sky
https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/...20151128200948

Figures that I've had to cut both of PI's Final Two. Anyway, Sky, like Shawn, is someone who I SORT OF like, in fact considerably more than i do Shawn, but she sadly pales in comparison to all the other nominees. And even though she's pretty by-the-book in personality, still a good, even great character in my eyes.

She's most well-known for the will-they/won't they/absolutely never should they pairing with Dave, which got a lot of backlash, but I can't really gather why. Yes, Sky takes advantage of Dave and isn't honest with him, and it does cause him to act way too over-the-top, but I found all of that really entertaining, and livened up an already fairly lively season. Sky is manipulative, somewhat selfish, and can get critically competitive, but that doesn't make her a BAD person. Here was a protagonist with lots of goals and visions to empathize with, but for the first time in the show, was stomping on others in her way to get there. That makes for a great character. Now granted I don't think Sky was a GREAT character. Up until Dave is out, she does sort of rely on him to make a presence, and even after he's out, she relies on Sugar, but both of those interactions are among my favorites in the show and Sky worked as a great straight-man to the two craziest members of the cast. When I rewatch PI, the unpredictability of Sky being slightly too cutthroat kind of loses its edge and she ends up looking like a pretty basic character, but she's simple enough to be worth tolerating and most of the time enjoying. But when a noms pool has Duncan and Geoff and Sugar and Stephanie and Carrie and Devin and Dwayne to choose from, it's suddenly easier for me to cut her.

Sky Confessional: To eat that entire cup (of barf) and NOT? WIN?! UGH! I HAVE *NEVER* BEEN THIS *ANGRY* BEFORE! :oh:
Dave Confessional: Heh heh. Didn't win immunity but I DID beat SKY. This is the perfect time to rub it in a little :smug: . Aw yeah :smug: . She's gonna fall in love with me riiiiight now :smug: .
Dave: Second place to ME. BOOM! :dance: Totally did better than yoooooo-uuuu :smug: Ha ha. Ah, how SEXY am I now? :dazzler: Bet you wish I was still your boyyyyfriend! :smug:
Sky: UURGH!
You were NEVER my boyfriend! :oh:
!!
And you will never BE my boyfriend! :oh:
!!
And you have no shot of BEATING *OR* DATING ME! GOT IT! :oh::mad::oh::mad: *gets in Dave's face*
Dave: Mm-hmm :( *collapses to the floor*
Sky: Uuuugh :hmph: *walks off*
Max: HA HA. Look at his FACE! :evilgrin:
Dave:
https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/...20161120165102

<3<3<3<3<3<3<3

Originally Posted by montblanc (Post 10523436)

i loved Sky

the first official female winner :love:

Originally Posted by montblanc (Post 10523436)

i loved Sky

the first official female winner :love:

Originally Posted by Epic. (Post 10523437)

...in your opinion :hee:

Originally Posted by Blurryface (Post 10523439)

Gwen and Heather say hello

Originally Posted by Epic. (Post 10523440)

The whole winner debate is pretty common and kind of bugs me, but I personally base it on which ending makes the most sense from an editing and narrative point of view, meaning I'd say Owen, Beth, Heather, Cameron, Zoey, Shawn, and the Police Cadets

Originally Posted by RileyH (Post 10523443)

I just use the winner from whichever ending I saw =/