Basically, both. She was given an offer she could only refuse.

Gary obviously. It'll be nice to see him every weekend, though I won't want to go out at the weekend during winter at all. I hope he proves that he's not dull like all you lot seem to think.

TULISA. Na na naiiiiiii

http://www.thisismax.net/wp-content/...PG.display.jpg

kelly rowland!!!
she deserves it cos shes been in a group and solo so she knows her music, and is lovely :)

gary barlow seems a bit boring
tulisa.. just a mess

Tulisa - just think she will be good, but will reserve judgement till I actually watch it.

Not keen on Kelly, think they could have found someone better.

I would have liked to see Stacey Solomon as a judge, she's lovely and has lived the dream....but don't think they will ever go for an ex contestant !

Katy Perry had promise also.

Louis is gonna be slaughtered again this year, they will give him the crappest category and he will pick **** acts AGAIN!