Why do people find it hard to like Madonna and Gaga. Christ. -__-

I'll give her credit where it's due "Ray of Light" was great but she needs to stop the phase she's going through now. No one wants to see a 50 odd year old gyrating with a member of N Sync.

Well she isn't in her next album, she is working with up and coming producers on her next album. Not mainstream successes.

To be honest Music and Confessions on a Dance Floor are also both fantastic albums by her.

This, though I hate her other stuff :laugh:

And Niall/Harry don't make me listen to her older albums I've heard most of it and I don't like it.

Harry don't get sucked in to defending Madonna. After nearly 30 years she doesnt need defending. And anybody who doesnt respect her by now never will so just leave them to it.

And this thread is about Gaga.

Her older stuff (prior to Hard Candy) is brilliant, but her new stuff is just garbage. 4 Minutes is proof of this.

subjective opinion.

get back on topic. Ta.

Comparing Gaga to Madonna is the thread's subject.

That sort of is the topic

From what I've listened to her, I love her more modern albums. Ray of Light, Music, American Life, Confessions on a Dance Floor are all some of my favourite albums ever now. :lovedup: I actually love Hard Candy too though not as much as the other four. :blush2:

And I won't. I'm here if you change your mind though. :bigsmile:

no the topic is not "what do you think of Madonna"

Please go re-read the OP.

Hard Candy is very underated. If you drelve into her backlog she has great demos from the Hard Candy/Celbration era as well.

It's about Gaga and Madonna. God forbid somebody post an opinion on one of them.

The thread question is about GAGA.

jesus fcking christ

"Is she asking for the "Madonna copycat" comments". Thus, discuss the comparisons between them. Hard to do without mentioning Madonna.

jesus fcking christ.

This thread is about how Madonna and other influential figures from this and last century have borrowed heavily from Our Great Sport.

What DO you want me to write? The thread is about MADONNA and GAGA. Writing an opinion about one of the artists in the thread title is hardly off topic.

i think you'll find this is my thread and it's now about sausages.

Shaun, you're such a shit stirrer :idc:

whatever, Mary

hopefully at some point you'll actually bother to address teh Ops question. Thats usually how thread topics work.

Like this;

my opinion is that it depends on what kind of book it turns out to be. Intimate and personal pictures is not really what sex was about. It was deliberately provocative and designed to press all kinds of buttons. That was very much her mo back then and nobody will ever do it to better effect.

Well if thats the case, I like sausages...