olly, joe and lucie.

I think Lucie was amazing last night but so was Rachel and Joe.
Voted Rachel because she's my fave though :D

Lucie tonight.

Lucie was outstanding, one of the best performances ever on X Factor for me aswell, and I think she's now set herself apart from the whole Leona comparison. I personally think it was better than Leonas Summertime.

Lucie, simply amazing definately showing her potential.

john and edward by far!

Im positive you are on a windup mission...


And Danyl and Lucie for me. Voted Danyl.

I think simon is giving lucie critism because shes a threat to danyl..

nope just being honest in my opinion but is it wrong to say a tiny part of me wants to wind up the haters? lol

Im thinking he does it because he wants her to try really hard and show the potential she has and shine.

Yup. Thats what I think too.

Simon is the only one of the judges who seems to want the most talented person to win...rather than it having to be one of his own acts.

Really? Personally I think he's absolutely forcing Danyl and to a lesser extent Jamie down our throats, he really wants to win. Having said that, he doesn't try to undermine the other judges acts with negative comments on good performances. Dannii, Cheryl and Louis do that.

Yeah but see the thing is...we only see simon criticising Lucie...we dont know what he has said to his own acts through the week...he could well have been going off it all week with them. He always admits if someone does good, and doesnt make snide comments to try and undermine the contestants like the others do.

Plus, he sent his own act home before...which kind of proves he isnt as bothered as the others about winning it.

Isn't that what judging is all about though? There's always something to perfect regardless of how good it was. Like the whole likeability thing with Danyl. it WAS true, and had they not have pulled him up about it it would be affecting his chances.

agreed :D

hello jessica :xyxwave:

no one has voted for lloyd.