I don't think his song choices are THAT bad, but like I said if he's for the overs then he might have some good advice for them. That or pick Rod Stewart :joker: what a legend he is.

He seems very awkward.

His song choices are good though. IMO.

Elton John would be better. :blush:

:shocked: Imagine Elton.

Doesn't Elton hate the show :joker:

http://www.metro.co.uk/showbiz/84437...ing-music-rant

Not really his song choices I just don't think he's very good live, like Lucas said he's really awkward and seems to find it hard to articulate himself

The same Elton that slates the show if he gets the chance? :tongue:

Yeah :blush2: we can win him over with millions and millions

That's cos he's old :sad:

I think he'd be amazing as a judge! :amazed:

That's no excuse :nono:

They should have the 4 main judges, then a guest judge every week on the live show, who can give unbias criticism:amazed:

New X-Factor UK line up:

Elton John, Paul McCartney, Mick Jagger, Adele


It's confirmed.

That would be sensational.

You won't be saying that when your old mister!

Niamh will give him pointers on how to deal with being old.

And that line-up would be so stunning. No Gary *******ing Barlow.

-wonders what that c word is.-

That would be amazing! :banana:

No http://www.planetsmilies.com/smilies...scared0005.gif

Wonder if Cher Lloyd would have got through if that was the case.

You make it sound like I was saying your opinion was wrong. Coming across a bit passive aggressive.

Cauliflower. x

white noise

Erm, yeah, cool.

why are you making accusations? describing someone as passive aggressive is very passive aggressive.